![]() |
|
And people wonder why we got rid of Bilic... - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: And people wonder why we got rid of Bilic... (/showthread.php?tid=14697) |
RE: And people wonder why we got rid of Bilic... - Ossian - 12-31-2020 Looking at our managers just over the past decade would lead anybody to think there was no coherent strategy. There's the dreamers like Mel and Slaven; the hard nosed pragmatists (Roy, Pulis, now Allardyce); a few who are difficult to sum up in a single word (Clarke, Darren Moore, as examples); plus an assortment of caretakers and the odd mystifying 'experiment' (Irvine, Pardew). Viewed as a list it all looks a bit odd, but it's probably just a reflection of how limited the options can be when there's not money to burn compared with the competition. Even if you do what Southampton did and unearth a Pochettino it only buys a relatively short time before a club with a bigger cheque book comes along and says 'We'll take him, thank you very much'. Makes it difficult to see how a relatively small and cash-strapped club can follow even a medium term plan when managers are almost inevitably going to make themselves either sackable or poachable. RE: And people wonder why we got rid of Bilic... - Derek Hardballs - 12-31-2020 (12-31-2020, 07:03 PM)Ossian Wrote: Looking at our managers just over the past decade would lead anybody to think there was no coherent strategy. There's the dreamers like Mel and Slaven; the hard nosed pragmatists (Roy, Pulis, now Allardyce); a few who are difficult to sum up in a single word (Clarke, Darren Moore, as examples); plus an assortment of caretakers and the odd mystifying 'experiment' (Irvine, Pardew). This is a great post and sums up where we are. The idea that a club like ourselves at the mercy of others can put together any consistent plan and stick to it for three, four, five years is very naive. If a manager does well they will be poached, if they falter they are sacked. The only conceivable alternative is a conveyor belt of quality managers that can fit neatly into a system but as we’ve seen that system isn’t perfect and falls to pieces when the DoF is poached or sacked for the same reasons as the traditional manager. We also make it hard for ourselves by flip flopping between styles of play. Since Megson we have employed managers / head coaches who play nice football then we realise at some point with our meagre budget at Prem level we need a more pragmatic approach. With the odd bizarre experiments in between. We are stuck in limbo, overly reliant on TV money that affords us the advantage for promotion but leaves us short of staying up unless the manager has pragmatic style of play and sections of our support are too puritanical for that. RE: And people wonder why we got rid of Bilic... - Hopalong - 12-31-2020 2 wins in 18 or whatever on the face of it is quite damning and we can only trust Dowling and Co that it was the right decision, but just a few points. Firstly, the other stats you've posted are a pointless load of nonsense. Secondly - regardless of the win profile, Bilic got us promoted (Hallelujah!) at least one year ahead of schedule (I've heard it mentioned it was a 3 yr project). So the club will benefit this season to the tune of at least £100m. Had we not got promoted which is well documented - particularly in view of Covid - it would have been a complete disaster on so many levels - but we did it! Certainly last season at that level he brought some brilliant players to the club, primarily Pereira, Diangana and Kroc. I'm confident that Grant, in time, will become a great signing - he's 23 years old! And as I may have mentioned before he scored more goals in the last two seasons than Watkins who cost at least twice as much. Someone said he has signed every player he wanted this season - that is complete bollocks and weasel words. He wanted; Grbic Vida Orsic Vlasic Manzukic. Quite a few others I've forgotten..... And he didn't get one of them. We will never know if Slav would have kept us up but I believe he would have had a better chance if he had been backed in the last window (and no-one can ever prove otherwise) and again in Jan - as BFSS will now be- one last throw of the lice by the 'Chinese' as Pulis would say. There may have been other issues which led to his demise and given the nature of these things they will no doubt come out in good time. The thing is. people are different - there is no absolute management blueprint for success - some managers are disciplinarians and run players up Austrian mountains til they're vomitting, others are a bit more laissez faire. All I know is that he got us promoted in his first season with a +32 goal difference and only 7 defeats and gave us back our pride after a few years of shite. And he will always be one of my favourite managers. A very well educated decent man. I also think we've appointed a clumsy, insensitive and tactless clown as his replacement. Which is what older people tend to become!
RE: And people wonder why we got rid of Bilic... - Squid - 12-31-2020 (12-31-2020, 08:01 PM)Hopalong Wrote: 2 wins in 18 or whatever on the face of it is quite damning and we can only trust Dowling and Co that it was the right decision, but just a few points. Where have you got the "Three year project" from? That is clear nonsense. As soon as Covid happened we had to go up in one year. So anyone still bleating about "A two year plan" is talking nonsense and sadly that includes some local journalists who should know better. He wanted Krov, Ivanovic and Grant and he got all three. You've listed a load of players Bilic supposedly wanted. As we've seen, we didn't need another GK and getting one would have caused a rapid depreciation in value of Johnstone, who has instead been able to add to his value. Then there's the issue of Bilic seemingly wanting to stuff the team with his compatriots. Always a bad, bad idea. Then there's the issue of us not having the money to buy more players anyway. Your line about Bilic being a well-educated decent man. That's not what he's employed to do. He's employed to get our team to win football matches, something he's failed abjectly to do since February. RE: And people wonder why we got rid of Bilic... - Derek Hardballs - 12-31-2020 (12-31-2020, 08:01 PM)Hopalong Wrote: 2 wins in 18 or whatever on the face of it is quite damning and we can only trust Dowling and Co that it was the right decision, but just a few points. Two, three year project... what nonsense. How exactly was it going to become easier to win promotion the longer we stayed in the Championship? Absolute glittery oss shit! RE: And people wonder why we got rid of Bilic... - Birdman1811 - 12-31-2020 West Brom signing Mandzukic..... If Slav believed that he deserved to be sacked for drug abuse. RE: And people wonder why we got rid of Bilic... - Sliced - 12-31-2020 I don't understand when people say "well he didn't get all the players he wanted" implying that he can't be judged. What manager ever gets all the players they wanted!? RE: And people wonder why we got rid of Bilic... - baggie_ray - 12-31-2020 (12-31-2020, 08:19 PM)Squid Wrote: Then there's the issue of Bilic seemingly wanting to stuff the team with his compatriots. Always a bad, bad idea. I don't see why that would be "always a bad, bad idea". Wenger signed many a French player and, of course, the Wolves are stuffed to the rafters with Portuguese players. Can't see that it was or has been to the detriment of either team. Didn't Liverpool go down the Spanish route under Benitez as well? RE: And people wonder why we got rid of Bilic... - Hopalong - 01-01-2021 (12-31-2020, 04:54 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Jan to Jan we’re 77th out of all the EPL and EFL sides (92) in the country. Load of bollocks. I replied to China - the thread has been deleted...hopefully not because of me! two words - Promotion - £100m!!! ( a year ahead of schedule) RE: And people wonder why we got rid of Bilic... - Remi_Moses - 01-01-2021 We can debate all we like, he should have done this or that. When your the manager one thing above all other counts and that's results. |