WBAUnofficial
Red cards in the first half of matches - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Red cards in the first half of matches (/showthread.php?tid=15740)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Red cards in the first half of matches - Cheshire East Baggie - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 09:38 AM)wba13 Wrote: Thinking logically about Ajayi sending off. Yes it probably was right but why don’t the FA have a sin bin for ten or 15 mins. Does anyone know if Vydra would have scored no is the answer. We have now lost Ajayi for 3 and a half matches for what was a minor incident, so I believe a fairer way would be to have a sin bin which would give the opposition 10 or 15 mins advantage not 60 mins and 3 matches for something which may not have happened ie vydra scores.

Surely it's only a 1 match ban for that?


RE: Red cards in the first half of matches - strawman - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 09:38 AM)wba13 Wrote: Thinking logically about Ajayi sending off. Yes it probably was right but why don’t the FA have a sin bin for ten or 15 mins. Does anyone know if Vydra would have scored no is the answer. We have now lost Ajayi for 3 and a half matches for what was a minor incident, so I believe a fairer way would be to have a sin bin which would give the opposition 10 or 15 mins advantage not 60 mins and 3 matches for something which may not have happened ie vydra scores.

The offence is not denying a goal but denying an obvious goal scoring opportunity so it did happen. Highly debatable that it is 'obvious' that far from goal though. I think it's just a 1 match ban


RE: Red cards in the first half of matches - Duffers - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 09:48 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(02-21-2021, 09:38 AM)wba13 Wrote: Thinking logically about Ajayi sending off. Yes it probably was right but why don’t the FA have a sin bin for ten or 15 mins. Does anyone know if Vydra would have scored no is the answer. We have now lost Ajayi for 3 and a half matches for what was a minor incident, so I believe a fairer way would be to have a sin bin which would give the opposition 10 or 15 mins advantage not 60 mins and 3 matches for something which may not have happened ie vydra scores.

Surely it's only a 1 match ban for that?

It is.


RE: Red cards in the first half of matches - Pragmatist - 02-21-2021

I’ve always liked the sin bin idea for various offences. Rugby does it well.


RE: Red cards in the first half of matches - Duffers - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 09:52 AM)strawman Wrote:
(02-21-2021, 09:38 AM)wba13 Wrote: Thinking logically about Ajayi sending off. Yes it probably was right but why don’t the FA have a sin bin for ten or 15 mins. Does anyone know if Vydra would have scored no is the answer. We have now lost Ajayi for 3 and a half matches for what was a minor incident, so I believe a fairer way would be to have a sin bin which would give the opposition 10 or 15 mins advantage not 60 mins and 3 matches for something which may not have happened ie vydra scores.

The offence is not denying a goal but denying an obvious goal scoring opportunity so it did happen. Highly debatable that it is 'obvious' that far from goal though. I think it's just a 1 match ban

There were so many possible outcomes - Vydra could have mis-controlled and over ran it, Ajayi could have recovered and tackled, Vydra could have gone through and missed, Johnstone could have saved... or he could have scored.

This is why Ajayi was so stupid to stick has hand out and stop the ball. There was no need. Absolute worse case scenario is that they score and you have 60 or so minutes with 11 men to try and equalise.


RE: Red cards in the first half of matches - baggie_ray - 02-21-2021

Duffers Wrote:
strawman Wrote:
wba13 Wrote:Thinking logically about Ajayi sending off. Yes it probably was right but why don’t the FA have a sin bin for ten or 15 mins. Does anyone know if Vydra would have scored no is the answer. We have now lost Ajayi for 3 and a half matches for what was a minor incident, so I believe a fairer way would be to have a sin bin which would give the opposition 10 or 15 mins advantage not 60 mins and 3 matches for something which may not have happened ie vydra scores.

The offence is not denying a goal but denying an obvious goal scoring opportunity so it did happen. Highly debatable that it is 'obvious' that far from goal though. I think it's just a 1 match ban

There were so many possible outcomes - Vydra could have mis-controlled and over ran it, Ajayi could have recovered and tackled, Vydra could have gone through and missed, Johnstone could have saved... or he could have scored.

