WBAUnofficial
For those saying scrap the academy - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: For those saying scrap the academy (/showthread.php?tid=5315)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: For those saying scrap the academy - Stevel Knievel - 07-09-2019

(07-08-2019, 08:42 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Balanced post alert!
Jack Fitzwater, Dara O'Shea, Kyle Edwards, Jonathan Leko, Josh Griffiths, Rayhaan Tulloch and Kane Wilson have all travelled to Spain.
Not all of them leave us! 
It’s not papering over the disappointment of Barry and possibly Rogers but a bit of pre season pant wetting is par for the course. 
 

Also worth adding in Berahino, Brown, Thorne, Roofe & Roberts the Academy bought in c. £18-20m


RE: For those saying scrap the academy - fuzzbox - 07-09-2019

There's no point railing at society and greedy players/agents etc. That's never going to change, so we have to work within it.
However, the european loophole should obviously close. 230k isn't enough.
But - we don't know how much we will be getting with Rogers - if he goes. I'm betting it's not 230k.
The academy has probably turned a profit with the ridiculous fee for fatboy alone. All the rest is just gravy.

Anyhow, I do believe the high profile leavers could be good news. As a means to attract new players and junior transfers, we can demonstrate success (no matter how bitter it is for us).

But we should make some enhancements:

We should look at more ways of instilling loyalty INSIDE the academy so they invest emotionally in the club and their teammates

Demonstrate the clubs loyalty to them, by providing for teammates that don't quite make it. Educational support, outplacements at less successful academies, local clubs, even work placements at local companies, if football isn't for them

Provide a commitment and mechanism for a legitimate pathway to the first team. We don't really have one, nor does any other club. The club sees this, but still just pays lip-service - train with the club, travel with the club etc. The link should be stronger so they feel like they are part of the team rather than an academy located somewhere else. As an example, how many times have we heard, "it was great they got to train with the first team"? This shouldn't be a one-off to celebrate. They should be working as much as possible with the senior squad, so they can see that they are already part of this club and see where they want to be. Importantly, it also gives them unrivalled exposure to the manager. Good for both sides.

I really feel we are on the right track. With a few enhancements we could pull in the best young talents from across UK and it seems with our new recognition - Europe!


RE: For those saying scrap the academy - Remi_Moses - 07-09-2019

Now that's a lesson in positive thinking - great post.


RE: For those saying scrap the academy - chasetownbaggie - 07-09-2019

It's not a case of closing down the Academy, it's more a case that the FA and UEFA grow some bollox and make clubs appropriately compensate the clubs who have nurtured a young talent. 230k at a time when transfer fees are inflating at pace is an insult. Some of the ideas put forward on the Rogers thread are good. A healthy chunk of any future sell ons or hitting specific milestones would be fair. It's galling enough not ever getting the chance to see these players flourish wearing the stripes, being given peanuts is a kick in the goolies.


RE: For those saying scrap the academy - fuzzbox - 07-09-2019

(07-09-2019, 09:32 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: It's not a case of closing down the Academy, it's more a case that the FA and UEFA grow some bollox and make clubs appropriately compensate the clubs who have nurtured a young talent. 230k at a time when transfer fees are inflating at pace is an insult. Some of the ideas put forward on the Rogers thread are good. A healthy chunk of any future sell ons or hitting specific milestones would be fair. It's galling enough not ever getting the chance to see these players flourish wearing the stripes, being given peanuts is a kick in the goolies.

From what I remember, one of the components in the FA arbitrated transfer fee already is a sell on clause and hitting specific milestones. The fees are going up and I 'think' I remember reading you're looking at north of 2 million - more if you've actually played them.

You've got to wonder if our "wunderkid" that's going to Spain is so good, why Liverpool, City et al weren't willing to risk £2m on him? Maybe because at the moment, he may be worth more than £230k, but not £2m...

The European loophole has to be stopped, but at the moment it's an exception rather than a rule and we receive substantially more in most cases. Including all the clauses that people are asking for.


RE: For those saying scrap the academy - Stig of the Dump - 07-09-2019

Man City agree £8m deal for West Brom kid Morgan Rogers in biggest transfer for a 16-year-old since Theo Walcott joined Arsenal – The Sun https://www.thesun.co.uk/sport/football/9467707/man-city-west-brom-morgan-rogers/

It is the Sun!


RE: For those saying scrap the academy - Derek Hardballs - 07-09-2019

The problem for us is we will only ever bring through and play the average youth players we develop. We will lose the top players to richer clubs and we shall discard the poorer players to Walsall etc. This doesn’t move us forward it doesn’t allow for the pie in the sky ‘projects’ I’ve heard so much about, unless the project is to bring through kids that are ok at this level but will perhaps struggle at the higher level.


RE: For those saying scrap the academy - MGalea - 07-09-2019

If we get £8m for him then that's great (especially as we may get him back in a couple of years to blood) but makes Barry going for so little a big kick in the nuts.


RE: For those saying scrap the academy - Three Degrees - 07-09-2019

(07-09-2019, 11:21 AM)MGalea Wrote: If we get £8m for him then that's great (especially as we may get him back in a couple of years to blood) but makes Barry going for so little a big kick in the nuts.

Money is no good in the bank or in this case Lai's back pocket .Weve just raked in over 30 mill when the Rondon n JRod deals go through  but Bilic will be lucky if he gets 10 mill . The squad is down to the bare bones and all it seems about at the moment is how much money we can save  . Im sick of the club pleading poverty and being run by a bunch of amateurs .


RE: For those saying scrap the academy - fuzzbox - 07-09-2019

(07-09-2019, 11:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The problem for us is we will only ever bring through and play the average youth players we develop. We will lose the top players to richer clubs and we shall discard the poorer players to Walsall etc. This doesn’t move us forward it doesn’t allow for the pie in the sky ‘projects’ I’ve heard so much about, unless the project is to bring through kids that are ok at this level but will perhaps struggle at the higher level.

Couldn't you argue the same about all of our players? And everybody's players? Don't the best always leave? You just hope that whilst they're with you, they raise the bar of everyone else in the club so that last years 'best' are now only 'ok' compared to the current crop.