RE: Last time you were this angry after a game... - baggiebloke - 11-22-2020
(11-21-2020, 11:35 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: An impartial view on the main talking points.
Albion penalty - The truth? I honestly wouldn't have wanted to call this one. I suspect I could have been watching replays all night and still not really be sure. I'd probably lean towards it not being a penalty, so I'd say the ref was ultimately right to not give it.
United penalty - It's a shit rule. A really shit rule. But as pathetic as the rule is, it's now a penalty.
Penalty re-take - Sorry, but irrespective of the shenanigans of the United player's run up, the keeper can't come off his line. So, as with the other two decisions, the ref's got it right.
If it had happened to Stoke, I'd be gutted and feeling like we'd been done. And you can always summise that if each incident had been reversed, the ref might not have been so keen to make sure his decisions were so spot on. But for me, all the decisions were right.
Sorry!
Here you go. Great reviews.
https://thespecsplace.co.uk
RE: Last time you were this angry after a game... - Peachy - 11-22-2020
Just watched MOTD this morning and there was no replays or mention of the foul on Gallagher.
Fucking myopic twats as per usual.
RE: Last time you were this angry after a game... - albion_pigeon - 11-22-2020
(11-21-2020, 11:35 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: An impartial view on the main talking points.
Albion penalty - The truth? I honestly wouldn't have wanted to call this one. I suspect I could have been watching replays all night and still not really be sure. I'd probably lean towards it not being a penalty, so I'd say the ref was ultimately right to not give it.
United penalty - It's a shit rule. A really shit rule. But as pathetic as the rule is, it's now a penalty.
Penalty re-take - Sorry, but irrespective of the shenanigans of the United player's run up, the keeper can't come off his line. So, as with the other two decisions, the ref's got it right.
If it had happened to Stoke, I'd be gutted and feeling like we'd been done. And you can always summise that if each incident had been reversed, the ref might not have been so keen to make sure his decisions were so spot on. But for me, all the decisions were right.
Sorry!
Absolute bollocks on your first point DK, go and watch it again.
RE: Last time you were this angry after a game... - 74bus - 11-22-2020
(11-21-2020, 11:35 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: An impartial view on the main talking points.
Albion penalty - The truth? I honestly wouldn't have wanted to call this one. I suspect I could have been watching replays all night and still not really be sure. I'd probably lean towards it not being a penalty, so I'd say the ref was ultimately right to not give it.
United penalty - It's a shit rule. A really shit rule. But as pathetic as the rule is, it's now a penalty.
Penalty re-take - Sorry, but irrespective of the shenanigans of the United player's run up, the keeper can't come off his line. So, as with the other two decisions, the ref's got it right.
If it had happened to Stoke, I'd be gutted and feeling like we'd been done. And you can always summise that if each incident had been reversed, the ref might not have been so keen to make sure his decisions were so spot on. But for me, all the decisions were right.
Sorry! The fact that you 'could have been watching replays all night and still not really be sure' shows that the original decision wasn't a clear and obvious error, and therefore the ref was ultimately wrong not to give it.
The points about the United penalty are correct, but because you only watched the pathetic MOTD coverage you missed a crucial (non) decision in the game. ON BT Sport, even the ex-Man U players agreed with the resident ref that Gallagher was clearly fouled directly before their penalty incident and that, therefore their penalty shouldn't have been given.
RE: Last time you were this angry after a game... - Dreamkiller - 11-22-2020
(11-22-2020, 11:02 AM)74bus Wrote: (11-21-2020, 11:35 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: An impartial view on the main talking points.
Albion penalty - The truth? I honestly wouldn't have wanted to call this one. I suspect I could have been watching replays all night and still not really be sure. I'd probably lean towards it not being a penalty, so I'd say the ref was ultimately right to not give it.
United penalty - It's a shit rule. A really shit rule. But as pathetic as the rule is, it's now a penalty.
Penalty re-take - Sorry, but irrespective of the shenanigans of the United player's run up, the keeper can't come off his line. So, as with the other two decisions, the ref's got it right.
If it had happened to Stoke, I'd be gutted and feeling like we'd been done. And you can always summise that if each incident had been reversed, the ref might not have been so keen to make sure his decisions were so spot on. But for me, all the decisions were right.
Sorry! The fact that you 'could have been watching replays all night and still not really be sure' shows that the original decision wasn't a clear and obvious error, and therefore the ref was ultimately wrong not to give it.
The points about the United penalty are correct, but because you only watched the pathetic MOTD coverage you missed a crucial (non) decision in the game. ON BT Sport, even the ex-Man U players agreed with the resident ref that Gallagher was clearly fouled directly before their penalty incident and that, therefore their penalty shouldn't have been given.
You're right about VAR. I suppose I was viewing it from an old-world 'was it a penalty?' point of view rather than 'should the ref have changed his decision?'
