RE: VAR - SW4Baggie - 07-02-2019
(07-02-2019, 09:02 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: VAR is going to kill the game.
That or the offside rule is going to have to have some serious revision. VAR is providing the ability for referees to disallow goals for which the offside rules were never intended to be applied. When it comes down to small bit of players anatomy being deemed to be offside you know there is something wrong with the way in which VAR is being applied.
And what happen to the concept that VAR was only to be used for clear and obvious mistakes, that idea has suffered the early death that was always inevitable.
Wait till they extend, as they will, the types of incidents that can be subject to VAR - games will regularly last longer than 100 minutes, don't expect a Saturday 3 o'clock kick off game to finish anytime before 5 o'clock in future.
There is increasingly much to recommend the Championship.
I couldn’t disagree more.
VAR has been introduced because as the rewards and speed at which the game moves increases relying on humans to officiate when there are more accurate systems is silly
The offside rule states any part of the body by which the ball can be legitimately played, which was exactly why she was offside. The rule is an absolute, you either are or aren’t. Andy Gray and other Pundits may want to believe it’s all about daylight or advantages but it’s not. If any part of your body that can play the ball is even a fraction of a millimetre ahead, you’re offside. As soon as you deviate from this you open a whole can of worms that’s impossible to police. Much like with the ball crossing the line.
Both the decisions that involved VAR tonight got the correct result, and in a game as big as this that’s all you can ask. I appreciate the amount of time some decisions take needs work, but I’d sooner they used it than not.
People saying football is being ruined by it are just overreacting to something new. I wish we’d had it in the playoff semis... we’d be looking at PL football now and the Vile would be going into a long long wilderness..
(07-02-2019, 09:17 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Totally agree VAR is more trouble than it's worth. What I have noticed about this here Womens World Cup is this;
Passes are the difference (to the male game), the power/pace of the ball is so much slower.
Goalkeeping also looks weak
They don't act up, dive, roll around as much. Grealish would be useless in the Ladies game.
The refs allow you to push someone over when they are wasting time at the corner flag. (I'm all for that).
Jonathon Pearce is annoying at whatever he does.
Any way..What is it with England and semi finals?
Without wanting to be flippant about the women’s game, the goals and the pitches need to be smaller. There is nothing technical and tactical a female player cannot do as well as a male one given the same resources and coaching, however they will never be as strong, fast or as physically big as male players.
Compared to some of the top male goalies the average female keeper is a foot smaller, but defending the same area. No amount of coaching will overcome that.
RE: VAR - CA Baggie - 07-02-2019
(07-02-2019, 09:20 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-02-2019, 09:02 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: VAR is going to kill the game.
I couldn’t disagree more.
VAR has been introduced because as the rewards and speed at which the game moves increases relying on humans to officiate when there are more accurate systems is silly
The offside rule states any part of the body by which the ball can be legitimately played, which was exactly why she was offside. The rule is an absolute, you either are or aren’t. Andy Gray and other Pundits may want to believe it’s all about daylight or advantages but it’s not. If any part of your body that can play the ball is even a fraction of a millimetre ahead, you’re offside. As soon as you deviate from this you open a whole can of worms that’s impossible to police. Much like with the ball crossing the line.
Both the decisions that involved VAR tonight got the correct result, and in a game as big as this that’s all you can ask. I appreciate the amount of time some decisions take needs work, but I’d sooner they used it than not.
People saying football is being ruined by it are just overreacting to something new. I wish we’d had it in the playoff semis... we’d be looking at PL football now and the Vile would be going into a long long wilderness..
We didn’t agree last summer and we won’t agree this. The offside goal should have been allowed and the penalty shouldn’t have been given.
Neither were clear and obvious mistakes so why go to VAR.
It doesn’t always provide the right decision either, only a partial correction. USA scored against Chile from a corner - except it should have been a goal kick. So much for VAR.
Spoils the game fir those that attend, probably great for a neutral.
Fuck VAR.
RE: VAR - Tom Joad - 07-02-2019
(07-02-2019, 09:20 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-02-2019, 09:02 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: VAR is going to kill the game.
That or the offside rule is going to have to have some serious revision. VAR is providing the ability for referees to disallow goals for which the offside rules were never intended to be applied. When it comes down to small bit of players anatomy being deemed to be offside you know there is something wrong with the way in which VAR is being applied.
And what happen to the concept that VAR was only to be used for clear and obvious mistakes, that idea has suffered the early death that was always inevitable.
