![]() |
|
So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... (/showthread.php?tid=12370) |
RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Fido - 09-05-2020 (09-05-2020, 12:09 PM)MassDebater Wrote: If the person doesn't resemble their passport then they should be getting a new one. How can they expect to fly or similar if they don't look like the passport? Fed up of these people clamouring for five minutes if outraged media attention when it's their own flipping fault. Anyway...mooo ving on ![]() [/quote] Is the right answer. RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Sliced - 09-05-2020 (09-05-2020, 12:09 PM)MassDebater Wrote: If the person doesn't resemble their passport then they should be getting a new one. How can they expect to fly or similar if they don't look like the passport? Fed up of these people clamouring for five minutes if outraged media attention when it's their own flipping fault. Exactly this. Or those with more sinister motives RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - The liquidator - 09-05-2020 Welcome to the world of woke . RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - fuzzbox - 09-05-2020 (09-05-2020, 12:22 PM)Sliced Wrote:(09-05-2020, 12:09 PM)MassDebater Wrote: If the person doesn't resemble their passport then they should be getting a new one. How can they expect to fly or similar if they don't look like the passport? Fed up of these people clamouring for five minutes if outraged media attention when it's their own flipping fault. Am I missing something? Wouldn't it be easier to just borrow your brothers - or even nick the blokes from down the road's for 'sinister purposes'? Why would you over-complicate things by pretending to be woman? Unless you really want to, I suppose... If this is the fear of the burka and terrorism, maybe I can help put peoples minds at rest. Until the pandemic, I travelled between the US and UK every couple of weeks. On the odd time someone is wearing a full hibab, they are ALWAYS ask to lift it and they ALWAYS do. No fuss, no argument, it's all over in 10 seconds. Some people will believe any shite they read. They should ask themselves why they choose to believe something so obviously ridiculous and why someone would make something like this up and distribute it. If someone wants to say they're black, woman or cat, why do I care? It's got nothing to do with me. Unless I'm expected to pay for it, of course. But that's not a moral issue, it's just I'm tight. When I was a student many decades ago, people made all sorts of idiot statements all the time. The difference then was that people dismissed it as shite and it got roundly ignored. Now people lap it up so they can comment about how stupid other people are. RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Sliced - 09-05-2020 That is a massive leap. You seem to be getting worked up about something that no one has said and I wasn't insinuating. I was actually talking about those wanting to commit fraud. People should look like their ID photo, otherwise ID's become pointless. Someone who wears a hijab and then has their ID checked will still have the same face. RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Borin' Baggie - 09-05-2020 (09-05-2020, 11:53 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:(09-05-2020, 10:56 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(09-05-2020, 10:19 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:(09-05-2020, 09:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:Well that concept of gender was introduced in the 50s and started to gain traction in the 70s but it did not mean this for most of human history. And we somehow survived. Not saying it isn't progress to have these new definitions and understandings for affected groups in society, and it is good for everyone to be aware, just don't think we should be spending so much time on it and entertaining any and all ideas. I/we blame social media.(09-05-2020, 09:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The worlds gone mad Tom, however I would put it like this - your race is defined by other people (your parents / ancestors) whereas your gender would be defined by you (who you are / how you feel). The UK perspective is based on the Bible, the same reason homosexual relations were frowned upon. Also, with regards to life expectancy for mill and factory workers in the UK that's skewed quite heavily by child mortality rates being higher and the rate of childbirth being higher in Northern England, and ultimately the progress made during that time has provided a crucial foundation to the modern prosperity of our country in both living conditions and social rights. Let's not forget how many rights industrialisation granted the new working classes of the late 18th and early 19th century and how the powers of the gentry declined with the growth of liberalism and the labour movements. With respect to "trans rights", pronouns are just common courtesy. If you're purposely misgendering someone then you're being a twat for no reason and in every story I've read the purposely part is the sticking point and is often glossed over for narrative purposes. You're example of health organisations being "concerned whether they can raise women's issues" also seems a bit bizarre, what examples are there? I know there was