![]() |
|
Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!! - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!! (/showthread.php?tid=13657) |
RE: Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!! - MassDebater - 11-10-2020 Was that written by someone off here? Sounds like the usual complaints from this bored to me. Someone owes Peace's debt and hasn't paid. Fans / S4A not happy with the investment in players. No-one knows who is actually in charge. S4A feel ignored by the Chinese owners. Think that sums it up in a much more succinct manner? RE: Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!! - Kit Kat Chunky - 11-10-2020 (11-10-2020, 01:50 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:(11-10-2020, 01:11 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(11-10-2020, 10:34 AM)Stourbridge Baggie Wrote: It has always been my view, from documents seen (the irony), that a number of the protagonists behind S4A have personal issues with certain officials of the Club and this festered and grew when JP sold and they didn't get a substantial pay out. My share was purchased when the Club was on the brink and I never considered it to be more than a donation, an equivalent of the modern GoFundMe schemes. it didn't give me any control over the Club nor did I expect it too. I am well aware that interests of Minority Shareholders should be taken into account under governance protocols but in the real Corporate world Majority shareholders call the shots and like it or not the Club exists in this world. When JP took control of the Club and restructured the shareholding it was made clear that anyone that retained their shares would be left with a financially worthless un-tradeable investment with little or no input on Club affairs. I fully understand why some Shareholders were upset by this at the time, I have a good friend who was a home and away season ticket holder who has never been to a game since, but this argument was lost a long time ago and the Club, like so many others, is no longer the same organization. An inter-Company loan is common within Corporate structures but the inference from S4A is that the funds were some how "miss-directed" and I have seen comments all over social media along the lines of "definitely dodgy" (mostly from people who wouldn't recognize a set of accounts if it smacked them in the face). I have no idea what the purpose of the loan was or what happened to the funds, but 1) It was years ago and pre-dates the current ownership and 2) The Club has turned over hundreds of millions of pounds since the transaction and the amount in question is miniscule by comparison. If the owner wanted to divert funds he could easily have reduced salary and transfer budgets this season and paid himself a dividend, from which the loan could be repaid but I doubt S4A would have been happy with that. S4A has every right to question the future strategy of the Club, lack of Investment etc as do we all but it is naïve in the extreme to demand that the owners respond, we are a privately owned club not a Publicly listed one. As I said in my opening comments, I still feel private grievances have driven the S4A agenda which is the reason why I have never joined the organization. Just my opinion and others may feel differently but worth putting a different view forward for discussion. And no I don't have any connection to the Club and I am not JP/MJ or Chinese ! Agree with all of this, CA. On the share buy-back, you are correct. The club (not JRP) bought the shares back and cancelled them. Didn't cost him a penny. The way it worked (for everyone else's knowledge - CA knows this) is that JRP had 50% of the shares, so 5 out of 10 if you like. The club bought 30% back and cancelled them, so he then had 5 out of 7, or 70%. The numbers here are examples, not saying they are 100% accurate. So the club spent millions buying back shares, so JRP could increase his shareholding at no cost. RE: Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!! - TartanRug - 11-10-2020 (11-10-2020, 01:50 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:(11-10-2020, 01:11 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(11-10-2020, 10:34 AM)Stourbridge Baggie Wrote: It has always been my view, from documents seen (the irony), that a number of the protagonists behind S4A have personal issues with certain officials of the Club and this festered and grew when JP sold and they didn't get a substantial pay out. My share was purchased when the Club was on the brink and I never considered it to be more than a donation, an equivalent of the modern GoFundMe schemes. it didn't give me any control over the Club nor did I expect it too. I am well aware that interests of Minority Shareholders should be taken into account under governance protocols but in the real Corporate world Majority shareholders call the shots and like it or not the Club exists in this world. When JP took control of the Club and restructured the shareholding it was made clear that anyone that retained their shares would be left with a financially worthless un-tradeable investment with little