Wait till they extend, as they will, the types of incidents that can be subject to VAR - games will regularly last longer than 100 minutes, don't expect a Saturday 3 o'clock kick off game to finish anytime before 5 o'clock in future.
There is increasingly much to recommend the Championship.
I couldn’t disagree more.
VAR has been introduced because as the rewards and speed at which the game moves increases relying on humans to officiate when there are more accurate systems is silly
The offside rule states any part of the body by which the ball can be legitimately played, which was exactly why she was offside. The rule is an absolute, you either are or aren’t. Andy Gray and other Pundits may want to believe it’s all about daylight or advantages but it’s not. If any part of your body that can play the ball is even a fraction of a millimetre ahead, you’re offside. As soon as you deviate from this you open a whole can of worms that’s impossible to police. Much like with the ball crossing the line.
Both the decisions that involved VAR tonight got the correct result, and in a game as big as this that’s all you can ask. I appreciate the amount of time some decisions take needs work, but I’d sooner they used it than not.
People saying football is being ruined by it are just overreacting to something new. I wish we’d had it in the playoff semis... we’d be looking at PL football now and the Vile would be going into a long long wilderness..
(07-02-2019, 09:17 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Totally agree VAR is more trouble than it's worth. What I have noticed about this here Womens World Cup is this;
Passes are the difference (to the male game), the power/pace of the ball is so much slower.
Goalkeeping also looks weak
They don't act up, dive, roll around as much. Grealish would be useless in the Ladies game.
The refs allow you to push someone over when they are wasting time at the corner flag. (I'm all for that).
Jonathon Pearce is annoying at whatever he does.
Any way..What is it with England and semi finals?
Without wanting to be flippant about the women’s game, the goals and the pitches need to be smaller. There is nothing technical and tactical a female player cannot do as well as a male one given the same resources and coaching, however they will never be as strong, fast or as physically big as male players.
Compared to some of the top male goalies the average female keeper is a foot smaller, but defending the same area. No amount of coaching will overcome that. That's about right, fella. Overall I've quite enjoyed it, particularly the lack of acting and diving.
RE: VAR - Peachy - 07-02-2019
VAR is absolutely ruining the game. The only thing that was ever needed was goal line technology. After all that is the most important thing. The act of the ball crossing the line is all that matters and was always the biggest injustice when not spotted. (Rotherham at home springs to mind for us in our promotion season when Jordao's header wasn't given which meant the 11 point dingle choke could have been ruined)
Ruling goals out for someone's little toe being 2cm ahead of someone else's is just ridiculous.
They need to seriously review it. The early weeks of the Prem next season is going to be hilarious.
RE: VAR - Dreamkiller - 07-02-2019
If you're a neutral, VAR adds to the theatre and drama which is why it's here to stay. It's a global televisual game now where the vast majority of spectators have no close connection with the teams and haven't invested so much of their time and emotional energy in following their side.
But for supporters whose days, weekends or whole summers can be ruined or celebrated by the events during games, I'm afraid VAR takes away more than it adds.
We all want to take away the injustices of the Maradona or Henry handballs, and VAR will do that. But it also throws the baby away with the bath water. That euphoric feeling of seeing the ball hit the net followed by a quick look at the ref and the linesman 'just to be on the safe side' will be replaced almost by a feeling of dread as you wait to see if you're allowed to celebrate. By the time you know you are, that moment will have passed. It's just not the same.
That instant feeling is, for me, one of the greatest feelings known to people who love their club more than they love football itself. VAR will kill that. We all want to see the right decisions, but the price is too big in my opinion.
RE: VAR - SW4Baggie - 07-02-2019
(07-02-2019, 09:29 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (07-02-2019, 09:20 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-02-2019, 09:02 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: VAR is going to kill the game.
I couldn’t disagree more.
VAR has been introduced because as the rewards and speed at which the game moves increases relying on humans to officiate when there are more accurate systems is silly
The offside rule states any part of the body by which the ball can be legitimately played, which was exactly why she was offside. The rule is an absolute, you either are or aren’t. Andy Gray and other Pundits may want to believe it’s all about daylight or advantages but it’s not. If any part of your body that can play the ball is even a fraction of a millimetre ahead, you’re offside. As soon as you deviate from this you open a whole can of worms that’s impossible to police. Much like with the ball crossing the line.
Both the decisions that involved VAR tonight got the correct result, and in a game as big as this that’s all you can ask. I appreciate the amount of time some decisions take needs work, but I’d sooner they used it than not.
