WBAUnofficial
Snowflakes and The Fairytale of New York - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Snowflakes and The Fairytale of New York (/showthread.php?tid=13766)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11


RE: Snowflakes and The Fairytale of New York - Ted Maul - 11-19-2020

(11-19-2020, 02:24 PM)Tokyo Baggie Wrote: [quote="Ted Maul" pid="242617" dateline="1605791271"]
This is bollocks, how many people actually want this censoring? Same as over the summer when there were campaigns to remove Gone With the Wind and Little Britain, this is not the outcome that the people who are actually impacted want.

Perhaps explaining why in 2020 it's not acceptable to use the term would be better than banning a song that is very much of its time. Christ, there are films from a decade ago where things are regularly derided as being "gay". A hell of a lot has changed since the original was released, banning it just fuels the fire of the permanently outraged and as always, the ones who ultimately lose out will be the whichever minority group want to walk down the street without being abused.

"Perhaps explaining why in 2020 it's not acceptable to use the term would be better than banning a song" - Agree.

"there are films from a decade ago where things are regularly derided as being "gay"" - An interesting point made in that article is that Aled Haydn-Jones is now head of Radio 1. If I'm not mistaken, he was the producer of the Chris Moyles show around 2007 when there was an uproar about his use of the word "gay". Aled was openly gay and if I remember correctly backed Chris Moyles on air at the time. Times have changed, and maybe in some cases this is a good thing. If a word causes a group of people to feel uncomfortable, maybe it shouldn't be used freely on on the BBCs flagship radio station? Especially if the people who feel uncomfortable are more likely to listen to said station than the people screaming "It's political correctness gone mad!" while at the same time never listening to the station in question.


Who are the real snowflakes? For me it's those foaming at the mouth to defend their right to freely use a homophobic slur.

The tweets from the Pogues should put this issue to bed.


RE: Snowflakes and The Fairytale of New York - Baggiejacko - 11-19-2020

Hey girls stop worrying about this. I just saw the Wagatha trial started today. Let's start a thread about that to argue and bitch about. Whose side are you on?


RE: Snowflakes and The Fairytale of New York - BurleyBaggie - 11-19-2020

(11-19-2020, 02:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-19-2020, 02:24 PM)Tokyo Baggie Wrote:
(11-19-2020, 01:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: This is bollocks, how many people actually want this censoring? Same as over the summer when there were campaigns to remove Gone With the Wind and Little Britain, this is not the outcome that the people who are actually impacted want.

Perhaps explaining why in 2020 it's not acceptable to use the term would be better than banning a song that is very much of its time. Christ, there are films from a decade ago where things are regularly derided as being "gay". A hell of a lot has changed since the original was released, banning it just fuels the fire of the permanently outraged and as always, the ones who ultimately lose out will be the whichever minority group want to walk down the street without being abused.

"Perhaps explaining why in 2020 it's not acceptable to use the term would be better than banning a song" - Agree.

"there are films from a decade ago where things are regularly derided as being "gay"" - An interesting point made in that article is that Aled Haydn-Jones is now head of Radio 1. If I'm not mistaken, he was the producer of the Chris Moyles show around 2007 when there was an uproar about his use of the word "gay". Aled was openly gay and if I remember correctly backed Chris Moyles on air at the time. Times have changed, and maybe in some cases this is a good thing. If a word causes a group of people to feel uncomfortable, maybe it shouldn't be used freely on on the BBCs flagship radio station? Especially if the people who feel uncomfortable are more likely to listen to said station than the people screaming "It's political correctness gone mad!" while at the same time never listening to the station in question.


Who are the real snowflakes? For me it's those foaming at the mouth to defend their right to freely use a homophobic slur.

The tweets from the Pogues should put this issue to bed.
Historical censorship is wrong, we should see worts and all to ensure we don’t make the same mistakes. 

However, to continue to use language that’s outdated and offensive, just because it is catchy Christmas hit is simply repeating history and reinforcing defunct and ignorant stereotypes. If the Pogues can see this what’s the issue?


RE: Snowflakes and The Fairytale of New York - Salter Spring - 11-19-2020

3 pages in and no-one has mentioned "baby it's cold outside", I'm disappointed so throwing it in there and running away  Smile

In all seriousness I thought Shane MacGowan responded to this last year stating that the person in the song isn't very nice and it is the sort of language they would use.  He's either changed his tune or like so many social media accounts it's most probably run by some marketing company and the Pogues themselves have very little input.  Growing up I listened to a lot of rap music and this was always censored (on the rare occasion it was played) on the radio so I see this as no different to that, nothing to see here.

