WBAUnofficial
RE the capacity/expansion debate. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: RE the capacity/expansion debate. (/showthread.php?tid=6111)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: RE the capacity/expansion debate. - Duffers - 08-17-2019

(08-17-2019, 11:55 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: How many on here who not attend games or attend very few for any reason, would be influenced by ground expansion.

Unless they expand 150 miles closer to me then it makes very little difference.

I never have any problems getting a ticket when I do come.


RE: RE the capacity/expansion debate. - cornishbaggie - 08-17-2019

(08-17-2019, 12:40 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote:
(08-17-2019, 11:55 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: How many on here who not attend games or attend very few for any reason, would be influenced by ground expansion.

Im not sure a yeah or neah to this is that relevant to the ground expansion debate. It wouldn't be fans on here who dont go (mostly for geographical reasons) that would be significant in filling a bigger stadium. Success or the anticipation of it and good marketing and targeting of fans is more important. Which requires positive thinking that we can be successful and grow and abandoning the Little Albion mantra constraint.

Can't say I agree, the whole point of the debate is if we expand, have we enough fans to regularly fill a larger ground. As you say there are a variety of reasons some fans don't attend, but they are fans none the less, they are just not the type that have to get to the game come what may, so I see little point in expanding to try to attract others to come and watch us that have nothing of the history the aforementioned have. As for success or indeed the perception of it, it's often pointed out we have spent eight seasons in the prem, but in reality we have had success in Albion context for seventeen years if you count promotions, play off's, an F A cup semi and total time in the prem, compare that with the previous seventeen years. In all that time, our attendant fanbase has rarely sold out. It is also getting harder and harder to attract live attendance, with wall to wall t v coverage and live streaming. So with that in mind any board would be insane to spend big to increase capacity with no guaranteed return. this is not West Brom's fault, it is football's.


RE: RE the capacity/expansion debate. - Remi_Moses - 08-17-2019

Although I'm France based I do spend time in the UK - I would like to see a reasonable priced hospitality suite. £250 for me and the Mrs is no longer VFM.
So yes I'm for expansion. To increase fans it has to be more family / community based IMO.


RE: RE the capacity/expansion debate. - lesley - 08-17-2019

(08-17-2019, 12:23 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(08-17-2019, 12:21 PM)Squid Wrote: The Halfords is also uncomfortable to sit in currently as there's hardly any legroom. An expansion would help that and I'd be tempted to move from the Brummie.

Halfords is the only place I've never sat, is it much worse than BRE?

I wouldn't expect the legroom to improve much though, SME & West are pretty bad for leg room (well if you're over 6' everywhere in the ground is terrible for it.)

It’s far worse than anywhere else in the ground. I’m only 5 feet 4 and my knees almost touch the seat in front of me. My 6 foot 2 son won’t even use my free ticket if I’m on holiday and can’t go. He prefers to pay and sit elsewhere because of the extremely limited legroom.


RE: RE the capacity/expansion debate. - Baggiejacko - 08-17-2019

I ain't going up the Albion till:-
Peace has gone
Pulis has gone
The ground is bigger
Some other bollox


RE: RE the capacity/expansion debate. - Birdman1811 - 08-17-2019

More seats doesn't stop my massive round trip and the expenses involved in that


RE: RE the capacity/expansion debate. - chasetownbaggie - 08-17-2019

(08-17-2019, 01:12 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(08-17-2019, 12:40 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote:
(08-17-2019, 11:55 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: How many on here who not attend games or attend very few for any reason, would be influenced by ground expansion.

Im not sure a yeah or neah to this is that relevant to the ground expansion debate. It wouldn't be fans on here who dont go (mostly for geographical reasons) that would be significant in filling a bigger stadium. Success or the anticipation of it and good marketing and targeting of fans is more important. Which requires positive thinking that we can be successful and grow and abandoning the Little Albion mantra constraint.