People saying football is being ruined by it are just overreacting to something new. I wish we’d had it in the playoff semis... we’d be looking at PL football now and the Vile would be going into a long long wilderness..
We didn’t agree last summer and we won’t agree this. The offside goal should have been allowed and the penalty shouldn’t have been given.
Neither were clear and obvious mistakes so why go to VAR.
It doesn’t always provide the right decision either, only a partial correction. USA scored against Chile from a corner - except it should have been a goal kick. So much for VAR.
Spoils the game fir those that attend, probably great for a neutral.
Fuck VAR.
The offside goal was offside, it shouldn’t have been given. There is too much of a grey area around offside goals which have been costing clubs the correct decisions for a long time.. yes they may well even out, but why chance It when something can definitively be proven right or wrong? The fact it was offside and had been given incorrectly as a goal is as clear and obvious mistake as you want.
VAR needs to remove the “clear and obvious error” wording and just be accepted that it will be used to check goals, red cards and penalties as it will always be used for that.
I don’t buy the argument it spoils the game either... it sees the occasional goal ruled out that wouldn’t normally be given, in the same way goal line technology gives them... yet no one seems to claim that soils it for the fans in attendance...it’s a low scoring game, so people will always bemoan anything that rules out a goal, but when it gets the right decision far more times than wrong I can’t see how it ruins it... I really see no reason why this dystopian future of everyone being scared to celebrate a goal will happen, 99% of goals have no hint of a reason to disallow then anyway... and it’s not like it doesn’t happen already.
You have your opinion, and I have mine. I have no issue with us disagreeing, but in matters of offside the system is 100% correct to be applied.
(07-02-2019, 09:36 PM)Peachy Wrote: Ruling goals out for someone's little toe being 2cm ahead of someone else's is just ridiculous.
They need to seriously review it. The early weeks of the Prem next season is going to be hilarious.
Then you change the rule, not the system. Make the rule so that it has to be 5cm?
Don’t have a rule that says one thing, introduce a system that manages it and then moan the system ruins the game.
(07-02-2019, 09:49 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: If you're a neutral, VAR adds to the theatre and drama which is why it's here to stay. It's a global televisual game now where the vast majority of spectators have no close connection with the teams and haven't invested so much of their time and emotional energy in following their side.
But for supporters whose days, weekends or whole summers can be ruined or celebrated by the events during games, I'm afraid VAR takes away more than it adds.
We all want to take away the injustices of the Maradona or Henry handballs, and VAR will do that. But it also throws the baby away with the bath water. That euphoric feeling of seeing the ball hit the net followed by a quick look at the ref and the linesman 'just to be on the safe side' will be replaced almost by a feeling of dread as you wait to see if you're allowed to celebrate. By the time you know you are, that moment will have passed. It's just not the same.
That instant feeling is, for me, one of the greatest feelings known to people who love their club more than they love football itself. VAR will kill that. We all want to see the right decisions, but the price is too big in my opinion.
I agree there are some kinks to work out with when it’s applied but I just don’t get the emotional argument about the thrill of goals being removed.
At the WC in Russia there were 64 games, yielding 164 goals... VAR was used 33 times, mostly for penalties... 6 goals were reviewed and 5 were ruled out. That’s 3%... over the course of a season with Pulis in charge that’s probably only one a year!
RE: VAR - CA Baggie - 07-02-2019
(07-02-2019, 09:50 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-02-2019, 09:29 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (07-02-2019, 09:20 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-02-2019, 09:02 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: VAR is going to kill the game.
I couldn’t disagree more.
VAR has been introduced because as the rewards and speed at which the game moves increases relying on humans to officiate when there are more accurate systems is silly
The offside rule states any part of the body by which the ball can be legitimately played, which was exactly why she was offside. The rule is an absolute, you either are or aren’t. Andy Gray and other Pundits may want to believe it’s all about daylight or advantages but it’s not. If any part of your body that can play the ball is even a fraction of a millimetre ahead, you’re offside. As soon as you deviate from this you open a whole can of worms that’s impossible to police. Much like with the ball crossing the line.
Both the decisions that involved VAR tonight got the correct result, and in a game as big as this that’s all you can ask. I appreciate the amount of time some decisions take needs work, but I’d sooner they used it than not.
People saying football is being ruined by it are just overreacting to something new. I wish we’d had it in the playoff semis... we’d be looking at PL football now and the Vile would be going into a long long wilderness..
We didn’t agree last summer and we won’t agree this. The offside goal should have been allowed and the penalty shouldn’t have been given.
Neither were clear and obvious mistakes so why go to VAR.
