WBAUnofficial
PSR breach reported by John Percy - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: PSR breach reported by John Percy (/showthread.php?tid=41270)



RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Cornflake - 04-14-2026

(04-14-2026, 10:08 AM)Mouse Wrote: An article not long been uploaded on the BBC website here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/cx2rr73g0pgo

A couple of quotes from Kieran Maguire:

"I've heard on the grapevine - and this was nothing to do with the club - they think that somebody, somewhere may have made an error in adding up or subtracting some numbers,"

"I think it's more of a mess up than a conspiracy. I don't think there's been some kind of grand plan by West Bromwich Albion to overspend."

Perhaps there has been an error at EFL level or at the club (or both) and both the club and EFL are trying to work it out, which would make some sense, especially given that the EFL haven't actually made an official statement.


Peace sold the calculator and insisted we could group together and use our fingers to count.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Sliced - 04-14-2026

Either way it's going to be embarrassing for someone.

If the EFL fucked up their numbers its them, if we fucked up our numbers its us, if its all a load of old bollocks then it's Percy


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - MGalea - 04-14-2026

We need to check some financial qualifications ASAP!


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Josh1873 - 04-14-2026

Whether it's us or them, to calculate incorrectly is some major fuck up. Who is doing these Spreadsheets? Baldrick, Dick Turpin?


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Scrantonbaggie - 04-14-2026

(04-14-2026, 11:24 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Whether it's us or them, to calculate incorrectly is some major fuck up. Who is doing these Spreadsheets? Baldrick, Dick Turpin?

Dianne Abbot in accounting.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - CIM - 04-14-2026

(04-14-2026, 11:24 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Whether it's us or them, to calculate incorrectly is some major fuck up. Who is doing these Spreadsheets? Baldrick, Dick Turpin?

Who says it's calculated incorrectly? Surely more down to interpretation as to what is factored as profit and loss under P&S rules.
I wonder if any sanction takes into account if a team has gained an advantage from breaching P&S? As was clearly the case with Leicester. With Albion the exact opposite. We've sold key players to try to meet P&S rules.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Tom Joad 25 - 04-14-2026

(04-14-2026, 11:29 AM)CIM Wrote:
(04-14-2026, 11:24 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Whether it's us or them, to calculate incorrectly is some major fuck up. Who is doing these Spreadsheets? Baldrick, Dick Turpin?

Who says it's calculated incorrectly? Surely more down to interpretation as to what is factored as profit and loss under P&S rules.
I wonder if any sanction takes into account if a team has gained an advantage from breaching P&S? As was clearly the case with Leicester. With Albion the exact opposite. We've sold key players to try to meet P&S rules.

Good points in that last paragraph,  CIM. I hope the club have someone suggesting this to the League.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke - 04-14-2026

We spent over £2m on Bany - it's hardly austerity is it.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - Wednesburybaggie - 04-14-2026

?.  If we knew we were not going to meet requirements why would we have sold 3 or 4 of our better players? Surely we would have kept them.


RE: PSR breach reported by John Percy - BristolCityInPeace - 04-14-2026

Essentially such are the way the EFL Rules are written, keeping players..can be even worse...

A Report in August 2024 suggested that WBA were under a Business Plan or a jointly agreed one. That was to try and prevent it, one bit even suggested since Spring 2023.

One possible consequence of actively refusing to sell Players would be a Formal Business Plan, targets by March or else significant Points deductions, Fee Bans..it's far removed from the PL system.

EFL deductions can go up to -12 or -21 if significantly aggravated and that is in addition to monitoring, Business Plans and so on.  Breaching a Business Plan in-season can be a separate offence to failing FFP. EFL system has become increasingly multilayered post Covid-19.

Chances are like with most clubs they ie the League, will have received 2024-25 Forecasts in March 2024 and indeed perhaps March 2023 subject to 3 Year Losses. They'll have known what to expect.