WBAUnofficial
Fellows - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Fellows (/showthread.php?tid=38487)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34


RE: Fellows - Ted Maul - 08-29-2025

I think some of you need Proth to come along and give a lesson on supply and demand and the markets.


RE: Fellows - Josh1873 - 08-29-2025

(08-29-2025, 11:38 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I think some of you need Proth to come along and give a lesson on supply and demand and the markets.

Some people are clearly lacking any sense of logic. I hope they've got plenty of pants to change into dry ones after they wet them.


RE: Fellows - Sliced - 08-29-2025

(08-29-2025, 11:37 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-29-2025, 11:23 AM)Mickyfudge Wrote: I think some of our fans think they would make great coaches.always seem to be criticising academy players saying they are nor good enough.then we sign players who are no better .
God knows who is going to create chances now hope we aren’t gonna rely on Wallace

Don’t worry - there are lots of players out there that create chances, are the top assist creators in their division but are very cheap because they’re not very good or very one dimensional. There are also clubs who need to sell their star players below market rate due to PSR regulations.

We can just sign all of those players with the £8M we’ve banked Smile


If you think number of assists and goal contributions are important then you don't understand football. It's all about multi-dimensionality.


RE: Fellows - Jacko - 08-29-2025

Plenty of 'cope' still going on here.


RE: Fellows - Ted Maul - 08-29-2025

Pretty strange reaction to sensible posta outlining possibly why other clubs don't value Fellows as highly as we do.

If he's not replaced I'll join the bed-wetting on Monday, until then, pull yourselves together.


RE: Fellows - Birdman1811 - 08-29-2025

See the argument to adsurdism tactic is still popular here.

Fellows is very good at what he does, but that is it, nowadays wingers are expected to cut in and score chances themselves, many prem coaches don't want to see crosses often since they're easily defended against too often. That's what Rich and I mean when saying Fellows is one dimensional, it doesn't mean he's bad at all, he's probably the best player we've developed in the modern academy.

Problem is, when valuing a player, it's what others will pay, no Prem team wants him, because he doesn't do what a winger at that level has to do, just repeating 'top assister' ad-nauseum doesn't change that. Wallace I believe was top assister for a few years, he's never gone for massive money, for similar reasons, upper ceiling just isn't that high.

Only team even remotely interested is Southampton, we need more players in, we are still working with the EFL for our transfers, they've likely specified how much we can spend depending on what we take in, if we need to spend more, we need more money in. Only player of decent value is Fellows, the only offer we have is the one from Southampton.

In January he's into the last 18 months of his contract, when transfer value drops significantly, if he doesn't particularly suit how Mason wants us to play, that's only going to drop more. So we wouldn't even get what were getting now, and he may not have such a good season, not contributing near those numbers

I've been saying this about Fellows for 12 months+ now, he needed to learn to cut in and score, to take the ball into the box more rather than go wider. He hasn't really added those skills to his game and that's limited him. He's a superb crosser and is excellent at taking on a full back to get that cross in, sadly few teams want that from their winger nowadays.


RE: Fellows - Ted Maul - 08-29-2025

Will the response be:

A) repeat "he's top assister" again
B) compare to a player who is younger, with more potential and has played in the PL.
C) claim that we're now just stuck with Wallace
D) 'cope'


RE: Fellows - Birdman1811 - 08-29-2025

Also, Southampton deal seems to be straight up cash, which is worth a lot more than slightly more on installments to us at the moment.

If we get 8-10 million in cash straight up, we can spend more on a player bought in installments and still record a PSR profit overall. It won't be like for like, it'll be a more modern right sided player that adds goals and assists as an overall, with Price now being the prime source of creativity it seems.


RE: Fellows - CA Baggie - 08-29-2025

I think the point of improving the squad as a whole with the money is that, we probably won't find an individual that is the top goal assistant in the league, but we may improve the defence so we concede less and may play differently that enables the assistants of others to increase, so as a whole we're stronger.

Despite me saying that I still believe it is a below MV offer and would question whether the money and strengthening will be better than having Fellows. £8m isn't a lot and it needs to stretch a long way to find a replacement, LB and another forward/10.

Gilchrist and £1.5m banked for Furlong is a good start, we've got 3 days or so left to complete the rest of the picture.


RE: Fellows - Sliced - 08-29-2025

(08-29-2025, 12:02 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Will the response be:

A) repeat "he's top assister" again
B) compare to a player who is younger, with more potential and has played in the PL.
C) claim that we're now just stuck with Wallace
D) 'cope'

Were you not expecting different opinions on a message board?

It's actually very simple. It's about the team being better, alongside getting as much out of a player who still has sell on value and could very likely improve his game because he's only 22. I do not think the 8 million or whatever it is will be enough to replace those attacking outputs, and there's no guarantee that his value will drop, but even if it does, it likely won't drop by much from 8 million, because that's not a very long way to fall anyway.

So you can sneer, but I don't think any of that is unreasonable. As I've said before, a lot of Saints fans can't believe the deal they are getting and a lot of our fans can't believe we're selling at that price.

I remember the similar conversations with Pereira with peeps desperately trying to justify the fee, "oh you're pant wetting" etc, and we NEVER replaced Pereira's goals and assists....and that was 5 years ago.