or no input on Club affairs. I fully understand why some Shareholders were upset by this at the time, I have a good friend who was a home and away season ticket holder who has never been to a game since, but this argument was lost a long time ago and the Club, like so many others, is no longer the same organization. An inter-Company loan is common within Corporate structures but the inference from S4A is that the funds were some how "miss-directed" and I have seen comments all over social media along the lines of "definitely dodgy" (mostly from people who wouldn't recognize a set of accounts if it smacked them in the face). I have no idea what the purpose of the loan was or what happened to the funds, but 1) It was years ago and pre-dates the current ownership and 2) The Club has turned over hundreds of millions of pounds since the transaction and the amount in question is miniscule by comparison. If the owner wanted to divert funds he could easily have reduced salary and transfer budgets this season and paid himself a dividend, from which the loan could be repaid but I doubt S4A would have been happy with that. S4A has every right to question the future strategy of the Club, lack of Investment etc as do we all but it is naïve in the extreme to demand that the owners respond, we are a privately owned club not a Publicly listed one. As I said in my opening comments, I still feel private grievances have driven the S4A agenda which is the reason why I have never joined the organization. Just my opinion and others may feel differently but worth putting a different view forward for discussion. And no I don't have any connection to the Club and I am not JP/MJ or Chinese ! Great post CA. Like your idea of community interest companies though I can't see it ever happening. Jezza as we know was interested in Jezza first and the club very much second, he gave the impression of carefully waiting before he sold to ensure we got the best owner we could get yet in reality was just waiting to maximise his personal income from the sale regardless of how that left the club. As for the new lot as you say many people are just asking for them to behave considerately, not demanding they spunk millions left, right and centre. (11-10-2020, 02:10 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(11-10-2020, 01:50 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:(11-10-2020, 01:11 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(11-10-2020, 10:34 AM)Stourbridge Baggie Wrote: It has always been my view, from documents seen (the irony), that a number of the protagonists behind S4A have personal issues with certain officials of the Club and this festered and grew when JP sold and they didn't get a substantial pay out. My share was purchased when the Club was on the brink and I never considered it to be more than a donation, an equivalent of the modern GoFundMe schemes. it didn't give me any control over the Club nor did I expect it too. I am well aware that interests of Minority Shareholders should be taken into account under governance protocols but in the real Corporate world Majority shareholders call the shots and like it or not the Club exists in this world. When JP took control of the Club and restructured the shareholding it was made clear that anyone that retained their shares would be left with a financially worthless un-tradeable investment with little or no input on Club affairs. I fully understand why some Shareholders were upset by this at the time, I have a good friend who was a home and away season ticket holder who has never been to a game since, but this argument was lost a long time ago and the Club, like so many others, is no longer the same organization. An inter-Company loan is common within Corporate structures but the inference from S4A is that the funds were some how "miss-directed" and I have seen comments all over social media along the lines of "definitely dodgy" (mostly from people who wouldn't recognize a set of accounts if it smacked them in the face). I have no idea what the purpose of the loan was or what happened to the funds, but 1) It was years ago and pre-dates the current ownership and 2) The Club has turned over hundreds of millions of pounds since the transaction and the amount in question is miniscule by comparison. If the owner wanted to divert funds he could easily have reduced salary and transfer budgets this season and paid himself a dividend, from which the loan could be repaid but I doubt S4A would have been happy with that. S4A has every right to question the future strategy of the Club, lack of Investment etc as do we all but it is naïve in the extreme to demand that the owners respond, we are a privately owned club not a Publicly listed one. As I said in my opening comments, I still feel private grievances have driven the S4A agenda which is the reason why I have never joined the organization. Just my opinion and others may feel differently but worth putting a different view forward for discussion. And no I don't have any connection to the Club and I am not JP/MJ or Chinese ! Thanks for explaining that. Basically using club