WBAUnofficial
Jovan Malcolm - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Jovan Malcolm (/showthread.php?tid=7366)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Jovan Malcolm - fuzzbox - 11-13-2019

(11-13-2019, 03:06 PM)WWHO Wrote:
(11-13-2019, 01:32 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: Don't we get £4m for Barrie(?)  if he's a success?

If that's the case (and I accept it might not be), it seems pretty reasonable. I can't imagine the academy staff on big money, so surely that covers a whole year and then some? We then have the rest of the crop to make something out of - for free.

I had a look at some of the other academy poachee's who we got upset about. I couldn't find one that's been a runaway success. Probably Chris Wood - and that's stretching the definitions of 'academy graduate' and 'poached'! For all the panic of harper leaving on a free, how much is he actually worth to the club? Obviously not much to the playing squad...

What we really should be concentrating on is a route to our first team. If we get them to play there, not only will less leave, they will also be worth more with first team appearances under their belts. 

...isn't that really the point of the academy, anyway?

Regardless, I don't think the issue is of youngsters leaving, it's more that none have actually been successful - with us or anyone else. That what we should be getting pissed off about.

There's the principle.  In a world where the 'haves' repeatedly riding roughshod over the 'have nots' with increasing cynicism, we are right to protest our powerlessness. 

RE the relative success of the players were have lost:  It's alright saying in hindsight they haven't found success at these clubs, but who's to say they wouldn't have here?

You're right about the first team route, but it's going to be difficult if the best are stolen off us and we're left with the also rans.

"There's the principle.  In a world where the 'haves' repeatedly riding roughshod over the 'have nots' with increasing cynicism, we are right to protest our powerlessness. "

Don't believe what they tell you. In footballing terms we are a 'have' rather than a 'have not'. There are far more youth teams 'below us' than 'above us'. We have repeatedly ridden roughshod over plenty of clubs. We didn't let 'principles' get in the way.


The only thing we have for certain is hindsight.  It's clutching at straws to say if they had of stayed they would have 'come good' 

Whilst we don't know what they could have achieved if they had stayed, we do know for certain that not one player has achieved anything from the academy - with or without us. Although not certain, surely the likelihood is they wouldn't have achieved if they had stayed? After all, nobody else did. Whichever way you look it, it's not a great success rate, is it?

Re the fee, The European exception needs to be addressed, but I still think the Rogers fee is fair (as it's stated here). Personally, I'd have taken it and used it for players we can use now. A bit like we did with Wood.

I've no idea what the answer is. Realistically, the chances are the first team will probably only have two proper spaces up for grabs over a season. Spread over 11 positions, is it even worth having an academy? Maybe if we can loan them out to develop to take them to the next stage, but that hasn't been a great success so far.

Maybe we'd be better off having a 'University' where they are closer to the first team and under contract. They'd cost more, but they would be worth more and there would be no 'leakages' as they are under contract. We could pick players where we know we have a short term weakness and even trump the bigger clubs by promising first team participation.

But wasn't this tried before? Didn't they call it the underbelly?

As it stands, we can't compete with the 'big' clubs. We also can't afford to keep loads of them on a players contract on the 'off-chance' they make good or can be sold to a loan club.
The only advantage we have is if we can actually play them, preferably with us or with 'useful' loans. Or maybe, to be boring, we offer them excellent academic schooling.


Whichever way, the bigger problem isn't the poaching (after all, we do it as well!), it's the fact that for whatever reason, the academy has a success rate of zero.


RE: Jovan Malcolm - Tom Joad - 11-13-2019

I don't agree with that, Fuzzbox. There's no doubt Izzy Brown was going to be successful AND we gave him a route to the first team. He still left, mind. I think SW has called it when he points out that Cat 1 academies are there to provide the best coaching therefore they shouldn't be allowed to poach from each other. Let's be honest here, it is both the national team (successful at most levels until the very top one), and the lad's sporting development that is hampered. These top clubs stockpiling young talent is a definite barrier to what Southgate is trying to achieve with England as they have no outlet to continue to develop.


RE: Jovan Malcolm - Pragmatist - 11-13-2019

We can’t stop the poaching and we won’t stop the poaching. If we lose a star Academy player every year to a bigger club and pocket £4m for a 16/17 year old who may or not make it, then at least our Academy is producing dividends which can be used to either invest in the first team squad or to strengthen the finances generally, but that’s a huge difference to picking up a pitiful £200k compensation, which is an insult.

Yes, we do it ourselves to smaller clubs, and the same principles should cascade down the pyramid.


