![]() |
|
Feel The Byrne - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Feel The Byrne (/showthread.php?tid=17231) |
RE: Feel The Byrne - Shabby Russian - 05-06-2021 (05-06-2021, 10:09 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The foundation and legacy of Attlee's Government was the postwar consensus, the provision of services (eg the NHS) might have differed from the originally conceived idea by Beveridge in its implementation but the core of that Government was built upon the expansion of the liberal welfare state (first implemented by Churchill no less as a Liberal minister) into its modern counterpart using the blueprints of another liberal (Beveridge) who's policies were consensus within the war ministry (including the Tory and Liberal Ministers) and the economic foundation was built upon the ideas of Keynesian economics and the need to build a budget surplus to bring national debt under control. Hmm i'm not sure i agree. The amount of nationalisation introduced by the Atlee Govt does not suggest they adopted liberal ideals. And the lurch to the left , i wasn't aware they did, actually proved very popular with the voters. The number of votes the Labour Party received in that election, to this day remains the highest number any party has ever received in the UK at a General Election. Just the vagaries of our electoral system saw them lose office. RE: Feel The Byrne - Borin' Baggie - 05-06-2021 The nationalised industries under Attlee were the same ones that the Liberal Party were proposing to be nationalised at the same time: rail, coal, steel and electricity. And, more to the point, they were either deemed critical national infrastructure due to the fallout from the war (coal and steel) or were natural monopolies (rail (before WW2 there was a big risk of a monopoly forming what with the Big 4 becoming closer and closer on top of there being no external private sector investment into rail aside from the Big 4 as there was during the golden age of rail) and electricity). It's hardly akin to the slapdash, poorly planned market interference and nationalisation of later Labour governments into things like the automotive or aerospace industries and the industrial sector was predominantly still privatised (one of the reason Leicester, Coventry and Birmingham didn't economically collapse immediately postwar despite the restrictions on those three cities' service economies). The ultimate basis for the economic policies of Attlee's government was Keynesian economics, a fundamentally liberal economic system and something that was later adopted by the Tories until Thatcher came in. And the vagaries of the electoral system caused the collapse in 1950 where the Conservative vote was significantly lower than their share of seats. In 51, in spite of Labour getting more votes it was actually more proportional to the vote share, one of the big issues for Labour in 1951 was Liberal Party votes swinging heavily to the Conservatives due to the worry about the lurch leftwards and the instability of the party with a slim majority due to factional infighting, instead of those Liberal voters being more evenly split. RE: Feel The Byrne - Shabby Russian - 05-06-2021 (05-06-2021, 11:25 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The nationalised industries under Attlee were the same ones that the Liberal Party were proposing to be nationalised at the same time: rail, coal, steel and electricity. And, more to the point, they were either deemed critical national infrastructure due to the fallout from the war (coal and steel) or were natural monopolies (rail (before WW2 there was a big risk of a monopoly forming what with the Big 4 becoming closer and closer on top of there being no external private sector investment into rail aside from the Big 4 as there was during the golden age of rail) and electricity). It's hardly akin to the slapdash, poorly planned market interference and nationalisation of later Labour governments into things like the automotive or aerospace industries and the industrial sector was predominantly still privatised (one of the reason Leicester, Coventry and Birmingham didn't economically collapse immediately postwar despite the restrictions on those three cities' service economies). I still would maintain that the legislative programme enacted by the Atlee Govt would be described more accurately as socialist rather than liberal but it really doesn't bother me one way or the other. It was a necessary and transformative programme, and if you want to describe it as liberal , then fair play to the liberals. And it still remains the fact that in the three General Elections of 1945, 1950 and 1951, Labour increased the number of people voting for them in each successive election, suggesting a high level of satisfaction from the electorate. RE: Feel The Byrne - Protheroe - 05-06-2021 (05-06-2021, 08:35 AM)Logic1 Wrote: No, because out of all of those 6 things, the Tories only do number 6 and I’m not a big fan of number 6 anyway but you have to do it to get elected. You must be looking at a different list. This current lot are to the left of Blair. |