RE: Robinson... - SW4Baggie - 01-18-2021
(01-18-2021, 03:43 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I still think if Pete hadn't started sulking that season we'd have got very close to a Europa League place.
For all the impact Lukaku had, Pete was still the key man... and as has been done to death, our best form came with Long up top and Wingie free to do as he pleased.
Wigan and Swansea winning the cups meant we'd have had to finish 5th that season however... would be just our luck to get 6th and not qualify!
Can't help but think we'd have won those dour home defeats to Wigan, Swansea and the standard Pulising.
RE: Robinson... - Shabby Russian - 01-18-2021
(01-18-2021, 03:45 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Losing Pete and Gera together ruined everything, especially since we decided not to replace them in the January window, a big, and stupid mistake.
This all day long.
Did for Clarke. People were able to point to a poor second half of our best ever premiership season, but given the circumstances not sure how he was supposed to do. better.
RE: Robinson... - Birdman1811 - 01-18-2021
That front 4, Long as the focal point. Mozza running behind linking the attack to the midfield. Gera the intelligent wide player, building play and of course his threat from distance, and of course Wingie just bullying the fuck out of full backs and scoring once the chance fell.
Then we could bring on Lukaku for Long to make tired centre backs sit and cry on the pitch.
RE: Robinson... - Super_Slav - 01-18-2021
(01-18-2021, 03:50 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: That front 4, Long as the focal point. Mozza running behind linking the attack to the midfield. Gera the intelligent wide player, building play and of course his threat from distance, and of course Wingie just bullying the fuck out of full backs and scoring once the chance fell.
Then we could bring on Lukaku for Long to make tired centre backs sit and cry on the pitch.
Add to the mix the likes of Brunt, Mulumbu and Yacob. We had a fine side for a period of time
RE: Robinson... - Belfastbaggie - 01-18-2021
(01-18-2021, 03:39 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (01-18-2021, 03:38 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (01-18-2021, 03:36 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (01-18-2021, 03:34 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I'd take a Fortune right now.
Well he was actually more key than Wingie in the 5-1. Wolves didn't get the ball off him all game long, was like an adult playing a bunch of primary school kids.
We really did take for granted the strike force under Clark...
Lukaku, Long, Wingie, Fortune and Rosenberg.
If we had Rosenberg now he'd probably be first choice
Best set of strikers we've had at this level by far,
Strangely enough, our best season at this level too.
I often think that had we beaten Chelsea that time at Stamford Bridge Clarkey would have had a far more successful end to his time with us...
RE: Robinson... - MancBaggie - 01-18-2021
(01-18-2021, 03:50 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: That front 4, Long as the focal point. Mozza running behind linking the attack to the midfield. Gera the intelligent wide player, building play and of course his threat from distance, and of course Wingie just bullying the fuck out of full backs and scoring once the chance fell.
Then we could bring on Lukaku for Long to make tired centre backs sit and cry on the pitch.
We had excellent quality across that entire front 6.
Dont forget we had Fortune on the bench as well as Rom for much of 12/13 - think they both scored as subs at Sunlun
RE: Robinson... - SW4Baggie - 01-18-2021
(01-18-2021, 04:39 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: (01-18-2021, 03:50 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: That front 4, Long as the focal point. Mozza running behind linking the attack to the midfield. Gera the intelligent wide player, building play and of course his threat from distance, and of course Wingie just bullying the fuck out of full backs and scoring once the chance fell.
Then we could bring on Lukaku for Long to make tired centre backs sit and cry on the pitch.
We had excellent quality across that entire front 6.
Dont forget we had Fortune on the bench as well as Rom for much of 12/13 - think they both scored as subs at Sunlun
They did indeed. I was legless in Bilbao that weekend, and discovered Bilbao and Sunderland have very close links as fans.
RE: Robinson... - Hopalong - 01-18-2021
(01-18-2021, 03:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (01-18-2021, 03:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I prefer Robinson over Grant. As would most people I reckon.
I feel for Grant, he's been given an impossible job, not suited to his strengths and with a massive price tag hanging over him.
At Hudds he was a goal scorer, often from wide positions, similar in many ways to Wingie, but without the technique, so he hasn't adapted well to being a lone striker up top at all. He doesn't give much outside the box, he isn't lazy mind, just doesn't have anything to offer. He isn't quick, at least not like Robinson, he has a poor first touch, not great in the air and ultimately just not suited to the role he's been signed for.
What Bilic was thinking I don't know.
Sadly this was patently obvious to the Hudds fans who all said as much when we were linked in the summer.
Given how difficult it is to find any semblance of agreement on messageboards, the fact the vast majority of their fans could see it does raise concerns around what our scouting team and Slav saw in him.
I'm sure if/when we go down Grant will be a useful asset in that league, but £16m for a decent Championship striker feels like we've been done.
Really hope he proves me wrong mind!
At times like this it's useful to actually provide some facts.
By way of comparison, over the past two seasons he has scored MORE league goals - 37 in 84 - than Watkins in FEWER games - 35 in 87 - playing on the left of a front three, in a shit side struggling with relegation for two seasons! He has also scored nearly as many goals as Robinson has (41) in his entire career and is two and a half years younger than Robinson and two years younger than Watkins.