that thing with that Labour MP recently that I saw an article on but if you actually read the article instead of the headline it's pretty evident that the Labour MP was being a twat, Piers Morgan himself (quelle surprise at Piers Morgan being a nobhead) deliberately excluded trans men who had not had their cervix removed and women who had undergone a total hysterectomy (implying the former group must be women and that the latter group aren't women anymore) despite there not being a need to and the supposed "health organisation" being CNN who, last I checked, weren't a health organisation. Then there's stuff like the recent rugby stuff where people twisted a report into trying to block people assigned as male at birth playing rugby full stop despite the report being about androgenisation so the conclusions not being relevant to trans women who hadn't gone through that process (like if they were on puberty blockers before transitioning) and would have the very detrimental and stupid side effect of banning junior mixed rugby, but nobody wants to talk about that as there's an easy soundbite from an LGBT group that can be attacked instead. Then there's the debate on legal gender identification where there are legitimate concerns over allowing anyone to self identify their gender but ignoring the reasons in support for self identification being that the policy is based on successful implementation in other countries and there haven't been any credible alternative solutions offered to fix the issue of loads of trans people being on hormones for a decade, being out publicly and going through the full course of surgery and still not having enough evidence that they're living as they're next gender to go through the referral process to change their registered gender, making it entirely possible for a trans woman to have no biological hormonal features of a man, living as a woman for 10 years and having their meat and veg turned into a fanny but the legislation says "nope, still a man". It's hardly clear cut and the fact that trans people are such a minority means people aren't really exposed to the issues they have so they fly under the radar, and when that happens only the loud, militant minorities can filter through and nobody sensible is able to challenge the nonsense being pushed by the militant groups on the other side. The ultimate underlying issue for trans groups isn't all the noise flying around but that there are still really stupid barriers that prevent them from having basic recognition. RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - fuzzbox - 09-05-2020 (09-05-2020, 12:48 PM)Sliced Wrote: That is a massive leap. You seem to be getting worked up about something that no one has said and I wasn't insinuating. I thought it might be. That's why I said "If this is the fear of the burka and terrorism, maybe I can help put peoples minds at rest." On the other hand, It's a massive leap to say I'm wound up! If you don't look like your photo, don't you have to change your passport? Isn't that why children's photos don't last such a long time and you have to change your photo every 10 years as you age? If you think people who are frightened of refusing a photo ID in case they get into 'trouble' then I'm not sure how often that would happen in reality. Certainly not in immigration or anywhere important and probably nowhere where it would be newsworthy on it's own merits. 'Borrowed ID' have always been used for fraud, way before any 'woke agendas' could explain photos not looking like their owners, surely? That means the issue is people just not checking and doing their job properly. It's got nothing to do with gender or anything else. I genuinely don't see the link, maybe that's why I misunderstood your point. I wasn't 'wound up' just confused... ***Update. I've just re-read what I wrote and you're right - the thing about Burqa's was completely irrelevant. I can't even work out what prompted me to write it! I was probably doing too many things at once. Apologies. RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - Cheshire East Baggie - 09-05-2020 Weird story though, isn't it? It's always occurred to me that you can't be regarded as a "little bit black", even if it is only one grandparent. And if you have a white parent and a black parent, you wouldn't get much credibility if you said "I'm white really". But claiming some undetectable black heritage or ancestry just to gain credibility is bizarre. The great Daley Thompson once said "I'm not black I'm British". To a chorus of abuse from all sides, obviously. We're all guilty of labelling ourselves and others. RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - LIMABAGGIE - 09-06-2020 They should only put you in a box when they bury you. We are all individuals, it is our actions and behaviours that make us what we are, not skin colour, background or gender. RE: So it's OK to claim whatever gender you like, but... - ColliersWoodBaggie - 09-06-2020 I'd say the concept is ethnicity, not race. I've always thought the Human Race, therefore our species is termed Homo Sapiens. Apart from Dingels, obviously. (09-06-2020, 09:50 AM)LIMABAGGIE Wrote: They should only put you in a box when they bury you. We are all individuals, it is our actions and behaviours that make us what we are, not skin colour, background or gender. +1 |