On their penalty I've now seen the foul leading up to it, so yeah, you should have had a free-kick.
On VAR as a whole, my opinion remains unchanged. It needs scrapping. The problem wasn't that we needed a better system, we needed better refs. Those same refs are making pretty much the same mistakes even with VAR. I've seen little evidence that it's doing anything other than destroying the game. I'd rather refs make wrong decisions instantaneously rather than take 5 minutes to do it.
Albert - I hope my revised view helps. And thanks for not banning me.
RE: Last time you were this angry after a game... - EastMidsBaggie - 11-22-2020
billybassett Wrote:At Villa park in the first leg playoff for me
Yep !
RE: Last time you were this angry after a game... - Tom Joad - 11-22-2020
In all fairness, let's look at it totally impartially;
1/ Albion penalty, Definitely kicked the player, it's probably given anywhere on the field.
2/ Foul on Gallagher in lead up to MU pen. That's a foul.
3/ Handball in area. Well technically they have been giving penalties for any handball this season although the fact he was so obviously trying to pull away makes it the harshest ever.
4/ Johnson saves penalty but is off the line. Isnt every keeper ALWAYS off the line? Plus it was the stutter in the run up that drew it.
5/ MU players encroaching area on retake. I didn't notice this myself but if so it seems harsh not to order another retake after being pedantic over the 1st pen.
For me, all these incidents can be seen as contentious and a committee would probably not agree after 24hrs debate. But the fact that in 10 minutes, United had all 5 decisions go their way AFTER REVIEWS is absolutely scandalous.
RE: Last time you were this angry after a game... - ElbowGrease1973 - 11-22-2020
(11-21-2020, 11:35 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: An impartial view on the main talking points.
Albion penalty - The truth? I honestly wouldn't have wanted to call this one. I suspect I could have been watching replays all night and still not really be sure. I'd probably lean towards it not being a penalty, so I'd say the ref was ultimately right to not give it.
United penalty - It's a shit rule. A really shit rule. But as pathetic as the rule is, it's now a penalty.
Penalty re-take - Sorry, but irrespective of the shenanigans of the United player's run up, the keeper can't come off his line. So, as with the other two decisions, the ref's got it right.
If it had happened to Stoke, I'd be gutted and feeling like we'd been done. And you can always summise that if each incident had been reversed, the ref might not have been so keen to make sure his decisions were so spot on. But for me, all the decisions were right.
Sorry!
Ban him Sid 
Hope you're good DK, I'm assuming the Christmas Cake has already been started?
RE: Last time you were this angry after a game... - Dreamkiller - 11-22-2020
(11-22-2020, 11:53 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: (11-21-2020, 11:35 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: An impartial view on the main talking points.
Albion penalty - The truth? I honestly wouldn't have wanted to call this one. I suspect I could have been watching replays all night and still not really be sure. I'd probably lean towards it not being a penalty, so I'd say the ref was ultimately right to not give it.
United penalty - It's a shit rule. A really shit rule. But as pathetic as the rule is, it's now a penalty.
Penalty re-take - Sorry, but irrespective of the shenanigans of the United player's run up, the keeper can't come off his line. So, as with the other two decisions, the ref's got it right.
If it had happened to Stoke, I'd be gutted and feeling like we'd been done. And you can always summise that if each incident had been reversed, the ref might not have been so keen to make sure his decisions were so spot on. But for me, all the decisions were right.
Sorry!
Ban him Sid 
Hope you're good DK, I'm assuming the Christmas Cake has already been started?
Cheers EG. Yeah mate, cake done last week. Whisky going on tonight.
RE: Last time you were this angry after a game... - TETLEY74 - 11-22-2020
(11-22-2020, 12:03 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: (11-22-2020, 11:53 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: (11-21-2020, 11:35 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: An impartial view on the main talking points.
Albion penalty - The truth? I honestly wouldn't have wanted to call this one. I suspect I could have been watching replays all night and still not really be sure. I'd probably lean towards it not being a penalty, so I'd say the ref was ultimately right to not give it.
United penalty - It's a shit rule. A really shit rule. But as pathetic as the rule is, it's now a penalty.
Penalty re-take - Sorry, but irrespective of the shenanigans of the United player's run up, the keeper can't come off his line. So, as with the other two decisions, the ref's got it right.
If it had happened to Stoke, I'd be gutted and feeling like we'd been done. And you can always summise that if each incident had been reversed, the ref might not have been so keen to make sure his decisions were so spot on. But for me, all the decisions were right.
Sorry!
Ban him Sid 
Hope you're good DK, I'm assuming the Christmas Cake has already been started?
Cheers EG. Yeah mate, cake done last week. Whisky going on tonight.
You mean you've still got whisky left, what's the matter with you ?
|