He's been thrown into the deep-end in an unaccustomed role but I'm confident that over the course of his time with us he'll prove great value for money.
As I've said countless times he's not an out and out no 9/lone striker who leads the line. Get a proper no. 9 alongside him and he'll deliver (similar to Gayle).
Whatever he has done or not done since he signed in a complete shit-fest of a season shouldn't be totally down to him. Yes he's missed a couple of chances, but what support and service has he had? Messi and Ronaldo would struggle to score in our side. How many have Aubamayang and Werner scored in far better sides and there are countless more examples.
RE: Robinson... - MozzasRocket - 01-18-2021
(01-18-2021, 05:26 PM)Hopalong Wrote: (01-18-2021, 03:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (01-18-2021, 03:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I prefer Robinson over Grant. As would most people I reckon.
I feel for Grant, he's been given an impossible job, not suited to his strengths and with a massive price tag hanging over him.
At Hudds he was a goal scorer, often from wide positions, similar in many ways to Wingie, but without the technique, so he hasn't adapted well to being a lone striker up top at all. He doesn't give much outside the box, he isn't lazy mind, just doesn't have anything to offer. He isn't quick, at least not like Robinson, he has a poor first touch, not great in the air and ultimately just not suited to the role he's been signed for.
What Bilic was thinking I don't know.
Sadly this was patently obvious to the Hudds fans who all said as much when we were linked in the summer.
Given how difficult it is to find any semblance of agreement on messageboards, the fact the vast majority of their fans could see it does raise concerns around what our scouting team and Slav saw in him.
I'm sure if/when we go down Grant will be a useful asset in that league, but £16m for a decent Championship striker feels like we've been done.
Really hope he proves me wrong mind!
At times like this it's useful to actually provide some facts.
By way of comparison, over the past two seasons he has scored MORE league goals - 37 in 84 - than Watkins in FEWER games - 35 in 87 - playing on the left of a front three, in a shit side struggling with relegation for two seasons! He has also scored nearly as many goals as Robinson has (41) in his entire career and is two and a half years younger than Robinson and two years younger than Watkins.
He's been thrown into the deep-end in an unaccustomed role but I'm confident that over the course of his time with us he'll prove great value for money.
As I've said countless times he's not an out and out no 9/lone striker who leads the line. Get a proper no. 9 alongside him and he'll deliver (similar to Gayle).
Whatever he has done or not done since he signed in a complete shit-fest of a season shouldn't be totally down to him. Yes he's missed a couple of chances, but what support and service has he had? Messi and Ronaldo would struggle to score in our side. How many have Aubamayang and Werner scored in far better sides and there are countless more examples.
Bang on the money. 'He isn't very good in the air'. Didn't he score a cracking header, but it got ruled out for offside by a few inches? From what i remember he got up quite well & powered it in.
RE: Robinson... - Birdman1811 - 01-18-2021
(01-18-2021, 05:51 PM)MozzasRocket Wrote: (01-18-2021, 05:26 PM)Hopalong Wrote: (01-18-2021, 03:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (01-18-2021, 03:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I prefer Robinson over Grant. As would most people I reckon.
I feel for Grant, he's been given an impossible job, not suited to his strengths and with a massive price tag hanging over him.
At Hudds he was a goal scorer, often from wide positions, similar in many ways to Wingie, but without the technique, so he hasn't adapted well to being a lone striker up top at all. He doesn't give much outside the box, he isn't lazy mind, just doesn't have anything to offer. He isn't quick, at least not like Robinson, he has a poor first touch, not great in the air and ultimately just not suited to the role he's been signed for.
What Bilic was thinking I don't know.
Sadly this was patently obvious to the Hudds fans who all said as much when we were linked in the summer.
Given how difficult it is to find any semblance of agreement on messageboards, the fact the vast majority of their fans could see it does raise concerns around what our scouting team and Slav saw in him.
I'm sure if/when we go down Grant will be a useful asset in that league, but £16m for a decent Championship striker feels like we've been done.
Really hope he proves me wrong mind!
At times like this it's useful to actually provide some facts.
By way of comparison, over the past two seasons he has scored MORE league goals - 37 in 84 - than Watkins in FEWER games - 35 in 87 - playing on the left of a front three, in a shit side struggling with relegation for two seasons! He has also scored nearly as many goals as Robinson has (41) in his entire career and is two and a half years younger than Robinson and two years younger than Watkins.
He's been thrown into the deep-end in an unaccustomed role but I'm confident that over the course of his time with us he'll prove great value for money.
As I've said countless times he's not an out and out no 9/lone striker who leads the line. Get a proper no. 9 alongside him and he'll deliver (similar to Gayle).
Whatever he has done or not done since he signed in a complete shit-fest of a season shouldn't be totally down to him. Yes he's missed a couple of chances, but what support and service has he had? Messi and Ronaldo would struggle to score in our side. How many have Aubamayang and Werner scored in far better sides and there are countless more examples.
Bang on the money. 'He isn't very good in the air'. Didn't he score a cracking header, but it got ruled out for offside by a few inches? From what i remember he got up quite well & powered it in.
Haven't seem him win a dual with a defender though, that's the issue.
I think he'll come good in time. But Bilic was a moron for signing for that role.
|