money to indirectly boost his own income when he sold up. RE: Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!! - baggiebloke - 11-10-2020 (11-10-2020, 02:10 PM)TartanRug Wrote:(11-10-2020, 01:50 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:(11-10-2020, 01:11 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(11-10-2020, 10:34 AM)Stourbridge Baggie Wrote: It has always been my view, from documents seen (the irony), that a number of the protagonists behind S4A have personal issues with certain officials of the Club and this festered and grew when JP sold and they didn't get a substantial pay out. My share was purchased when the Club was on the brink and I never considered it to be more than a donation, an equivalent of the modern GoFundMe schemes. it didn't give me any control over the Club nor did I expect it too. I am well aware that interests of Minority Shareholders should be taken into account under governance protocols but in the real Corporate world Majority shareholders call the shots and like it or not the Club exists in this world. When JP took control of the Club and restructured the shareholding it was made clear that anyone that retained their shares would be left with a financially worthless un-tradeable investment with little or no input on Club affairs. I fully understand why some Shareholders were upset by this at the time, I have a good friend who was a home and away season ticket holder who has never been to a game since, but this argument was lost a long time ago and the Club, like so many others, is no longer the same organization. An inter-Company loan is common within Corporate structures but the inference from S4A is that the funds were some how "miss-directed" and I have seen comments all over social media along the lines of "definitely dodgy" (mostly from people who wouldn't recognize a set of accounts if it smacked them in the face). I have no idea what the purpose of the loan was or what happened to the funds, but 1) It was years ago and pre-dates the current ownership and 2) The Club has turned over hundreds of millions of pounds since the transaction and the amount in question is miniscule by comparison. If the owner wanted to divert funds he could easily have reduced salary and transfer budgets this season and paid himself a dividend, from which the loan could be repaid but I doubt S4A would have been happy with that. S4A has every right to question the future strategy of the Club, lack of Investment etc as do we all but it is naïve in the extreme to demand that the owners respond, we are a privately owned club not a Publicly listed one. As I said in my opening comments, I still feel private grievances have driven the S4A agenda which is the reason why I have never joined the organization. Just my opinion and others may feel differently but worth putting a different view forward for discussion. And no I don't have any connection to the Club and I am not JP/MJ or Chinese ! Indeed. JRP played a blinder. The icing on his cake was the fact he drew an income after he had sold up. It feels like the new owners had someone knock on their door, listened to a sales pitch that suckered them in and they agreed to buy, emptying all the jam jars in the house. Its quite a mess, unfortunately. RE: Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!! - Stourbridge Baggie - 11-10-2020 A lot of good points on here, particularly how we all feel the Club should be run, however back to reality. The accounts have always shown the inter company loan so no action against the auditors in that respect - it isn't hidden. The morality of it and the fact it hasn't been repaid is a different issue but not a legal one. Using Fosun as an example is flawed in my opinion, I would be more sympathetic to that view if Fosun revealed the full nature of its relationship with Mendez, his level of involvement at Board level and the amount of cash he earns for incomings and outgoings from players and the Club. It's certainly not a model other Clubs could follow because they haven't got Mendez. As regards management charges in the accounts, we wont know this years figure until March but previous years have revealed nothing untoward. Lepko and Goldberg themselves broke down the myth of "where's the money gone Tom" in their podcast, details of which appeared on this bored. I am not defending the current board or JP, I want to make that clear, but the inference of illegality in S4A correspondence, picked up on and magnified by people on social media, is in danger of creating a false crises around what is in reality a minor disagreement between a few disgruntled people and the Football Club. All this at a time when we should all be pulling together. Still if it makes them feel important. RE: Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!! - ericlegrisly - 11-10-2020 I've still got two shares. Worthless shit ones by the sounds of it. I'm not even sure how to prove I've got them - anybody want to buy them off me? One Grand ono. I bought them (at a time I couldn't really afford to) to help West Bromwich Albion. What a