WBAUnofficial
Brexit Gains 2 - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Brexit Gains 2 (/showthread.php?tid=20905)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49


RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Pontificator - 03-31-2022

(03-30-2022, 02:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-30-2022, 01:37 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-30-2022, 01:18 PM)Protheroe Wrote: There's nothing like raking over the ashes...

You won an empty box and have been proven wrong on pretty much every political position you’ve taken over the last few years. Brexit has been an exercise in punching ourselves in the face, and the government you helped get elected off the back of it are the most dishonest, arrogant, incompetent, dodgy, unscrupulous charlatans and snake oil salesmen to ever take office. Hollow victory after hollow victory. 

Leaving the EU won’t go away as a political battleground when the older generations leave this mortal coil the calls to rejoin will get louder as the younger generations watch on in envy as the rest of Northern Europe enjoy a better standard of living than we do. Unless the U.K. offer la a more attractive alternative to the EU it’s folly to believe people won’t want another say in the next couple of decades.

Currently this government are offering no benefits other than some nebulous notion of sovereignty.

Polemic aside I wonder what you think I've been "proven wrong" about? I've said on here for many years that high tax, high borrowing & high spend would be our road to ruin. I told you many years ago that suppressed interest rates would lead to huge wealth inequality and intergenerational unfairness. I told you that an obsession with net zero defied the reality of our carbon-based economy. And here we are. We didn't fix the roof while the sun was shining, again - and the policies you supported would've made things even worse.

You should be thanking me for helping ensure the least worst outcome for you. My pleasure.

To the person whose economic analysis would have allowed the banks to fail post crash causing untold financial chaos. Least worst FFS. These classical liberal believers, are the slops at the bottom of the barrel along with the narrow minded socialists that fucked the Labour Party, indistinguishable from each other, two sides of the same rotten coin, not Labour or Tory
Polemic aside the difference is that a government can be replaced when it goes wrong. BREXIT can't. 
I'm past the debate and just wanna say the people who facilitated BREXIT and the people who voted for it in all knowledge are cunts. I excuse the millions of thick as pigshit people who were taken in by the lying arseholes but there's nothing left but to tell them to fuck themselves. 


RE: Brexit Gains 2 - baggy1 - 03-31-2022

(03-31-2022, 07:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-30-2022, 02:33 PM)baggy1 Wrote: We've cut our front line services to a point they are collapsing and only just made it through covid

Except we haven't cut our front line services at all. If the NHS can't survive taking £150bn from us each year then please tell me, how much is enough?

In the next breath you'll be telling me it's somehow "unfair" to be asked to use your wholly unearned increases in housing equity to pay for your retirement and social care. The biggest issue we have in this country is that we collectively suck on the teat of the state, demanding ever more without understanding that we need to pay for it and refusing to take fiscal responsibility for our own lives. Most depressingly of all, there's not a prominent politician these days who doesn't encourage this conceit. 

As I said on another thread recently - the poorest must be bailed out by the welfare system, but for the rest of us - no more caps and price controls, no more bailouts and probably much more tax - we will have to tighten our belts and adjust. We're overdue a dose of reality, and Brexit is just a sideshow in this paradigm shift.

Health is the primary measure of the state of the nation and is also the biggest identifier of inequalities in the country. The blind faith in just pouring money into the NHS without looking at the social structures that the poorest live in will always be akin to pouring that money down the drain and bullshit that the tories falls back on to show how the NHS is failing.. It's basically respraying the car without ever servicing it. The alternative of private healthcare will only exacerbate those inequalities

And, barring serious illness, I'll have no need to use the equity in my property to fund my retirement or social care, I have had time during my working life to plan for that. However anyone nearer to 60 or already in retirement will not have had that opportunity and therefore it is wholly unfair to punish them for house value increases and strip them of that asset that they can pass on from a lifetime of working to pay for it. It's ironic that landlords such as yourself are bemoaning the house value increases when landlords in general (added to the lack of replenishment of the housing stock) are the primary reason for reducing the available housing stock and those increases.

We've spent 10 years in a failed Tory policy of 'austerity' and that has been added to by another failing current Tory policy of Brexit. There's one commonality in all of the failures that have led us to this point.


RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Protheroe - 03-31-2022

The alternative isn't just private healthcare, the lack of imagination amongst Brits concerning healthcare is mind boggling. Latvia, South Africa and Argentina have better survival rates for pancreatic cancer that killed my father, though they spend far less on health than the UK. Much poorer Romania, Turkey and Malaysia have better survival rates for stomach cancer, for which Britain is ranked 46th out of 60 countries. The NHS is a national disaster spending about 1.5% of its annual budget on clinical negligence cases, which are the tip of the iceberg for those tenacious enough to pursue them.

I am part of the problem in the housing market, but if the state supressses interest rates to enable me to benefit from asset price inflation to protect my family's future then why wouldn't I? After all, as a business owner I don't get paid leave or sick pay and I'm still taxed to the eyeballs. Unlike you, and most of Britain I suspect, I don't believe my kids have some sort of divine right to an unearned inheritance whilst compelling some of the poorest taxpayers pay for my care. How on Earth is that fair?

And as for austerity - 2010-2015 will be viewed as picnic compared with what's coming.


