WBAUnofficial
Sweeping Generalisation - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Sweeping Generalisation (/showthread.php?tid=12161)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: Sweeping Generalisation - fuzzbox - 08-25-2020

I've read this argument on here before. Would it be fair to say that the BBC seems to fill its ranks with plenty of people with high ranking political affiliations from BOTH sides?

If that's the case, why is the BBC doing that when they are supposed to be non-partisan? Isn't it just asking for trouble?
IF the two mothers were politically active, did they disclose their affiliation and was it disclosed tio the viewers? If not, that's surely an issue?
How were they selected? Was any effort taken to get views from a 'normal' mother. If not, why not?  Was it just lazy journalism looking for a body to fill 5 minutes and went for the easiest source. Or was it some elaborate plan?
On a side note, I never understand why we have to have feature 'man in the street' opinions so heavily anyway. I just don't see the value - I can only imagine it's because they don't want paying.

As I said, whilst I don't agree with Proth, it does merit investigation, even just to call out bs.


RE: Sweeping Generalisation - Borin' Baggie - 08-25-2020

(08-25-2020, 02:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-25-2020, 01:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(08-25-2020, 01:06 PM)Protheroe Wrote: And I rest my case.
https://order-order.com/2020/08/25/revealed-bbcs-far-left-anti-school-mum-campaigners/?fbclid=IwAR0cTTCoqWYOCXHQnKjjFXtR9IxmcGxnDsz6HE8XVa-55-uSx2zgBPp6KHM

Have you got it from a reputable source and not Paul Staines deranged blog of misinformation?

Did you click on the links to the two people involved? No? Then you may have reconsidered posting this.

There's no better way to hoist socialists than on their own petard.

Yup, they were links to Facebook.

I'm not reconsidering posting it though as it's an entirely accurate description of that shit blog and the tax dodger who owns it is a hypocritical cunt who is too busy gorging his face on Tayto and Supermacs in Dublin.

Has as much journalistic integrity as the Canary.


RE: Sweeping Generalisation - Protheroe - 08-25-2020

(08-25-2020, 02:41 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Yup, they were links to Facebook.

I'm not reconsidering posting it though as it's an entirely accurate description of that shit blog and the tax dodger who owns it is a hypocritical cunt who is too busy gorging his face on Tayto and Supermacs in Dublin.

Has as much journalistic integrity as the Canary.

Blah blah.

But none of that changes the FACT that two socialist agitators were brought on as "concerned parents". The BBC is beyond parody these days.


RE: Sweeping Generalisation - Protheroe - 08-25-2020

(08-25-2020, 02:39 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: I've read this argument on here before. Would it be fair to say that the BBC seems to fill its ranks with plenty of people with high ranking political affiliations from BOTH sides?

If that's the case, why is the BBC doing that when they are supposed to be non-partisan? Isn't it just asking for trouble?
IF the two mothers were politically active, did they disclose their affiliation and was it disclosed tio the viewers? If not, that's surely an issue?
How were they selected? Was any effort taken to get views from a 'normal' mother. If not, why not?  Was it just lazy journalism looking for a body to fill 5 minutes and went for the easiest source. Or was it some elaborate plan?
On a side note, I never understand why we have to have feature 'man in the street' opinions so heavily anyway. I just don't see the value - I can only imagine it's because they don't want paying.

As I said, whilst I don't agree with Proth, it does merit investigation, even just to call out bs.

It's every day Fuzz. And no the BBC doesn't fill its ranks with anyone from the liberal right.

Chris Patten was arguably the last and he was a wringing wet Tory Europhile.


RE: Sweeping Generalisation - fuzzbox - 08-25-2020

(08-25-2020, 05:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-25-2020, 02:39 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: I've read this argument on here before. Would it be fair to say that the BBC seems to fill its ranks with plenty of people with high ranking political affiliations from BOTH sides?

