WBAUnofficial
Big Dave - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Big Dave (/showthread.php?tid=15575)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Big Dave - Wotty - 02-08-2021

I haven't seen Doncaster play this season.

Are they playing out from the back as much as he tried to have us doing?


RE: Big Dave - SW4Baggie - 02-08-2021

(02-08-2021, 03:12 PM)Madness Wrote: If we would have kept Darren Moore we would have gone up. Then Villa would have had another season in the Championship and we could have been still ahead of them

No we wouldn't... the way we were playing and the atmosphere behind the scenes between Jones an the players would have seen us probably drop out of the playoffs!

Had Barnes not been recalled I think we'd have gone up, but we'd have had a bloody ENORMOUS amount of work to do last year!


RE: Big Dave - Atomic - 02-08-2021

Appleton would be on my shortlist as well together with the ridiculously under rated Nigel Pearson.

Any of those three I'd be happy with next season.

Not an exclusive list though, there are others out there that could do a good job for us.


RE: Big Dave - albion_pigeon - 02-08-2021

(02-08-2021, 03:18 PM)Wotty Wrote: I haven't seen Doncaster play this season.

Are they playing out from the back as much as he tried to have us doing?

Not sure

https://www.drfc-vsc.co.uk/index.php?PHPSESSID=b625e23b7a1558d7a5a154ed743c9c88&topic=279583.0


RE: Big Dave - SW4Baggie - 02-08-2021

(02-08-2021, 03:27 PM)Atomic Wrote: Appleton would be on my shortlist as well together with the ridiculously under rated Nigel Pearson.

Any of those three I'd be happy with next season.

Not an exclusive list though, there are others out there that could do a good job for us.

I think managers can be roughly split into firefighters and builders. Some have immediate impacts which wanes, and some need a bit of time, but will generally leave the club in a better position longer term. We probably need the latter as we've been treading water for a while and for me this isn't Pearson. 

Pearson would have been a contender for the job when Fat Sam was got it, but giving him the ropes this summer would be a massive risk IMO.

We need someone to take the sting out of things, as we're seeing with Sam, I think a lot of this squad is mentally exhausted, and isn't going to react well to another headcase.


RE: Big Dave - Gzbaggy - 02-08-2021

(02-08-2021, 03:27 PM)Atomic Wrote: Appleton would be on my shortlist as well together with the ridiculously under rated Nigel Pearson.

Any of those three I'd be happy with next season.

Not an exclusive list though, there are others out there that could do a good job for us.

I like Nigel Pearson, intelligent and no-nonsense but there must be a reason he does not stay anywhere for very long. Did you see him on the EFL show on Saturday? He does not look too well

I am coming round to the idea of Appleton for next season has done well at Lincoln and I suspect he could get us Rogers and Johnson for next season. He also should know who the players are in League one who could make the step up (the Watkins, Maddisons, Toneys and Wilsons of this world who we ignore so we can take players who are experienced and past it)


RE: Big Dave - Squid - 02-08-2021

I would also say, never ever forget the work DM did in getting an apparently toxic* squad turned around and actually looking decent with pretty much minimal support or input. Barnes was going to Leeds. Gayle absolutely did not want to come. A chunk of the players wanted to go to PL clubs. DM got them all playing and playing together.



*In the words of Mozza, who reckoned the dressing room was foul in 16/17 and that squad was doomed. I'm not so sure, frankly.

(02-08-2021, 04:12 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(02-08-2021, 01:35 PM)Duffers Wrote: No.

He’s doing brilliantly at Donny, but he couldn’t get a squad containing Barnes, Gayle, Rodriguez, etc up. I don’t accept the “Graeme Jones” excuse either. Moore hired him and should have kept him in check.

Hope he takes Doncaster up though.

Quick question Duffers. How are you supposed to get a team up when you are not given a chance to see the play offs? He had zero chance of getting us promoted! We were on a poor run but 4th in the league. Who's to say if he hadn't jettisoned Jones he would'nt have achieved promotion through the play offs.its like saying a snooker player failed to make a 180 break without the blue ball on the table. Saying he didn't get us up is hypothetical.
 

Fwiw I don't think he would come back in the current circumstances with the same owners and personnel. He's too proud a man. I wouldn't rule him out in the longer term though. 

Love the bloke to bits. Just wish he'd have taken Shan on instead of Jones. It could have all been so different.

He got offered the chance to sack off Jones and keep his job. He said no, sadly. I agree with your last line.


RE: Big Dave - Peachy - 02-08-2021

(02-08-2021, 01:35 PM)Duffers Wrote: No.

He’s doing brilliantly at Donny, but he couldn’t get a squad containing Barnes, Gayle, Rodriguez, etc up. I don’t accept the “Graeme Jones” excuse either. Moore hired him and should have kept him in check.

Hope he takes Doncaster up though.

Quick question Duffers. How are you supposed to get a team up when you are not given a chance to see the play offs? He had zero chance of getting us promoted! We were on a poor run but 4th in the league. Who's to say if he hadn't jettisoned Jones he would'nt have achieved promotion through the play offs.its like saying a snooker player failed to make a 180 break without the blue ball on the table. Saying he didn't get us up is hypothetical.
 

Fwiw I don't think he would come back in the current circumstances with the same owners and personnel. He's too proud a man. I wouldn't rule him out in the longer term though. 

Love the bloke to bits. Just wish he'd have taken Shan on instead of Jones. It could have all been so different.


RE: Big Dave - Birdman1811 - 02-08-2021

I'm a fan of Big Dave and felt he was hard done to here really, however he was too weak to Jones and that sealed his fate.

However, no way should you ever go back like that, I wish it has worked out, he'd taken Shan on and we beat those cumts to promotion.


RE: Big Dave - Duffers - 02-08-2021

(02-08-2021, 04:12 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(02-08-2021, 01:35 PM)Duffers Wrote: No.

He’s doing brilliantly at Donny, but he couldn’t get a squad containing Barnes, Gayle, Rodriguez, etc up. I don’t accept the “Graeme Jones” excuse either. Moore hired him and should have kept him in check.

Hope he takes Doncaster up though.

Quick question Duffers. How are you supposed to get a team up when you are not given a chance to see the play offs? He had zero chance of getting us promoted! We were on a poor run but 4th in the league. Who's to say if he hadn't jettisoned Jones he would'nt have achieved promotion through the play offs.its like saying a snooker player failed to make a 180 break without the blue ball on the table. Saying he didn't get us up is hypothetical.
 

Fwiw I don't think he would come back in the current circumstances with the same owners and personnel. He's too proud a man. I wouldn't rule him out in the longer term though. 

Love the bloke to bits. Just wish he'd have taken Shan on instead of Jones. It could have all been so different.

You’re right in that we’re dealing with hypotheticals here. He could have gone on some fantastic run that catapulted us back into the automatic picture... but sadly results leading up to his sacking suggest we were heading in the opposite direction.

We’ll never know for sure.