WBAUnofficial
Not deliberate handball say VAR today - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Not deliberate handball say VAR today (/showthread.php?tid=7336)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Not deliberate handball say VAR today - Colmanspig_ - 11-10-2019

I was sat in line with Jake Livermores winner. When it left his foot you just knew it was a goal. We celebrated like mad. My 8 year old jumped from his normal away fan postion (stood on the seat so he can see) right into my arms. Pure joy. This is why we stick with football. Anything that effects needs to be resisted. VAR is poison. get rid.

Those poor sheff U sods at spurs.


RE: Not deliberate handball say VAR today - CA Baggie - 11-10-2019

Goal like technology works, VAD doesn’t (yet).

They should scrap it until they can come up with some sort of consistent use and decision making.

It was always going to happen eventually, awaiting VAR and the other team goes and scores. It’s a fairly blatant handball too, little doubt it was a penalty. They bottled chalking the goal off and giving a penalty. It’s one thing when it’s between 2 top 6 sides but you know there’d be much less hesitation f Albion scored at Anfield following an obvious handball.

Same refs making shite decisions and backing each other up.


RE: Not deliberate handball say VAR today - quintonbaggie - 11-10-2019

(11-10-2019, 11:08 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Goal like technology works, VAD doesn’t (yet).

They should scrap it until they can come up with some sort of consistent use and decision making.

It was always going to happen eventually, awaiting VAR and the other team goes and scores.  It’s a fairly blatant handball too, little doubt it was a penalty.  They bottled chalking the goal off and giving a penalty.  It’s one thing when it’s between 2 top 6 sides but you know there’d be much less hesitation f Albion scored at Anfield following an obvious handball.  

Same refs making shite decisions and backing each other up.

Was exactly my comment (about whether if it was Albion...) when watching t with my lad. Plus the context of the FA Cup tie we won in spite of VAR - when which ever punter said ' Liverpool should have had a penalty and Salah should have been booked for diving'.


RE: Not deliberate handball say VAR today - Hopalong - 11-11-2019

(11-10-2019, 10:10 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(11-10-2019, 07:02 PM)Hopalong Wrote: re Alexander-Arnold....Mmmm...thought the rule had been changed by EUFA to if the ball hits the arm it's a pen??   Disgraceful.

Who was on the panel, a bunch of scousers?

Nah, it’s only a pen if the arms in an unnatural position. The law that’s changed is its a free kick if the forward scores with an accidental handball, or creates a goal from it. Defenders handling still has to be deliberate or unnatural position.

I haven’t seen the incident today though.

Well trust me the 1st claim was a definite pen, he moved his arm towards the ball.

Alexander-Arsehole moves his arm towards the ball.  Definite pen.  Of course Poo break away and score within 20 seconds.

 Can you imagine if the Poo goal was disallowed and brought back for a City pen?


RE: Not deliberate handball say VAR today - Bob Fossil - 11-11-2019

Stick 3 blokes in separate rooms and give them 30 secs each to review, if they time out, original decision stands. Majority rules.
If it's clear cut 30 secs should be enough, if not then it's not for VAR anyway.


RE: Not deliberate handball say VAR today - Dreamkiller - 11-11-2019

(11-11-2019, 11:27 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Stick 3 blokes in separate rooms and give them 30 secs each to review, if they time out, original decision stands. Majority rules.
If it's clear cut 30 secs should be enough, if not then it's not for VAR anyway.

Exactly. And presumably this is where the 'clear and obvious error' rule should come in.


RE: Not deliberate handball say VAR today - WWHO - 11-11-2019

I'm confused, is VAR secretly a conspiracy to hand Liverpool the league or not?