WBAUnofficial
Newcastle Sat - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Newcastle Sat (/showthread.php?tid=14085)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Newcastle Sat - Super_Slav - 12-08-2020

(12-08-2020, 10:13 AM)Olympic Wrote: I don't think Slav will lose his job. We are actually overachieving given our budget and lack of new additions.

Nail on head here Olympic. 

Look at what we actually added.

We really needed a Shane Duffy type CB as a partner for Semi Ajayi. Who do we get? A 36 year old Ivanovic who can only play in a 3 IMO.

I think due to the 4 teams in mix atm, is keeping Slav in a job. 

If Sat goes ahead maybe the stars are aligning for him as Newcastle will be depleted IMO


RE: Newcastle Sat - Olympic - 12-08-2020

(12-08-2020, 10:17 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(12-08-2020, 10:13 AM)Olympic Wrote: I don't think Slav will lose his job. We are actually overachieving given our budget and lack of new additions.

Not sure you can class 6 points from 11 games as over achieving. It's our worst ever Premier League start. Others had to work with measly budgets and did slightly better (Megson, Mowbray). Look down the carp squad AFI had and even he did better.

The gap between the PL and Championship has never been this big before though. Villa only just stayed up after spending over £100 million and this year they invested again in Watkins, Cash and Bartley. Leeds who kept all their players from last season bar Dean White invested huge money into Rodrigo, Raphinha, Llorente and Koch. Sheff Utd who had a great season spent huge money on Brewster and Ramsdale and brought in two promising full backs. Brighton paid some huge wages on Lallana, Welback, Veltman and got Dean White back. Burnley are the only ones that haven't invested and they are on same points as us despite being an established PL side. Now compare that to us. We barely went up which was a huge achievement considering it was a brand new team, but everyone could see and underlying stats confirmed we weren't ready to go up. Instead of strengthening we only brought in Kipre (Wigan), 36 yo Ivanovic and Grant on top of last years squad. Bilic wasn't even given a chance to succeed.


RE: Newcastle Sat - aj21 - 12-08-2020

(12-08-2020, 10:30 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(12-08-2020, 10:13 AM)Olympic Wrote: I don't think Slav will lose his job. We are actually overachieving given our budget and lack of new additions.

Nail on head here Olympic. 

Look at what we actually added.

We really needed a Shane Duffy type CB as a partner for Semi Ajayi. Who do we get? A 36 year old Ivanovic who can only play in a 3 IMO.

I think due to the 4 teams in mix atm, is keeping Slav in a job. 

If Sat goes ahead maybe the stars are aligning for him as Newcastle will be depleted IMO

Have you seen Shane Duffy this season? Ivanovic has been fine for me, he played in a 4 at Brighton which in the 2nd half was out best 45 minutes of the season. Why we have gone back to a back 5 I don't know, yes we were terrible at Fulham but that wasn't the formation. Why can't we just play the following team

Johnstone
O'Shea (RB)
Semi
Ivanovic Or Bartley
Gibbs

Sawyers 
Pereira
Gallagher
Grady

Grant
Robinson

4 4 fucking 2


RE: Newcastle Sat - Olympic - 12-08-2020

aj - personally I don't think it needs to be a binary choice. Against Man Utd and Spurs 5 at the back worked really well and we could have easily won the Spurs game had Gallagher's shot been a few inches to the right and against Man Utd we should have been 1 up with 30 mins to go. I agree against lower sides 4 at the back would be my preferred choice.


RE: Newcastle Sat - Big Daddy Cool - 12-08-2020

(12-08-2020, 10:46 AM)aj21 Wrote:
(12-08-2020, 10:30 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(12-08-2020, 10:13 AM)Olympic Wrote: I don't think Slav will lose his job. We are actually overachieving given our budget and lack of new additions.

Nail on head here Olympic. 

Look at what we actually added.

We really needed a Shane Duffy type CB as a partner for Semi Ajayi. Who do we get? A 36 year old Ivanovic who can only play in a 3 IMO.

I think due to the 4 teams in mix atm, is keeping Slav in a job. 

If Sat goes ahead maybe the stars are aligning for him as Newcastle will be depleted IMO

Have you seen Shane Duffy this season? Ivanovic has been fine for me, he played in a 4 at Brighton which in the 2nd half was out best 45 minutes of the season. Why we have gone back to a back 5 I don't know, yes we were terrible at Fulham but that wasn't the formation. Why can't we just play the following team

Johnstone
O'Shea (RB)
Semi
Ivanovic Or Bartley
Gibbs

Sawyers 
Pereira
Gallagher
Grady

Grant
Robinson

4 4 fucking 2


We'd get destroyed every week


RE: Newcastle Sat - ferencpuskas - 12-08-2020

I like Billic, and did so when he was a player, however when we lost Pereira the score I think was still 1-1, if not only 2-1, ok, we only had 10 players, but we still could make 2 banks of 4, and a front man up for quick out balls, which meant they'd at least have to keep 2 back to mark. To let in  another 4, against the keeper who last week was being feted as England's no 1, was truly a disgrace. It should have been PARK the kin bus!


RE: Newcastle Sat - Hopalong - 12-08-2020

(12-08-2020, 11:47 AM)ferencpuskas Wrote: I like Billic, and did so when he was a player, however when we lost Pereira the score I think was still 1-1, if not only 2-1, ok, we only had 10 players, but we still could make 2 banks of 4, and a front man up for quick out balls, which meant they'd at least have to keep 2 back to mark. To let in  another 4, against the keeper who last week was being feted as England's no 1, was truly a disgrace. It should have been PARK the kin bus!

We lost our individual responsibility, shape and heads dropped that's why Livermore will be back on Saturday if fit to show some leadership.


RE: Newcastle Sat - SW4Baggie - 12-08-2020

(12-07-2020, 09:45 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: We either lose to them Saturday or lose to them another time.

Big Grin


RE: Newcastle Sat - cornishbaggie - 12-08-2020

Looks like it's going ahead.


RE: Newcastle Sat - Fulham Fallout - 12-08-2020

(12-08-2020, 10:36 AM)Olympic Wrote:
(12-08-2020, 10:17 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(12-08-2020, 10:13 AM)Olympic Wrote: I don't think Slav will lose his job. We are actually overachieving given our budget and lack of new additions.

Not sure you can class 6 points from 11 games as over achieving. It's our worst ever Premier League start. Others had to work with measly budgets and did slightly better (Megson, Mowbray). Look down the carp squad AFI had and even he did better.

The gap between the PL and Championship has never been this big before though. Villa only just stayed up after spending over £100 million and this year they invested again in Watkins, Cash and Bartley. Leeds who kept all their players from last season bar Dean White invested huge money into Rodrigo, Raphinha, Llorente and Koch. Sheff Utd who had a great season spent huge money on Brewster and Ramsdale and brought in two promising full backs. Brighton paid some huge wages on Lallana, Welback, Veltman and got Dean White back. Burnley are the only ones that haven't invested and they are on same points as us despite being an established PL side. Now compare that to us. We barely went up which was a huge achievement considering it was a brand new team, but everyone could see and underlying stats confirmed we weren't ready to go up. Instead of strengthening we only brought in Kipre (Wigan), 36 yo Ivanovic and Grant on top of last years squad. Bilic wasn't even given a chance to succeed.

And who will want to come in for a relegation scrap with a transfer budget most likely to be zilch?


The players aren’t good enough and changing the manager (which we can’t afford) won’t change anything.