WBAUnofficial
Fellows - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Fellows (/showthread.php?tid=38487)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34


RE: Fellows - B68Baggie - 08-29-2025

Spot on Birdy. The mini meltdown about the fee from many quarters promoted me to get re-registered on here and offer my two penneth. Bit disappointed that by the time I could post common sense views were prevailing.

Tom just doesn't seem to have it in his locker (yet) to cut inside and try bending one into the top corner, and that is the expectation on a winger once you get into the top level. He has been trying, but pretty sure his last attempt this season was a proper row z job. The wide players moving for the really big money offer the potential for regular goals and/or even to drop into the ten role.


RE: Fellows - Josh1873 - 08-29-2025

(08-29-2025, 12:02 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Will the response be:

A) repeat "he's top assister" again
B) compare to a player who is younger, with more potential and has played in the PL.
C) claim that we're now just stuck with Wallace
D) 'cope'

That's all their braincells can muster. Shame.


RE: Fellows - Ted Maul - 08-29-2025

(08-29-2025, 12:13 PM)Sliced Wrote: Were you not expecting different opinions on a message board?

It's actually very simple. It's about the team being better, alongside getting as much out of a player who still has sell on value and could very likely improve his game because he's only 22. I do not think the 8 million or whatever it is will be enough to replace those attacking outputs, and there's no guarantee that his value will drop, but even if it does, it likely won't drop by much from 8 million, because that's not a very long way to fall anyway.

So you can sneer, but I don't think any of that is unreasonable. As I've said before, a lot of Saints fans can't believe the deal they are getting and a lot of our fans can't believe we're selling at that price.

I remember the similar conversations with Pereira with peeps desperately trying to justify the fee, "oh you're pant wetting" etc, and we NEVER replaced Pereira's goals and assists....and that was 5 years ago.

Of course, but people keep parroting the same nonsense when it's been highlighted why the points they are making aren't as valid, or as relevant as they thought they were.

I think it's low, but it's not THAT much too low and I can certainly see why no other team has come in for him. The counter argument to your point around his value is that, he's shown nothing yet to suggest he isn't a get to the byline, stand the ball up winger. I'm bored of saying it but teams want goals from wide forwards, that the current vogue in world football, whether we like it or not. However effective - and it was bloody effective - this was for us, he's in a minority of players who play like this and the majority of teams do not deploy wingers in this fashion. Mason has arrived this season and we've instantly become more narrow. It would represent a huge risk to us, as he goes into the later years of his contract were he to have a poor season this year and leave for even less next summer. Nestor and the recruitment team have targets, they know how much those targets are going to cost us, they will have known exactly how much value they needed to extract from the Fellows deal.

In hindsight you'll be hard pushed to find anyone who is onboard with the Pereira deal but that was the last knockings of a corrupt regime who had absolutely no interest in reinvesting a penny. Bilkul have already shown by improving and rebuilding our entire defence for less than the cost of one Heggem that they operate in a parallel universe to Lai & Co.


RE: Fellows - Vinebaggie - 08-29-2025

Think when people, like me, first heard the news there was an emotional spike that one of own, a lad with loads of potential was leaving on what looked like a poor fee. On reflection I guess the question will be after the window “are we a better team / squad now than we were last season” in the round things are looking as though we probably will be. So though I’m disappointed to see Tom go I’m happy to trust that Shilen, Nestor and Co know what their doing. And I guess many of us are finding it tough to believe that after the Jeremy Peace self enrichment project and the disaster that was Lai we actually just might have owners with the interest of the club at heart.


RE: Fellows - Birdman1811 - 08-29-2025

Yeah the Periera deal I did explain how we got to the situation where the only option was to be ripped off, not that it was acceptable, just awful management lead to it. I've said regularly since it was a prime example of how badly run we were as a club. There are no similarities with Fellows at all.


RE: Fellows - CA Baggie - 08-29-2025

(08-29-2025, 12:03 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Also, Southampton deal seems to be straight up cash, which is worth a lot more than slightly more on installments to us at the moment.

If we get 8-10 million in cash straight up, we can spend more on a player bought in installments and still record a PSR profit overall. It won't be like for like, it'll be a more modern right sided player that adds goals and assists as an overall, with Price now being the prime source of creativity it seems.

to be fair whether they pay cash or on instalments PSR should still be the same, that's just a cashflow issue.

I said on a thread a few days ago, he's too one dimensional in that he's great at taking a full back on and provides a consistently good cross but to step up a level from where he is he needs to learn to cut inside and get shots off and he needs to learn how to attack the far post, adding goals to his game.

Football tactics and styles of player are cyclical, there currently aren't loads of teams playing with out and out wingers that do what Fellows does with the limitations that he has.  