RE: Jovan Malcolm - fuzzbox - 11-13-2019

(11-13-2019, 04:44 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I don't agree with that, Fuzzbox. There's no doubt Izzy Brown was going to be successful AND we gave him a route to the first team. He still left, mind.   I think SW has called it when he points out that Cat 1 academies are there to provide the best coaching therefore they shouldn't be allowed to poach from each other. Let's be honest here, it is both the national team (successful at most levels until the very top one), and the lad's sporting development that is hampered. These top clubs stockpiling young talent is a definite barrier to what Southgate is trying to achieve with England as they have no outlet to continue to develop.

Has Izzy Brown been successful? Yes, he earns more money, but footballing wise probably not, but that's probably what you meant. I was bothered when he left, but looking back, we probably got a small fee and saved on his contract. We didn't too badly on the deal.

Yes, we gave Brown, Thorne and Harper* first-team football - just before we offered them a contract. Would they have stayed in the team? To be honest, I thought it came across as cynical. Thorne publicly stated the same view.

Don't get me wrong, I do think things need changing, I just don't think it's the main reason our academy has failed to produce a single player of any merit.

As for the Cat 1 not being able to poach, I think it would be very hard to prevent the free movement of children and their parents! Also, it seems a little disingenuous to say you can't poach from us, but we're free to poach from elsewhere in the footballing league. I wouldn't want to be a part of that.



*Harper's an interesting one. I don't think we played him just to get a contract. But, I do think it's fair to say he hasn't done as well as we would have hoped - SO FAR. Maybe that's the challenge of predicting the success of youngsters? They're still growing up - I suppose that's one of the challenges of running an academy...


RE: Jovan Malcolm - Bloke who lives abroad - 11-13-2019

Too much money (and so, too much power) in too few hands.

Sadly that's the UK through and through.


RE: Jovan Malcolm - Kit Kat Chunky - 11-14-2019

When clubs like us close our Academies then it will change


RE: Jovan Malcolm - Babel - 11-14-2019

(11-13-2019, 09:47 PM)Bloke who lives abroad Wrote: Too much money (and so, too much power) in too few hands.

Sadly that's the UK through and through.

Is right, and the wider point. The poaching free market allows big clubs to create huge, virtually endless banks of talent while the rest go to blazes. SW4 is correct; regulaton is needed to stop the handful of clubs with comparatively unlimited  resources from gaming the talent system.


RE: Jovan Malcolm - fuzzbox - 11-14-2019

(11-14-2019, 05:13 AM)Pneumann Wrote:
(11-13-2019, 09:47 PM)Bloke who lives abroad Wrote: Too much money (and so, too much power) in too few hands.

Sadly that's the UK through and through.

Is right, and the wider point. The poaching free market allows big clubs to create huge, virtually endless banks of talent while the rest go to blazes. SW4 is correct; regulaton is needed to stop the handful of clubs with comparatively unlimited  resources from gaming the talent system.

But we are one of those clubs!! We've taken loads of 'students' from further down the footballing pyramid! I don't have the figures, but I bet we've taken more than we've had taken.

Let's not also forget they're children - they don't get paid. What about if their parents/guardians want/have to move to earn money for the family. How could you/would you stop that? If you make them sign a contract when they are old enough, you're back to the pre-bosman arguments - except this time with 17 year olds!


I agree with the wider point, but you just can't stop it - it's always been that way. ManU and FatRon did it to us 50 years ago. It's not just football - the haves have always exploited the have-nots. (hint - there's an election coming up...)


Instead of wasting time figuring out how to make kids stay against their will, or wishing a never-changing society will miraculously change to suit us, I think we should just look at ways to make our students WANT to stay.

In our world, the only way you can RELIABLY convince people to do something is by appealing to the selfish gene. The only thing we can offer above bigger teams is a greater probability of success - preferably in football, but if not, in life. That's what Crewe did for many years before their 'troubles'. As it stands we can't demonstrate any success at all on the footballing front - except as a stepping stone.

Worse - because we have had no real success stories their 'role models' are kids who have achieved no footballing success but financial wealth through leaving early.


RE: Jovan Malcolm - Pragmatist - 11-14-2019

I think it’s very simple. A fair and proper compensation system needs to exist, based on how many years a player has been in the Academy. This needs to apply exactly the same way whether it is bigger clubs poaching kids from our Academy, or us poaching kids from smaller clubs. And introducing proper compensation for poaching by one C1 Academy club from another C1 Academy club is the easiest and most obvious place to start.


RE: Jovan Malcolm - Johnnykayeengland - 11-14-2019

(11-14-2019, 11:17 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: I think it’s very simple.  A fair and proper compensation system needs to exist, based on how many years a player has been in the Academy.  This needs to apply exactly the same way whether it is bigger clubs poaching kids from our Academy, or us poaching kids from smaller clubs.  And introducing proper compensation for poaching by one C1 Academy club from another C1 Academy club is the easiest and most obvious place to start.

I think we would all agree with some sort of compensation scheme.

But the question that's begged-cos this has been going on for years - is why hasn't it been discussed (maybe it has) at FA / UEFA level & implented?