If that's the case, why is the BBC doing that when they are supposed to be non-partisan? Isn't it just asking for trouble?
IF the two mothers were politically active, did they disclose their affiliation and was it disclosed tio the viewers? If not, that's surely an issue?
How were they selected? Was any effort taken to get views from a 'normal' mother. If not, why not?  Was it just lazy journalism looking for a body to fill 5 minutes and went for the easiest source. Or was it some elaborate plan?
On a side note, I never understand why we have to have feature 'man in the street' opinions so heavily anyway. I just don't see the value - I can only imagine it's because they don't want paying.

As I said, whilst I don't agree with Proth, it does merit investigation, even just to call out bs.

It's every day Fuzz. And no the BBC doesn't fill its ranks with anyone from the liberal right.

Chris Patten was arguably the last and he was a wringing wet Tory Europhile.

Maybe, but I know of a fair few right wing activists that have got jobs in the BBC where you would expect the role to be impartial. 
I've also seen a few high profile errors where some of the more right wing 'extravagances' have got through.

To be honest, considering they're under pressure from both sides as regards impartiality, I find it amazing they don't take more care. I don't know whether they're just arrogant or inept.

But it's not just that that, it's the unofficial editorial that I find annoying. I know they mean well, but it's explicitly outside their remit. Not only that, the continual effort to shoehorn a racism or sexism issue in almost every topic does more harm than good. Especially when some of the examples even had me raising my eyebrows in disbelief. People get tired of being lectured and annoyed with being made to feel as if 'their side' is always evil. Just give it a rest! The point has been made, by all means take it up again when something actually happens, but until then let me get on with my life without having it thrust in my face all day. Maybe then I won't have to spend the first 10 minutes of each day deleting a load of 'passionate' emails offering me helpful ways I could avoid nasty accidents and financial advice such as nipping over to africa to buy a second home. Or something like that, I only skim-read them, to be honest. Sorry, rant over!


RE: Sweeping Generalisation - Borin' Baggie - 08-25-2020

(08-25-2020, 05:18 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-25-2020, 02:41 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Yup, they were links to Facebook.

I'm not reconsidering posting it though as it's an entirely accurate description of that shit blog and the tax dodger who owns it is a hypocritical cunt who is too busy gorging his face on Tayto and Supermacs in Dublin.

Has as much journalistic integrity as the Canary.

Blah blah.

But none of that changes the FACT that two socialist agitators were brought on as "concerned parents". The BBC is beyond parody these days.

The FACT is that Guido Fawkes has as much credibility as my arse.


RE: Sweeping Generalisation - Borin' Baggie - 08-25-2020

(08-25-2020, 05:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-25-2020, 02:39 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: I've read this argument on here before. Would it be fair to say that the BBC seems to fill its ranks with plenty of people with high ranking political affiliations from BOTH sides?

If that's the case, why is the BBC doing that when they are supposed to be non-partisan? Isn't it just asking for trouble?
IF the two mothers were politically active, did they disclose their affiliation and was it disclosed tio the viewers? If not, that's surely an issue?
How were they selected? Was any effort taken to get views from a 'normal' mother. If not, why not?  Was it just lazy journalism looking for a body to fill 5 minutes and went for the easiest source. Or was it some elaborate plan?
On a side note, I never understand why we have to have feature 'man in the street' opinions so heavily anyway. I just don't see the value - I can only imagine it's because they don't want paying.

As I said, whilst I don't agree with Proth, it does merit investigation, even just to call out bs.

It's every day Fuzz. And no the BBC doesn't fill its ranks with anyone from the liberal right.

Chris Patten was arguably the last and he was a wringing wet Tory Europhile.

Tim Davie is the next Director General and the next chairman is expected to be one of either two ex-Tory MPs and Andrew Neil.

Where's the ex-Lib Dem, SNP and Labour politicians within the BBC?

Also to add, Rona Fairhead succeeded Chris Patten and she bloody sits on the Tory benches in the Lords.


RE: Sweeping Generalisation - Derek Hardballs - 08-25-2020

(08-25-2020, 11:11 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-23-2020, 04:32 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Before anyone gets upset and defensive this is clearly a sweeping generalisation and there will be lots of exceptions, but why do these disparate subjects seem to bind a certain group of people together? 