It doesn’t always provide the right decision either, only a partial correction. USA scored against Chile from a corner - except it should have been a goal kick. So much for VAR.
Spoils the game fir those that attend, probably great for a neutral.
Fuck VAR.
The offside goal was offside, it shouldn’t have been given. There is too much of a grey area around offside goals which have been costing clubs the correct decisions for a long time.. yes they may well even out, but why chance It when something can definitively be proven right or wrong? The fact it was offside and had been given incorrectly as a goal is as clear and obvious mistake as you want.
VAR needs to remove the “clear and obvious error” wording and just be accepted that it will be used to check goals, red cards and penalties as it will always be used for that.
I don’t buy the argument it spoils the game either... it sees the occasional goal ruled out that wouldn’t normally be given, in the same way goal line technology gives them... yet no one seems to claim that soils it for the fans in attendance...it’s a low scoring game, so people will always bemoan anything that rules out a goal, but when it gets the right decision far more times than wrong I can’t see how it ruins it... I really see no reason why this dystopian future of everyone being scared to celebrate a goal will happen, 99% of goals have no hint of a reason to disallow then anyway... and it’s not like it doesn’t happen already.
You have your opinion, and I have mine. I have no issue with us disagreeing, but in matters of offside the system is 100% correct to be applied.
(07-02-2019, 09:36 PM)Peachy Wrote: Ruling goals out for someone's little toe being 2cm ahead of someone else's is just ridiculous.
They need to seriously review it. The early weeks of the Prem next season is going to be hilarious.
Then you change the rule, not the system. Make the rule so that it has to be 5cm?
Don’t have a rule that says one thing, introduce a system that manages it and then moan the system ruins the game.
Having to watch several replays and draw lines across the pitch to see if a stud is ahead of someone else’s is pedantic to the extreme and against the ethos of VAR being introduced. It was sold as clearing up the (clear &) obvious errors that we can all see from the stands and has already become much, more more than that. And it doesn’t achieve the correct decisions as proven by the USA/Chile game.
As for the off-side rule! Players can be yards offside then have a square ball played to them to tap in and it stands. A stud on a through ball and it’s disallowed. The offside rule is worthy of its own thread - if you’re on the pitch in a traditional offside position then you’re offside. Second phase bollocks.
I could accept if VAR maybe had a rule of daylight/half a body to make it clear and obvious, some of these off side decisions are a screen pixel from a wrong decision. Cricket has umpire’s original call on 1/2 ball LBWs.
RE: VAR - bradesbaggie - 07-03-2019
When will we ever learn? You only have to pin this up in the dressing room and forget the pep talk!
RE: VAR - lesley - 07-03-2019
(07-02-2019, 09:49 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: If you're a neutral, VAR adds to the theatre and drama which is why it's here to stay. It's a global televisual game now where the vast majority of spectators have no close connection with the teams and haven't invested so much of their time and emotional energy in following their side.
But for supporters whose days, weekends or whole summers can be ruined or celebrated by the events during games, I'm afraid VAR takes away more than it adds.
We all want to take away the injustices of the Maradona or Henry handballs, and VAR will do that. But it also throws the baby away with the bath water. That euphoric feeling of seeing the ball hit the net followed by a quick look at the ref and the linesman 'just to be on the safe side' will be replaced almost by a feeling of dread as you wait to see if you're allowed to celebrate. By the time you know you are, that moment will have passed. It's just not the same.
That instant feeling is, for me, one of the greatest feelings known to people who love their club more than they love football itself. VAR will kill that. We all want to see the right decisions, but the price is too big in my opinion.
Exactly this! Toatally agree with everything said above by Dreamkiller.
Was having this argument last night with my hubby and he just doesn’t get it. He follows the Albion but isn’t what I call a “true supporter.”
I think the ball crossing the line technology is great, but am really not convinced by VAR.
RE: VAR - MassDebater - 07-03-2019
VAR leads to such long delays that the old American idea of four quarters will no doubt be bought back up again soon. Then it'll be extended to allow for ad breaks, during VAR calls, and VAR will be used for far more to allow the ad breaks to be implemented.
VAR is bad, humans are not computers and allowances have to be made. The USA shouldn't have been given a penalty in their previous match, England shouldn't have got one last night. The offside was just about correct. The Keepers saving then having to re-face penalties was stupid, what about the players encroaching being ignored?
Football is about emotion and bad calls are part of that.
If they want 100% accurate calls with no human interaction, then they may as well start computers off playing FIFA against each other and televising that.
|