WBAUnofficial
Iran missile attacks & plane crash - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Iran missile attacks & plane crash (/showthread.php?tid=8241)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Iran missile attacks & plane crash - Derek Hardballs - 01-08-2020

(01-08-2020, 10:06 AM)albion_pigeon Wrote:
(01-08-2020, 08:37 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s ‘all good’ according to his last tweet, without even knowing if anyone was injured or killed. At least the UK is in a very strong position post Brexit to stand up to US and not get embroiled in a war that has / should have nothing to do with us.

<rings bell>

I know it’s great that our sovereignty is now so liberated from the EU that we shall do exactly as the US demands.


RE: Iran missile attacks & plane crash - Beano - 01-08-2020

Back to the strikes, hopefully someone can convince Trump that it is a score draw
And  not to escalate any further. The danger is that one of the militia or the
Revolutionary guard think more AmeRican blood needs spilling.


RE: Iran missile attacks & plane crash - Sotv - 01-08-2020

(01-08-2020, 04:37 PM)Beano Wrote: Back to the strikes, hopefully someone can convince Trump that it is a score draw
And  not to escalate any further. The danger is that one of the militia or the
Revolutionary guard think more AmeRican blood needs spilling.

No US casualties reported (maybe Trump did have that knowledge when he tweeted despite what some on here have stated? ). 
Personally I think this is where it may end for now. 
The Iranians have now shown their population they have struck back. I’m sure they will forget to mention no casualties,  and they will have some lovely pictures of missiles being launched for their TV propaganda. Their story will be “we have struck at the heart of the US military”
The Yanks have killed a top military commander who was responsible for a number of US and U.K. deaths as well as other actions. Their claim will be we have taken out a significant figure with just a token strike back that caused no harm. 
Both sides can claim to be victors, hopefully that puts an end to it.


RE: Iran missile attacks & plane crash - baggy1 - 01-09-2020

(01-08-2020, 07:47 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(01-08-2020, 04:37 PM)Beano Wrote: Back to the strikes, hopefully someone can convince Trump that it is a score draw
And  not to escalate any further. The danger is that one of the militia or the
Revolutionary guard think more AmeRican blood needs spilling.

No US casualties reported (maybe Trump did have that knowledge when he tweeted despite what some on here have stated? ). 
Personally I think this is where it may end for now. 
The Iranians have now shown their population they have struck back. I’m sure they will forget to mention no casualties,  and they will have some lovely pictures of missiles being launched for their TV propaganda. Their story will be “we have struck at the heart of the US military”
The Yanks have killed a top military commander who was responsible for a number of US and U.K. deaths as well as other actions. Their claim will be we have taken out a significant figure with just a token strike back that caused no harm. 
Both sides can claim to be victors, hopefully that puts an end to it.

I agree with all of that SOTV but there is one line in there that I haven't really understood (not trying to be awkward, just haven't followed the news close enough). Which deaths are we talking about here, my view was that the US were happy to let this mad dog run loose to deal with ISIS but I wasn't clear on what he had done to allied forces.


RE: Iran missile attacks & plane crash - Sotv - 01-09-2020

(01-09-2020, 09:35 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(01-08-2020, 07:47 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(01-08-2020, 04:37 PM)Beano Wrote: Back to the strikes, hopefully someone can convince Trump that it is a score draw
And  not to escalate any further. The danger is that one of the militia or the
Revolutionary guard think more AmeRican blood needs spilling.

No US casualties reported (maybe Trump did have that knowledge when he tweeted despite what some on here have stated? ). 
Personally I think this is where it may end for now. 
The Iranians have now shown their population they have struck back. I’m sure they will forget to mention no casualties,  and they will have some lovely pictures of missiles being launched for their TV propaganda. Their story will be “we have struck at the heart of the US military”
The Yanks have killed a top military commander who was responsible for a number of US and U.K. deaths as well as other actions. Their claim will be we have taken out a significant figure with just a token strike back that caused no harm. 
Both sides can claim to be victors, hopefully that puts an end to it.

I agree with all of that SOTV but there is one line in there that I haven't really understood (not trying to be awkward, just haven't followed the news close enough). Which deaths are we talking about here, my view was that the US were happy to let this mad dog run loose to deal with ISIS but I wasn't clear on what he had done to allied forces.

It won’t be direct conflict with allied forces that they are talking about. For a start he was the major general of the Quds forces, long seen as a terrorist organisation by the west. Imagine a kind of combination of CIA & special forces that could take part in clandestine operations. He specialised as well in “extra governmental” operations. 
He was also linked to a variety of organisations like Hezbollah.
I think what’s important to understand here is how the Iranian state uses lots of proxies to do its bidding and I believe the US thought he was involved in helping and directing terrorists that had attacked allied forces but couldn’t be directly traced back to the Iranian state.
It’s a very murky world where an enemy one week may be an ally the next, all depending on who is fighting who.


RE: Iran missile attacks & plane crash - baggy1 - 01-10-2020

Again I don't disagree with that, but you are buying the line that not only was he a bad guy (nobody is disputing that but that isn't a reason for taking him out), or that he was head of a clandestine operation that posed a threat (again no reason for taking him out - he's basically head of the Iranian version of the CIA) but the reason for taking him out lies in the line that he was responsible for a number of US and UK deaths - this is simply not obvious, but you choose to accept that line without question.

If the Iranians took out the head of the CIA how would you react?


RE: Iran missile attacks & plane crash - Sotv - 01-10-2020

(01-10-2020, 09:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Again I don't disagree with that, but you are buying the line that not only was he a bad guy (nobody is disputing that but that isn't a reason for taking him out), or that he was head of a clandestine operation that posed a threat (again no reason for taking him out - he's basically head of the Iranian version of the CIA) but the reason for taking him out lies in the line that he was responsible for a number of US and UK deaths - this is simply not obvious, but you choose to accept that line without question.

If the Iranians took out the head of the CIA how would you react?

its because he is involved with a number of terror groups and provided material support for their operations that killed westerners. He doesn't have to plant the bomb himself to be repsonsible. 
Maybe this will answer a few of your questions :
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/01/08/why-administration-claims-that-soleimani-killed-hundreds-americans/
To be honest, i couldn't care less if the Iranians killed the head of the CIA. In geopolitical terms he is probably as deserving of the same fate as the Iranian general.


RE: Iran missile attacks & plane crash - baggy1 - 01-10-2020

Thanks for the link, some interesting stuff in there and the Washington Post are not known for their support of The Don so that does add to the weight of it. On balance I agree this action is justified if, for no other reason, it stops Iran in their tracks and shows that the 'what can you do' attitude doesn't work when you have a Trump type character in charge. Hopefully the Iranian response is the end of it.


RE: Iran missile attacks & plane crash - spyro 123 - 01-10-2020

he literally prevented isis from taking even more territory in iraq and syria


RE: Iran missile attacks & plane crash - SausEggBaton - 01-10-2020

(01-10-2020, 02:13 PM)spyro 123 Wrote: he literally prevented isis from taking even more territory in iraq and syria

Trump or the Iranian General?