![]() |
|
England v India - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: England v India (/showthread.php?tid=20109) |
RE: England v India - CA Baggie - 09-06-2021 rsbaggy2 Wrote:CA Baggie Wrote:Really stirred you guys up. If you look I withdrew the FODTV remark .. but don't know why I'm being singled out for an acronym used by so many before.rsbaggy2 Wrote:If I was an Indian supporter I'd be a little concerned that this is a very poor batting side they're playing, Root aside, with no Stokes, Archer or Broad and yet the games have still been close. I understand conditions play a part etc but the great Aussie side of the 90s and early 2000s just swept teams aside.oldun Wrote:Cuzer Wrote:RS, you do realise his action has been looked at numerous times by the ICC, take the blinkers off fella (again) it's a valid observation Chill. I was being flippant. I would agree test cricket is in a slump in general across the world, the quality is down and teams of only a few years back would easily beat these sides. There have been too many batting collapses for it to be anything but a lack of quality. The games have been tight and turned on a couple of sessions and this one in a particular a lod of dropped catches!! Some of the basics have been poorly executed. RE: England v India - Ted Maul - 09-06-2021 Been close? If it weren't for the weather India would be 3-1 up. A far superior batting, bowling and fielding unit that England. RE: England v India - Cuzer - 09-06-2021 (09-06-2021, 03:46 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Been close? I think they've been the better side throughout but it's all come down to fine margins and passages of play, I think England would need their strongest XI to beat this India side over 5 tests and this is nowhere near their strongest side is it? Bowlers dead on their feet so I see little chance of a bounce back at Manchester either Cuzer RE: England v India - MancBaggie - 09-06-2021 Great win for India after Day 1. Dont be surprised if England bounce back on Friday though - especially if India persist with leaving Ashwin out. In terms of the current strength of the 2 teams the ICC rankings put India as a clear second behind NZ (well ahead of England and Aus). This series so far has come down to the top 5 for each side - India's finally fired in the 2nd dig - and you still feel that that Pujara Kohli and Rahane can show a lot more. Not much between the 2 attacks if you ignore Ashwin. Bumrah is an outstanding bowler with an unorthodox action. However, he has not been quite as effective since that recent injury. The others have chipped in though - just as the England seamers complement Jimmy. RE: England v India - ElbowGrease1973 - 09-06-2021 (09-06-2021, 03:46 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Been close? It's been closer than I expected, which shows the expectations I had. Unfortunately, India are just the better overall side currently, particularly with Stokes and Archer out. If you were to select a combined England / India eleven, based on players used in this series, there would only be Root & Anderson that would have chance of being included. Says it all really. RE: England v India - rsbaggy2 - 09-06-2021 A beer or two will taste extra sweet tonight! RE: England v India - Cuzer - 09-06-2021 (09-06-2021, 04:08 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: A beer or two will taste extra sweet tonight! Sweet? You're drinking the wrong beer fella! Cuzer RE: England v India - MancBaggie - 09-06-2021 (09-06-2021, 04:08 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: A beer or two will taste extra sweet tonight!
RE: England v India - Cheshire East Baggie - 09-06-2021 Predictable result in the end. England can't bat under pressure, regardless of the players selected. Anderson struggles in the second innings, especially after back-to-back Tests. England pick bowlers who can bat a bit due to the dodgy top order - Sam Curran and Craig Overton being classic examples. Mahmood was brought in to provide pacy cover for Wood, but wasn't picked even though Wood wasn't fit. Robinson has become the new Broad - always gets the new ball regardless of conditions or other options - when his pace drops to mid-70s mph he is ordinary. The continued absence of a "proper" spinner (OK, I know Ali has nearly 200 wickets) denies us an attacking edge in certain conditions. Playing a non-specialist wicket-keeper (let's not pretend Buttler and Bairstow are anything more than average performers) only works if said wicket-keeper scores runs. The muddled selection policy is slowly unravelling Joe Root's excellent win percentage as captain. Was it ever clear why Silverwood took full control of everything earlier in the year? He's been a total disaster IMO. Credit to India for an excellent performance, but my word, England have a way of making things difficult for themselves. RE: England v India - KratosBaggie - 09-06-2021 (09-06-2021, 04:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Predictable result in the end. England can't bat under pressure, regardless of the players selected. Anderson struggles in the second innings, especially after back-to-back Tests. England pick bowlers who can bat a bit due to the dodgy top order - Sam Curran and Craig Overton being classic examples. Mahmood was brought in to provide pacy cover for Wood, but wasn't picked even though Wood wasn't fit. Robinson has become the new Broad - always gets the new ball regardless of conditions or other options - when his pace drops to mid-70s mph he is ordinary. The continued absence of a "proper" spinner (OK, I know Ali has nearly 200 wickets) denies us an attacking edge in certain conditions. Playing a non-specialist wicket-keeper (let's not pretend Buttler and Bairstow are anything more than average performers) only works if said wicket-keeper scores runs. I've been down Edgbaston today, and watched a proper wicket keeper at work. For the runs a proper wicket keeper fails to get with the bat, they more than save with stumpings, and stopping wayward balls, from the bowlers, go for four. Fowkes is head and shoulders the best wicket keeper in the country, but I'd like to see anyone argue against Burgess as the second best choice. He's not exactly poor with the bat, either. |