![]() |
|
Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! (/showthread.php?tid=7869) |
RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Derek Hardballs - 12-16-2019 Sorry but seeing an increase in the membership of the party is not the same as engaging the general populace. Labour continually forget this and they will never win an election again until they move back to the centre ground. The only hope is that in 5, 10yrs time people will be utterly sick of the lies, broken promises and empty presents they thought the Tories and Brexit were going to give them. RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Ossian - 12-16-2019 There would be a lot of support from those who regularly use the railways for the proposition of taking them back into public ownership. Some compelling evidence as well, based on those franchises which have had to revert to DfT control when private operators have failed. The process would also be gradual, relatively low-cost and could have been a vote-winner. Big chunks of our network are already run by state-owned operators from overseas and Network Rail, far from perfect though it may be, has considerably improved on the passenger safety record of its privatised predecessor. But to then bundle it in with much more costly propositions like water, gas, electricity and an off-the-cuff offer of free broadband just turned it into an open goal for Johnson's spinners and the Tory press. It didn't, in itself, cost the election but tactically it was a massive blunder. (12-16-2019, 04:40 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry but seeing an increase in the membership of the party is not the same as engaging the general populace. Labour continually forget this and they will never win an election again until they move back to the centre ground. Correct. Members are not reflective of most voters; particularly ambivalent swing voters. Half a million is an impressive figure for party membership, but it's barely 4% of the numbers needed to win an election. RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Ossian - 12-16-2019 (12-16-2019, 05:00 PM)Pickle Rick Wrote: I always thought the railways were a natural monopoly and should be run at a loss with low fares - as you more than get your money back into the evonomy from the increased mobility of workers and consumers plus the social benefits. Not sure how easy it would be to take them back though. I like using trains still despite all the criticism and I think people forget how good the network still is - but you have to be prepared in today's fast paced living you wont necessarily get from A to B as quick as by car. Much less difficult to take the railway franchises back into public ownership than would be the case with utilities; mainly because - being franchises - they have a pre-agreed expiry date. Far less complicated or costly than acquiring the ownership of PLCs and dealing with the issue of shareholder compensation values. Added to which there is already experience of what's involved, as a number of franchises have already failed (some more than once) and had to be rescued by the DfT via its Directly Operated Railways subsidiary. During its stint as a publicly-owned operator, East Coast railways regularly topped the customer satisfaction and punctuality stats for long-distance operators, and paid more than a £billion back to the DfT. My view is that some parts of the network - our local line into Snow Hill/Moor Street being an example - would be guaranteed to generate a surplus, as long as the fares are properly collected. Others, like The Highland Main Line or The Heart of Wales Line wouldn't - so treat them as a publicly-subsidised amenity if need be. I doubt many rail users would begrudge the arrangement. RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Derek Hardballs - 12-17-2019 I see Momentum have decided to go with ‘Team Becky’ Long Bailey. No Labour government for the next decade at least then. RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Ossian - 12-17-2019 (12-17-2019, 08:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I see Momentum have decided to go with ‘Team Becky’ Long Bailey. No Labour government for the next decade at least then. Oh aye, difficult as it might be to believe, the NEC and the unions really are that wilfully blind to what's just happened. Let's hope the membership have learned something from the experience; personally I'm not filled with optimism. RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Derek Hardballs - 12-17-2019 (12-17-2019, 09:01 AM)Ossian Wrote:(12-17-2019, 08:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I see Momentum have decided to go with ‘Team Becky’ Long Bailey. No Labour government for the next decade at least then. I’ve seen the nonsense on Twitter arrogance, stupidity, stubbornness, myopia, however best to describe it, it’s a recipe for failure to carry on with the same policies that have lost you two elections. We now have the term Blue Labour for anyone who isn’t wedded to the ideological group think of Momentum. It’s a complete lack of awareness with regards to how you go about winning elections. I get the feeling some like the comfort blanket of protest rather than the responsibility of power. Have you got your marker pen and placards ready comrades! RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Solihull Throstle - 12-17-2019 (12-16-2019, 04:40 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry but seeing an increase in the membership of the party is not the same as engaging the general populace. Labour continually forget this and they will never win an election again until they move back to the centre ground. Spot on. I have a close mate who is a dyed-in-the-wool Corbynite and a very intelligent bloke. It is impossible trying to point out that the British people will not elect a leftist Labour Party. He will always point out that it's all down to media bias and (dare I say) voter ignorance. This is the problem with his ilk. I would consider myself pretty left-wing but am happy to compromise and move to the centre to kick this arrogant, incompetent rabble out. He talks about Tory-lite, his hatred of Blair, increased party membership under Corbyn. Misses the point completely! Its going to be a bloody fight as these "sixth form politicos" are not going to have the party wrestled from them without a fight, even though they must see their way leads to a lifetime in opposition. RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - baggy1 - 12-17-2019 I see that Khalid Mahmood has put himself forward for deputy leader of the Labour party now. Fuck me, as if things aren't bad enough - can the labour party please not pick candidates in high profile positions that have an 'alledged' history that would make them easy pickings for the tories. RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Derek Hardballs - 12-17-2019 (12-17-2019, 01:34 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I see that Khalid Mahmood has put himself forward for deputy leader of the Labour party now. Fuck me, as if things aren't bad enough - can the labour party please not pick candidates in high profile positions that have an 'alledged' history that would make them easy pickings for the tories. Labour - Get stupid done RE: Labour inability to look itself in the mirror! - Sotv - 12-17-2019 (12-17-2019, 09:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(12-17-2019, 09:01 AM)Ossian Wrote:(12-17-2019, 08:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I see Momentum have decided to go with ‘Team Becky’ Long Bailey. No Labour government for the next decade at least then. That's definitely a part of the problem the left have right now. I saw a pic today on facebook that said something along the lines of blaming the working class voters who voted tory this time round for the usual scare stories the left love to put out. That is no way to tr and re-engage with people who have desserted you in droves. I truly believe a part of the rejection of labour had it roots in the social justice warriors on social media who screamed racist, stupid etc at anyone who thought differently to them and here they are again doing just the very same thing again. |