Think Brexit is great
Dislike Meghan Markel 
Dislike face masks, and very anti-lockdown
Think Covid 19 is a hoax or just the flu
Support the Conservative’s without question 
Have British, US, Israeli avatars 
Want to ‘Defund the BBC’
Refuse to trust mainstream media but trust random blog and dubious social media links / ‘facts’
Think the climate change is a hoax or not that bad 

Just an observation from SM, radio and tv.

As you admitted, it's very simplistic view and if I may say so, also from the faux moral and intellectual high ground you inhabit most of the time.

All of the issues you raise are highly nuanced and I think you probably read into peoples' views what you want to read. You don't appear to be a very tolerant chap.

(08-25-2020, 08:51 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Even the BBC have done this.

As an example, consider the BBC's wholly extreme narrative on mask wearing in English secondary schools this morning.

Most media are determined to fuel fear, when the evidence is entirely absent. That, Dekka - is why the mainstream media is held in such low regard, they're incapable of telling us even half of the story.

You missed the part where I said before anyone gets upset and defensive then? 

I gave a list of subjects of course it’s simplistic and I also gave the caveat it’s a sweeping generalisation. There are nuances to most arguments but stating the BBC’s narrative with regards face masks in schools is extreme is well a little black and white and erm extreme.


RE: Sweeping Generalisation - Shabby Russian - 08-25-2020

I don't know about Derek's sweeping generalisations, but i am increasingly becoming disillusioned with the state of British politics.
Nothing illustrates this better than the non story that was the 'Rule Brittania' saga. A centre right sunday newspaper runs an article that claims the Beeb are going to drop 'Rule Brittania' from the last night of the proms so as to appease the Black Lives Matter movement. There is no evidence to suggest that BLM were campaigning to have it removed from the Last Night of the Proms programme - i suspect they have bigger issues to deal with them - but that doesn't stop right wing commentators laying into the Beeb and then the PM and Culture secretary added their twopenneth.

Turns out that it isn't being dropped from the programme, but for this year and this year only it is being played as an instrumental, because this year of course there is no audience and it is felt that this is very much an audience particpatory piece, which would not sound as good if there is only one vocalist singing along to it, unlike the NA which will be sang at this years proms.

So it would appear to be an artistic decision made by the conductor - cur her receiving thousands of abusive tweets, who knew tweeters with right wing views might indulge in abit of abusive tweeting, i think we were assured only lefties indulged in this kind of behaviour.

Why does any of this matter. You might well ask. But i suspect because it allows the Govt and its supporters to indulge in a bout of culture wars, which after 10 years of Govt from the right being shown to be less than competent, is where they find themselves to be most comfortable. Why talk and debate the issues that matter, when you can concoct a false story to rally the troops to your side.

And in all of this the Beeb becomes a political punchbag. There may be a lot to criticise the Beeb for these days, but political bias isn't one of them. The right have their knockers in a twist about Lewis Goodall, writing an article on the exam fiasco in the New Statesman. I have read the article in question, it is critical, but is not overtly political in nature. And he is not the only BBC journalist who has contributed articles for that magazine, Andrew Marr has done as well. But Marr is not a target for the right, but Goodall is and i suspect because of his skills as a journalist who has done his job and held the Govt to account .I don't know Goodall's politics - he did write a book about the Labour Party but i don't know if it was critical or not - he may well be left wing in his views, but so what the BBC also employs people like Nick Robinson and Andrew Neill in their politics team. Both are known to have right wing views, but in fairness both do an excellent job.


RE: Sweeping Generalisation - Protheroe - 08-26-2020

Lewis Goodall is a Labour actvist and former policy wonk at the IPPR. He has no business as policy editor of a "news" programme. Though to be fair Newsnight ceased to be anything more than opinion-led several years ago.

(08-25-2020, 07:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: stating the BBC’s narrative with regards face masks in schools is extreme is well a little black and white and erm extreme.

No, it's not. Once again this morning the BBC's line is that it will not be satisfied until masks are mandatory in secondary schools. It is an extreme viewpoint with no basis in scientific evidence.