Can't say I agree, the whole point of the debate is if we expand, have we enough fans to regularly fill a larger ground. As you say there are a variety of reasons some fans don't attend, but they are fans none the less, they are just not the type that have to get to the game come what may, so I see little point in expanding to try to attract others to come and watch us that have nothing of the history the aforementioned have. As for success or indeed the perception of it, it's often pointed out we have spent eight seasons in the prem, but in reality we have had success in Albion context for seventeen years if you count promotions, play off's, an F A cup semi and total time in the prem, compare that with the previous seventeen years. In all that time, our attendant fanbase has rarely sold out. It is also getting harder and harder to attract live attendance, with wall to wall t v coverage and live streaming. So with that in mind any board would be insane to spend big to increase capacity with no guaranteed return. this is not West Brom's fault, it is football's.

So why are other clubs expanding their grounds? Sorry cornish, but I just think not expanding the ground is myopic. Whatever our stadium size since the turn of the millenium, I think out average has consistently been about 95% of capacity in the Prem and 90% in the chump. I don't go as often as I want (for a variety of reasons) but I know there have been times I haven't gone because I couldn't get 2 seats together.


RE: RE the capacity/expansion debate. - cornishbaggie - 08-17-2019

(08-17-2019, 04:15 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(08-17-2019, 01:12 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(08-17-2019, 12:40 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote:
(08-17-2019, 11:55 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: How many on here who not attend games or attend very few for any reason, would be influenced by ground expansion.

Im not sure a yeah or neah to this is that relevant to the ground expansion debate. It wouldn't be fans on here who dont go (mostly for geographical reasons) that would be significant in filling a bigger stadium. Success or the anticipation of it and good marketing and targeting of fans is more important. Which requires positive thinking that we can be successful and grow and abandoning the Little Albion mantra constraint.

Can't say I agree, the whole point of the debate is if we expand, have we enough fans to regularly fill a larger ground. As you say there are a variety of reasons some fans don't attend, but they are fans none the less, they are just not the type that have to get to the game come what may, so I see little point in expanding to try to attract others to come and watch us that have nothing of the history the aforementioned have. As for success or indeed the perception of it, it's often pointed out we have spent eight seasons in the prem, but in reality we have had success in Albion context for seventeen years if you count promotions, play off's, an F A cup semi and total time in the prem, compare that with the previous seventeen years. In all that time, our attendant fanbase has rarely sold out. It is also getting harder and harder to attract live attendance, with wall to wall t v coverage and live streaming. So with that in mind any board would be insane to spend big to increase capacity with no guaranteed return. this is not West Brom's fault, it is football's.

So why are other clubs expanding their grounds? Sorry cornish, but I just think not expanding the ground is myopic. Whatever our stadium size since the turn of the millenium, I think out average has consistently been about 95% of capacity in the Prem and 90% in the chump. I don't go as often as I want (for a variety of reasons) but I know there have been times I haven't gone because I couldn't get 2 seats together.

That actually furthers my point mate, as I said there are many fans that don't go for various reasons, so upgrading won't change that and it certainly isn't worth upgrading on the off chance someone wants to go but can't get 2 seats together. As for myopic, I can't see how it can be when there are rarely if ever outside obvious games, fans clambering for home tickets that are not there.


RE: RE the capacity/expansion debate. - TETLEY74 - 08-17-2019

if we turned the Hawthorns into a 32k stadium over night how many think we would get any where near 30k on wed against reading or Blackburn next home on a sat ?


RE: RE the capacity/expansion debate. - Baggiejacko - 08-17-2019

I believe that the clubs aim is in X amount of years to be established and higher profile in the Prem so we need a 40k+ stadium. If so building a paltry in comparison 32k stadium that isn't needed is a waste of resources. Most crowd increases have coincided with newly built stadia not slowly grown ones. We remember about success stories of ground moves but forget about bad ones. We talk about local rivals with envy but omit Coventry. Top flight for years, sold their old ground, moved to shiny new stadium, tits up, got no where to go now and sharing with fookin Blues.