Either way it's become overplayed and very annoying as the years have gone on, but then again i'm a miserable bar steward and have the same opinion of all Christmas songs.

Bah Humbug


RE: Snowflakes and The Fairytale of New York - baggiebloke - 11-19-2020

The Pogues will enjoy the publicity.

The word "faggot" was only seemingly used because it rhymed with "maggot". I bet ar Kirst's spinnin in her grave.

On a separate note, it's jolly just as well that what was said in my school playgrounds in the 70s and 80s wasn't recorded. A large proportion of the "student body" would still be in prison to this day*.

* some are actually**.

** but we don't mention them***.

*** apart from that mention.


RE: Snowflakes and The Fairytale of New York - Ted Maul - 11-19-2020

(11-19-2020, 03:11 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(11-19-2020, 02:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-19-2020, 02:24 PM)Tokyo Baggie Wrote:
(11-19-2020, 01:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: This is bollocks, how many people actually want this censoring? Same as over the summer when there were campaigns to remove Gone With the Wind and Little Britain, this is not the outcome that the people who are actually impacted want.

Perhaps explaining why in 2020 it's not acceptable to use the term would be better than banning a song that is very much of its time. Christ, there are films from a decade ago where things are regularly derided as being "gay". A hell of a lot has changed since the original was released, banning it just fuels the fire of the permanently outraged and as always, the ones who ultimately lose out will be the whichever minority group want to walk down the street without being abused.

"Perhaps explaining why in 2020 it's not acceptable to use the term would be better than banning a song" - Agree.

"there are films from a decade ago where things are regularly derided as being "gay"" - An interesting point made in that article is that Aled Haydn-Jones is now head of Radio 1. If I'm not mistaken, he was the producer of the Chris Moyles show around 2007 when there was an uproar about his use of the word "gay". Aled was openly gay and if I remember correctly backed Chris Moyles on air at the time. Times have changed, and maybe in some cases this is a good thing. If a word causes a group of people to feel uncomfortable, maybe it shouldn't be used freely on on the BBCs flagship radio station? Especially if the people who feel uncomfortable are more likely to listen to said station than the people screaming "It's political correctness gone mad!" while at the same time never listening to the station in question.


Who are the real snowflakes? For me it's those foaming at the mouth to defend their right to freely use a homophobic slur.

The tweets from the Pogues should put this issue to bed.
Historical censorship is wrong, we should see worts and all to ensure we don’t make the same mistakes. 

However, to continue to use language that’s outdated and offensive, just because it is catchy Christmas hit is simply repeating history and reinforcing defunct and ignorant stereotypes. If the Pogues can see this what’s the issue?

Exactly.


RE: Snowflakes and The Fairytale of New York - Offside - 11-19-2020

Please ban all Christmas songs from every radio station. Above all John Lennon.


RE: Snowflakes and The Fairytale of New York - Psalm23 - 11-19-2020

(11-19-2020, 04:07 PM)Offside Wrote: Please ban all Christmas songs from every radio station.  Above all John Lennon.

+1

Christmas songs my arse, bahhhh!    Angry


RE: Snowflakes and The Fairytale of New York - Salter Spring - 11-19-2020

(11-19-2020, 04:07 PM)Offside Wrote: Please ban all Christmas songs from every radio station.  Above all John Lennon.

If the world wants to erase anything from history, they can take Stop the Cavalry and I saw mommy kissing Santa Claus with them.  I actually can't walk into a shop during November/December without the incessant shite polluting my ear drums winding me up untilI have to walk out.  I used to sit next to a guy who was old enough to know fuggin better who on the 1st December every year without fail would sit next to me humming Wham or some other such shite, and would say "I'm getting in the mood"!!!  The only person getting in the fuggin mood sunshine is me and if you don't stop it soon you're gonna have to shit those headphone out in the morning when i shove them down your throat.

Thank the lord for the small mercy of lockdown and working from home where I can miserably sit on my own with the only noise being that of my angry typing to my boss.


RE: Snowflakes and The Fairytale of New York - Remi_Moses - 11-19-2020

Shall we just ban yesterday and start a new calendar just to be on the safe side.
Who thinks this stuff up?
I'm offended nobody has been offended for 33 years.
Should increase record sales - Put a fiver on it being No1 at xmas