I still think £8m rising to £10m is a gamble on whether we can improve the squad by more than what we're losing.  Maybe Mason doesn't see the ability to learn those extras to his game, doesn't want the out and out winger so thinks it's worth taking the risk and with what Saints are offering being the only option is willing to take it.


RE: Fellows - Birdman1811 - 08-29-2025

For what it's worth to make it clear

Personally I'd rather sign Fellows up for a longer contract, see if we can get what we need with the smaller amount of cash, and build up Prices value to sell for big bucks because we will do.

However, I can see the reasoning and I get why the fee is what it is.


RE: Fellows - SW4Baggie - 08-29-2025

(08-29-2025, 12:13 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-29-2025, 12:02 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Will the response be:

A) repeat "he's top assister" again
B) compare to a player who is younger, with more potential and has played in the PL.
C) claim that we're now just stuck with Wallace
D) 'cope'

Were you not expecting different opinions on a message board?

It's actually very simple. It's about the team being better, alongside getting as much out of a player who still has sell on value and could very likely improve his game because he's only 22. I do not think the 8 million or whatever it is will be enough to replace those attacking outputs, and there's no guarantee that his value will drop, but even if it does, it likely won't drop by much from 8 million, because that's not a very long way to fall anyway.

So you can sneer, but I don't think any of that is unreasonable. As I've said before, a lot of Saints fans can't believe the deal they are getting and a lot of our fans can't believe we're selling at that price.

I remember the similar conversations with Pereira with peeps desperately trying to justify the fee, "oh you're pant wetting" etc, and we NEVER replaced Pereira's goals and assists....and that was 5 years ago.

Well said Sliced.

We don’t *NEED* to sell Fellows at this price - sure it gives us some wiggle room, but it’s not like we’d not have gotten £8M in January or next summer. Should he have another season similar to last year, we’d still get £8M for him with 12 months on his deal, or being a fan, we may well have been able to extend the contract.

When Kasey McAteer has just signed for Ipswich for £12m, no one will convince me we’ve got the best deal we could have for Fellows.

But, we have 3 days now to bring in the quality to improve our squad beyond what Tom brings. Let’s see what we get.


RE: Fellows - Ted Maul - 08-29-2025

(08-29-2025, 12:30 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Well said Sliced.

We don’t *NEED* to sell Fellows at this price - sure it gives us some wiggle room, but it’s not like we’d not have gotten £8M in January or next summer. Should he have another season similar to last year, we’d still get £8M for him with 12 months on his deal, or being a fan, we may well have been able to extend the contract.

When Kasey McAteer has just signed for Ipswich for £12m, no one will convince me we’ve got the best deal we could have for Fellows.

But, we have 3 days now to bring in the quality to improve our squad beyond what Tom brings. Let’s see what we get.

We do *NEED* to sell him (sell him full stop) if whatever fee we can get for him has already been earmarked for other targets across the squad. If Mason has said he's not going to use a winger in Tom's role then why hang on for another season for his value to either not grow, or even drop?

It's the first real gamble Bilkul have made on a players value not being higher in 12 months time, will certainly be an interesting one to keep an eye on.


RE: Fellows - Birdman1811 - 08-29-2025

(08-29-2025, 12:30 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2025, 12:13 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-29-2025, 12:02 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Will the response be:

A) repeat "he's top assister" again
B) compare to a player who is younger, with more potential and has played in the PL.
C) claim that we're now just stuck with Wallace
D) 'cope'

Were you not expecting different opinions on a message board?

It's actually very simple. It's about the team being better, alongside getting as much out of a player who still has sell on value and could very likely improve his game because he's only 22. I do not think the 8 million or whatever it is will be enough to replace those attacking outputs, and there's no guarantee that his value will drop, but even if it does, it likely won't drop by much from 8 million, because that's not a very long way to fall anyway.

So you can sneer, but I don't think any of that is unreasonable. As I've said before, a lot of Saints fans can't believe the deal they are getting and a lot of our fans can't believe we're selling at that price.

I remember the similar conversations with Pereira with peeps desperately trying to justify the fee, "oh you're pant wetting" etc, and we NEVER replaced Pereira's goals and assists....and that was 5 years ago.

Well said Sliced.

We don’t *NEED* to sell Fellows at this price - sure it gives us some wiggle room, but it’s not like we’d not have gotten £8M in January or next summer. Should he have another season similar to last year, we’d still get £8M for him with 12 months on his deal, or being a fan, we may well have been able to extend the contract.

When Kasey McAteer has just signed for Ipswich for £12m, no one will convince me we’ve got the best deal we could have for Fellows.

But, we have 3 days now to bring in the quality to improve our squad beyond what Tom brings. Let’s see what we get.

Considering the offers we've had already, I don't know how you work that out, the offers will get lower in the last 2 years, not higher, this summer is the peak.

As said, I'd have happily seen him tied down for a long time, but if the club wants to cash in, which will be in discussions with Mason about style of play etc, have to accept that's what they want.