RE: Brexit Gains 2 - baggy1 - 03-31-2022

(03-31-2022, 09:36 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The alternative isn't just private healthcare, the lack of imagination amongst Brits concerning healthcare is mind boggling. Latvia, South Africa and Argentina have better survival rates for pancreatic cancer that killed my father, though they spend far less on health than the UK. Much poorer Romania, Turkey and Malaysia have better survival rates for stomach cancer, for which Britain is ranked 46th out of 60 countries. The NHS is a national disaster spending about 1.5% of its annual budget on clinical negligence cases, which are the tip of the iceberg for those tenacious enough to pursue them.

I am part of the problem in the housing market, but if the state supressses interest rates to enable me to benefit from asset price inflation to protect my family's future then why wouldn't I? After all, as a business owner I don't get paid leave or sick pay and I'm still taxed to the eyeballs. Unlike you, and most of Britain I suspect, I don't believe my kids have some sort of divine right to an unearned inheritance whilst compelling some of the poorest taxpayers pay for my care. How on Earth is that fair?

And as for austerity - 2010-2015 will be viewed as picnic compared with what's coming.

It's pointless arguing with you when you cherry pick a single illness completely out of context for one country and comparing it with the UK. And you appear to have missed my point that apart from serious illness I am pretty sorted for my retirement, but then I've had a working lifetime to prepare for it, those older than me haven't.

And again we come back to you ignoring the vanity project of Brexit which you said was going to solve some of the problems and it has achieved fuck all apart from drain the countries resources for the past 6 years and will continue to punish the population for years to come. Brexit may be a sideshow to you now, but it has led us to exacerbating the problems that lie ahead.


RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Protheroe - 03-31-2022

Cherrypicking? OK - here's some more international cancer comparisons for the service that also needlessly killed 200 babies & 9 mothers in Shropshire.
https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/health-professional/data-and-statistics/international-cancer-benchmarking-partnership-icbp/icbp-findings


RE: Brexit Gains 2 - baggy1 - 03-31-2022

(03-31-2022, 02:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Cherrypicking? OK - here's some more international cancer comparisons for the service that also needlessly killed 200 babies & 9 mothers in Shropshire.
https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/health-professional/data-and-statistics/international-cancer-benchmarking-partnership-icbp/icbp-findings

Well then try and fix the underlying problems rather than chucking it in the bin. Fucks sake Proth, it's really schoolboy debating to argue one distinct point without looking at the wider issues that are interlinked. The Tory party have been in power for that long now they feel immune to having to fix anything properly and just pay it lip service. 

We need to refresh the system completely and that will take money, we need to start with the health of the nation from childhood and create a system that guides and advises throughout their lives with regular health checks at various points (where for example we can pick up on cancer early enough to do something about it). Because the NHS is so broken we need to almost phase the current model out but that can't happen overnight, we would need to run these two systems in parallel. This is something that should have been started years ago but the Tory model was to privatise everything and that has clearly failed as a hybrid approach.


RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Protheroe - 03-31-2022

The Tory Model demonstrably, was not to "privatise everything". I have no idea what prism you view the world through, but by Christ it's at odds with reality.

I don't for a moment advocate "privatising everything" either.

The NHS spends 1.5% of its budget on settling clinical negligence cases. And that's just the tip of the iceberg given that it's only the tenacious few who aren't in thrall to the professionals and institutional insiders on permanent cover-up call. That's the definition of a busted flush.


RE: Brexit Gains 2 - baggy1 - 03-31-2022

And what with the money that is being paid over to the private sector (in some cases guaranteed by the government no matter what the usage - up to 5Bn for covid capacity unused) then we can already start to see savings. But why would the government arrange such lucrative contracts with the private sector at such a cost to the NHS.

Corrupt, corrupt from the bottom to the top.

What would your solution be if it doesn't involve individuals paying as much for private medical care (that hasn't got anywhere near the capacity needed) as it would just paying the extra taxes. And if you think that it is just NHS services that are involved in the clinical negligence cases then think again, the doctors specifically have a foot in both camps and guess where they focus their attentions and time (clue - not the one that pays less), which adds another strain onto the NHS services that leads to mistakes on a massive scale.


RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Rustynail - 04-02-2022

All hail the gullible who voted leave, with their A levels and degrees in excuses, the gullible who were taken in by the lies and the popular press, the gullible who were unable to see the real outcome, the gullible who mock those who could.

Everything has gone up in price, construction materials are going through the roof (pun intended), it has been a monumental fuck up of the highest order, no surprise when you see the shower of shit trying to implement it, the first party to say we will rejoin will get my vote.


RE: Brexit Gains 2 - Protheroe - 04-02-2022

(04-02-2022, 07:11 AM)Rustynail Wrote: All hail the gullible who voted leave, with their A levels and degrees in excuses, the gullible who were taken in by the lies and the popular press, the gullible who were unable to see the real outcome, the gullible who mock those who could.

Everything has gone up in price, construction materials are going through the roof (pun intended), it has been a monumental fuck up of the highest order, no surprise when you see the shower of shit trying to implement it, the first party to say we will rejoin will get my vote.

You're blaming Brexit for the increase in global commodity prices?

Wow.