WBAUnofficial
1917 - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: 1917 (/showthread.php?tid=8399)

Pages: 1 2


RE: 1917 - billybassett - 01-19-2020

(01-19-2020, 10:57 AM)Idiodyssey Wrote: I was disappointed. I honestly went with an open mind and was looking forward to it given the reviews. Technical aspects of the film were impressive and I can understand why people find the film good but I'm baffled by the idea that it is a great film. To be honest, I found the story cliched (and boring) and the characters not especially engaging.

I wouldn't say I was disappointed but certainly not a great. Obviously the way it was filmed is impressive and the main actors seeing that through did a spectacular job given no editing for each section.

Shaving Ryan's Privates and others still better in the genre.

As for the lack of editing it felt like a video game to me at times the way it was shot and the way the sections moved from one to the other.


RE: 1917 - Ampadu's Left Boot - 01-19-2020

Agree that the story wasn't particularly original, fairly cliched even. A good but far from great film.

In terms of the one-shot-take effect, I expected it to be better executed than it was. Not that it was done badly, just that on first viewing I could tell how some of the transitions were done and that's probably what created that 'video game' feeling which it had at times.


RE: 1917 - Cunninghamismagic - 01-19-2020

After Dunkirk it's also nice to see a war film from a British perspective rather than the American Hollywood view.


RE: 1917 - Baggeridgebaggy - 01-19-2020

Given the budget & hype the film was a wasted opportunity in my opinion

There’s hardly any really high profile films made any WW1 - this was the war that shaped a generation. where every family was affected, a war to end all wars. A visceral, heart breaking & devastating conflict

But they choose to make a film that had both few & one dimensional characters, far fetched incidents & without any emotional attachment to those depicted. I think it was a war film for beginners & teenagers ...not what I expected

Looked amazing but fundamentally flat & uninspiring


RE: 1917 - Tom Joad - 01-19-2020

(01-19-2020, 01:40 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: Given the budget & hype the film was a wasted opportunity in my opinion

There’s hardly any really high profile films made any WW1 - this was the war that shaped a generation. where every family was affected, a war to end all wars. A visceral, heart breaking & devastating conflict

But they choose to make a film that had both few & one dimensional characters, far fetched incidents & without any emotional attachment to those depicted. I think it was a war film for beginners & teenagers ...not what I expected

Looked amazing but fundamentally flat & uninspiring

Not seen the film yet but that 2nd paragraph is spot on.