WBAUnofficial
SB moaning - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: SB moaning (/showthread.php?tid=8299)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: SB moaning - SW4Baggie - 01-12-2020

Slav’s West Ham side consistently struggled on set pieces and balls into the box...

The good thing is that he called out the players about lack of concentration and conceding skippy set piece goals after a few games this season and we improved almost immediately.

I don’t think we defend them as badly as some on here are making out, we defended numerous balls in against Leeds fine for example, we just got caught by a big and physical side yesterday.

(01-12-2020, 01:58 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I like zonal marking if you have players raised with it. In principle it is great, however when you have players raised on man marking it tends to fail.

Absolutely should have a man on each post imo though.

Teams that mark zonally and do it properly tend to concede far less than those that mark man for man, hence why the system is embraced by so many managers, however in the UK the shift tends to result in a season of adjustment where sloppy goals are gifted. 

We’ve spent over half a season working on it, if we move back to man to man we will still concede the same goals but we’ll have a player to slaughter for missing his header rather than a system.

I think we need to persevere, we will reap the rewards eventually, .


RE: SB moaning - Borin' Baggie - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 01:58 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I like zonal marking if you have players raised with it. In principle it is great, however when you have players raised on man marking it tends to fail.

Absolutely should have a man on each post imo though.

The problem with zonal marking is you need the right players to be covering a zone and the right players to track runners, players don't need to be raised on it as they pick it up in training. Bartley and Ajayi should not be in the 6 yard box, Sawyers should not be tracking the run of the opposition centre halves.

I do think that we should have one player up though, we're not really quick enough to counter at pace from corners as a team so teams aren't scared of that and crowd the box.


RE: SB moaning - Kit Kat Chunky - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 02:22 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(01-12-2020, 01:58 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I like zonal marking if you have players raised with it. In principle it is great, however when you have players raised on man marking it tends to fail.

Absolutely should have a man on each post imo though.

The problem with zonal marking is you need the right players to be covering a zone and the right players to track runners, players don't need to be raised on it as they pick it up in training. Bartley and Ajayi should not be in the 6 yard box, Sawyers should not be tracking the run of the opposition centre halves.

I do think that we should have one player up though, we're not really quick enough to counter at pace from corners as a team so teams aren't scared of that and crowd the box.

I would leave Kevin Bartlett and Goodman on the half way line, and wait for Talbot to pass it long  Smile


RE: SB moaning - baggy1 - 01-12-2020

Zonal marking or player marking means fuck all if the player hasn't readied himself. Look a Semi for the 1st yesterday and see how flat footed he is which ultimately means he doesn't get the height needed. He was lucky to be on the park for the 2nd so as much as he has been a revalation this year alongside Barts I would give him the best and one more game before bringing in Hegazi (if he stays).


RE: SB moaning - Tom Joad - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 02:31 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Zonal marking or player marking means fuck all if the player hasn't readied himself. Look a Semi for the 1st yesterday and see how flat footed he is which ultimately means he doesn't get the height needed. He was lucky to be on the park for the 2nd so as much as he has been a revalation this year alongside Barts I would give him the best and one more game before bringing in Hegazi (if he stays).

Valid point, IMO. Yesterday we had their giant, Sarri, hurtling into the box being covered by a player 6" shorter than him. By the time he gets to the ball, Ajayi  on the spot, is totally flat footed and unable to spring. Also, the scorer was given too much space by Bartley (I think). The second was ridiculously easy. The winger has time to pick a cross and the scorer gets a run in on Bartley. I hate to criticize our own but, for me Bartley is a good blocker but weak in the air, Hegazi is the better player and thus needs to start. We simply HAVE to improve our set piece defending as it is where 90% of our goals are conceded. Championship teams are nowhere near as clinical at finishing as the Prem, but they are causing us huge problems. Even at this level we need to score 2 goals a game, should we go up, who knows what we'll need?


RE: SB moaning - Toby Jugg - 01-12-2020

Zonal marking is one of the worst 'trendy' ideas of the last twenty years.

It just doesn't work.


RE: SB moaning - Kit Kat Chunky - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 07:53 PM)Toby Jugg Wrote: Zonal marking is one of the worst 'trendy' ideas of the last twenty years.

It just doesn't work.

It's like playing out from the back - only the very best can do it well.


RE: SB moaning - Birdman1811 - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 07:53 PM)Toby Jugg Wrote: Zonal marking is one of the worst 'trendy' ideas of the last twenty years.

It just doesn't work.

Almost all Italian clubs throughout their whole league system use it, and have done for years. It is technically a better system. However it takes a long time to get players bought up on Man Marking used to it, and it's a painful transition.


RE: SB moaning - 74bus - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 05:55 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(01-12-2020, 02:31 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Zonal marking or player marking means fuck all if the player hasn't readied himself. Look a Semi for the 1st yesterday and see how flat footed he is which ultimately means he doesn't get the height needed. He was lucky to be on the park for the 2nd so as much as he has been a revalation this year alongside Barts I would give him the best and one more game before bringing in Hegazi (if he stays).

Valid point, IMO. Yesterday we had their giant, Sarri, hurtling into the box being covered by a player 6" shorter than him. By the time he gets to the ball, Ajayi  on the spot, is totally flat footed and unable to spring. Also, the scorer was given too much space by Bartley (I think). The second was ridiculously easy. The winger has time to pick a cross and the scorer gets a run in on Bartley. I hate to criticize our own but, for me Bartley is a good blocker but weak in the air, Hegazi is the better player and thus needs to start. We simply HAVE to improve our set piece defending as it is where 90% of our goals are conceded. Championship teams are nowhere near as clinical at finishing as the Prem, but they are causing us huge problems. Even at this level we need to score 2 goals a game, should we go up, who knows what we'll need?
A few months ago it would have been ridiculous to suggest that a fit Hegazi would have to sit on the bench. Admittedly, Ajayi and Bartley have done well this season, but surely now it should just be a question of which of them loses out to Hegazi, who was our best defender last season.


RE: SB moaning - Ampadu's Left Boot - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 11:08 PM)74bus Wrote:
(01-12-2020, 05:55 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(01-12-2020, 02:31 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Zonal marking or player marking means fuck all if the player hasn't readied himself. Look a Semi for the 1st yesterday and see how flat footed he is which ultimately means he doesn't get the height needed. He was lucky to be on the park for the 2nd so as much as he has been a revalation this year alongside Barts I would give him the best and one more game before bringing in Hegazi (if he stays).

Valid point, IMO. Yesterday we had their giant, Sarri, hurtling into the box being covered by a player 6" shorter than him. By the time he gets to the ball, Ajayi  on the spot, is totally flat footed and unable to spring. Also, the scorer was given too much space by Bartley (I think). The second was ridiculously easy. The winger has time to pick a cross and the scorer gets a run in on Bartley. I hate to criticize our own but, for me Bartley is a good blocker but weak in the air, Hegazi is the better player and thus needs to start. We simply HAVE to improve our set piece defending as it is where 90% of our goals are conceded. Championship teams are nowhere near as clinical at finishing as the Prem, but they are causing us huge problems. Even at this level we need to score 2 goals a game, should we go up, who knows what we'll need?
A few months ago it would have been ridiculous to suggest that a fit Hegazi would have to sit on the bench. Admittedly, Ajayi and Bartley have done well this season, but surely now it should just be a question of which of them loses out to Hegazi, who was our best defender last season.

Yes, Hegazi was one of our best players last season and still is our best defender and should be coming back into the side now. He'll be almost like a new signing if and when he does win his place in the team back.