This is why Ajayi was so stupid to stick has hand out and stop the ball. There was no need. Absolute worse case scenario is that they score and you have 60 or so minutes with 11 men to try and equalise.

I saw it as Ajayi "instinctively" stopping a ball that was going past him with his hand, rather than him assessing the situation and thinking "I'd best hand ball this".

Reactions can take over players.  Such as when a player goes diving in to retrieve the ball after they mis-control it.


RE: Red cards in the first half of matches - Brentbaggie - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 10:06 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
Duffers Wrote:
strawman Wrote:
wba13 Wrote:Thinking logically about Ajayi sending off. Yes it probably was right but why don’t the FA have a sin bin for ten or 15 mins. Does anyone know if Vydra would have scored no is the answer. We have now lost Ajayi for 3 and a half matches for what was a minor incident, so I believe a fairer way would be to have a sin bin which would give the opposition 10 or 15 mins advantage not 60 mins and 3 matches for something which may not have happened ie vydra scores.

The offence is not denying a goal but denying an obvious goal scoring opportunity so it did happen. Highly debatable that it is 'obvious' that far from goal though. I think it's just a 1 match ban

There were so many possible outcomes - Vydra could have mis-controlled and over ran it, Ajayi could have recovered and tackled, Vydra could have gone through and missed, Johnstone could have saved... or he could have scored.

This is why Ajayi was so stupid to stick has hand out and stop the ball. There was no need. Absolute worse case scenario is that they score and you have 60 or so minutes with 11 men to try and equalise.

I saw it as Ajayi "instinctively" stopping a ball that was going past him with his hand, rather than him assessing the situation and thinking "I'd best hand ball this".

Reactions can take over players.  Such as when a player goes diving in to retrieve the ball after they mis-control it.

This +1.  If he acted logically he doesn't stick out his hand.  It's instinctive, albeit instinctively mistaken.


RE: Red cards in the first half of matches - chasetownbaggie - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 10:37 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: This +1.  If he acted logically he doesn't stick out his hand.  It's instinctive, albeit instinctively mistaken.

Did he 'stick out his hand' though? Undoubtedly the ball hit his hand and we gained an advantage from it, but to my eyes his hand was moving in a natural arc seen when a player is running. It happened so quickly.


RE: Red cards in the first half of matches - Shabby Russian - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 10:02 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(02-21-2021, 09:52 AM)strawman Wrote:
(02-21-2021, 09:38 AM)wba13 Wrote: Thinking logically about Ajayi sending off. Yes it probably was right but why don’t the FA have a sin bin for ten or 15 mins. Does anyone know if Vydra would have scored no is the answer. We have now lost Ajayi for 3 and a half matches for what was a minor incident, so I believe a fairer way would be to have a sin bin which would give the opposition 10 or 15 mins advantage not 60 mins and 3 matches for something which may not have happened ie vydra scores.

The offence is not denying a goal but denying an obvious goal scoring opportunity so it did happen. Highly debatable that it is 'obvious' that far from goal though. I think it's just a 1 match ban

There were so many possible outcomes - Vydra could have mis-controlled and over ran it, Ajayi could have recovered and tackled, Vydra could have gone through and missed, Johnstone could have saved... or he could have scored.

This is why Ajayi was so stupid to stick has hand out and stop the ball. There was no need. Absolute worse case scenario is that they score and you have 60 or so minutes with 11 men to try and equalise.
Given our finishing yesterday maybe he gained us a point.


RE: Red cards in the first half of matches - Baggie_Nick - 02-21-2021

(02-20-2021, 04:01 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(02-20-2021, 04:00 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(02-20-2021, 03:57 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(02-20-2021, 03:56 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(02-20-2021, 03:51 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: At least everyone got a stiffy over how much the know about football.

You get your kicks where you can these days.

At least no bullying happened  Big Grin

There’s still time.

Of course there is, you stupid little cunt. 

Big Grin

You missed the 'bald-headed' bit out.

Oh, sorry, that was FF's tirade. I lose track these days...  Big Grin