twat. RE: Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!! - CA Baggie - 11-10-2020 (11-10-2020, 02:45 PM)Stourbridge Baggie Wrote: A lot of good points on here, particularly how we all feel the Club should be run, however back to reality. The accounts have always shown the inter company loan so no action against the auditors in that respect - it isn't hidden. The morality of it and the fact it hasn't been repaid is a different issue but not a legal one. Using Fosun as an example is flawed in my opinion, I would be more sympathetic to that view if Fosun revealed the full nature of its relationship with Mendez, his level of involvement at Board level and the amount of cash he earns for incomings and outgoings from players and the Club. It's certainly not a model other Clubs could follow because they haven't got Mendez. As regards management charges in the accounts, we wont know this years figure until March but previous years have revealed nothing untoward. Lepko and Goldberg themselves broke down the myth of "where's the money gone Tom" in their podcast, details of which appeared on this bored. I am not defending the current board or JP, I want to make that clear, but the inference of illegality in S4A correspondence, picked up on and magnified by people on social media, is in danger of creating a false crises around what is in reality a minor disagreement between a few disgruntled people and the Football Club. All this at a time when we should all be pulling together. Still if it makes them feel important. I haven't bothered looking at the accounts for a few years which is why I put an "if" in the statement. I'm sure there's more to come out of the woodwork with the Fosun\Medez relationship but you can't argue that they're doing right by Wolves to date. I doubt the inbreds giva toss how much Mendez earns in agents fees. I suspect most of those fees are hidden in inter-company charges as there appears to be common ownership. My suspicion Birdie don't get the legals out! They do know how to behave towards the fans and the local stakeholders of the club though and the fans have had a better outcome than a pint of beer bought for them. The morality comes into football ownership much more as it's not a true business in the sense we all know it. In reality it's not like any fan can go elsewhere for their football which is why I raised morality and why a CIC type initiative would work better imo. Looking at the German model of ownership we might actually get a say at board level, not sure if that is a good thing or not... RE: Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!! - throstle - 11-10-2020 The reason for the concern about the loan of c£3.7m from Club to Holdings (JP's company) in September 2014 is the suspicion that the Club's money, that could otherwise be used for transfers etc, was instead given to allow Holdings to pay off the bridging loan it took out to finance the June 2014 Tender of £3k a share which increased its shareholding from c67% to c77%, and so make it much more attractive to a potential buyer. If true, not a good use of Club money and the reason why S4A have asked if the directors who authorised the loan were in breach of their fiduciary duty to the Club. S4A have tabled a resolution to ask for an investigation into the circumstances surrounding the loan, if this request is refused one can draw one's own conclusions. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-7846305/West-Brom-fans-demand-club-open-investigation-3-7million-loan-Jeremy-Peaces-company.html RE: Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!! - baggie_ray - 11-10-2020 (11-10-2020, 04:10 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I haven't bothered looking at the accounts for a few years which is why I put an "if" in the statement. Too right! They got a bloody pie as well...! RE: Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!! - Stourbridge Baggie - 11-10-2020 (11-10-2020, 04:22 PM)throstle Wrote: The reason for the concern about the loan of c£3.7m from Club to Holdings (JP's company) in September 2014 is the suspicion that the Club's money, that could otherwise be used for transfers etc, was instead given to allow Holdings to pay off the bridging loan it took out to finance the June 2014 Tender of £3k a share which increased its shareholding from c67% to c77%, and so make it much more attractive to a potential buyer. If true, not a good use of Club money and the reason why S4A have asked if the directors who authorised the loan were in breach of their fiduciary duty to the Club. S4A have tabled a resolution to ask for an investigation into the circumstances surrounding the loan, if this request is refused one can draw one's own conclusions. Throstle this may all be true but there are no facts to substantiate it and I can't believe after all his financial maneuverings that JP left himself exposed to investigation for the sake of clearing £3.7m out of his potential gain of £150m plus (whatever that figure was), it just doesn't make sense. But even if he did, it was a totally different board to the one we have now and they are not answerable for his actions. |