WBAUnofficial
Why I'm not stressing. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Why I'm not stressing. (/showthread.php?tid=4925)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: Why I'm not stressing. - Peachy - 06-07-2019

(06-07-2019, 06:13 AM)clem4england Wrote: I am not stressed about it but the point a couple of days ago that the profile and style of all of the potential candidates is so varied that we don’t appear to have a clear idea of how we want to play is certainly very valid.

But wouldn't we leave the "style" of play up to the manager? What's it got to do with Dowling/Jenkins how we play?

Surely it's right that we look for the best candidates from a managerial sense and then leave it up to him to determine is own system.

We've had plenty of successful seasons down the years by loads of different managers playing hugely varying styles of football.

Megson, RDM, Mowbray, Clarke, Pulis etc all played different styles and systems.


RE: Why I'm not stressing. - Shabby Russian - 06-07-2019

(06-06-2019, 07:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’m not stressing because there is fuck all I can do about the decision.

This. Plus what do I know anyway about the suitability of any particular candidate's ability to manage our club at this moment in time.

They will eventually appoint someone, I might have a superficial opinion on how good they are and then they will in all probability spend their tenure proving my opinion wrong.


RE: Why I'm not stressing. - Ed Hopper - 06-07-2019

(06-07-2019, 06:31 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(06-06-2019, 07:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’m not stressing because there is fuck all I can do about the decision.

This. Plus what do I know anyway about the suitability of any particular candidate's ability to manage our club at this moment in time.

They will eventually appoint someone, I might have a superficial opinion on how good they are and then they will in all probability spend their tenure proving my opinion wrong.
Optimist!


RE: Why I'm not stressing. - KratosBaggie - 06-07-2019

(06-06-2019, 06:52 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I know through Social Media land there is a lot of pant wetting about our manager search. However I am not joining in, we are actively interviewing a wide array of candidates, my biggest issue with the last few managerial appointments has been the lack of thought and time spent, instead it was a shortlist of one or two, get that person and that was it. A process I'm not a fan of. 

Until the playoff loss we had no idea what division we'd be in, Shan did an exceptional job in horrible circumstances and therefore the board could spend time planning for both eventualities, promotion or another Championship season. Once we knew we got interviewing, the list is evolving as different people become interested and available, as IMO it should the players are on holiday, so would be any manager we hired right now. If Dowling has been doing his job correctly, we should have a decent set of possible targets to present to the new man, with his own input of course. 

I have no doubt we'll have someone in place soon, and at least this time I'll be happy that we've actually looked at a lot of possible options, talked to a lot of people and decided what we really wanted this time, not just taken an easy choice. 

Hughton remains my favourite though Bilic would be a good choice if he is ready to get back into it all. But most the names mentioned would intrigue me for different reasons, and I mean the realistic ones, not Ziz's head names.
You'll get no where on here with well reasoned and thought out posts like this.


RE: Why I'm not stressing. - Huggybear - 06-07-2019

My concern is that the list of managers are very much varied from style of play ,experience to no experience,foreign manager or British manager.Is Dowling looking at the budget and the pennies first and if so then how can we expect to attract a top class manager.I keep saying it but getting a top class manager in is vital and one of the most important decision to make.Lord help us if we get another Pardew or appoint Bilic.


RE: Why I'm not stressing. - Psalm23 - 06-07-2019

(06-06-2019, 07:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’m not stressing because there is fuck all I can do about the decision.

+1

Always been my approach to all things Albion, actually it's pretty much my approach to everything in life, regarding issues I have fuck all control over.  Que sera sera  Cool


RE: Why I'm not stressing. - HeathAyIt - 06-07-2019

(06-07-2019, 05:48 AM)The liquidator Wrote: The communication between the club and the fan base is very shoddy they really take the raving piss out of us . How can we really trust them as they have really fucked up the last 4/5 seasons in a manager and recruitment they are simply not up to the job .

Plus one.

I think we are in a terrible state at the top and it will get a lot worse before it gets better.


RE: Why I'm not stressing. - Birdman1811 - 06-07-2019

(06-07-2019, 07:06 AM)Huggybear Wrote: My concern is that the list of managers are very much varied from style of play ,experience to no experience,foreign manager or British manager.Is Dowling looking at the budget and the pennies first and if so then how can we expect to attract a top class manager.I keep saying it but getting a top class manager in is vital and one of the most important decision to make.Lord help us if we get another Pardew or appoint Bilic.

Since if anything the names being mentioned are getting more expensive I'd say its not just getting the cheap option. 

Don't get why Bilic is labelled with Pardew at all, he'd be a good choice imo.


RE: Why I'm not stressing. - Statto - 06-07-2019

(06-07-2019, 05:48 AM)The liquidator Wrote: The communication between the club and the fan base is very shoddy they really take the raving piss out of us . How can we really trust them as they have really fucked up the last 4/5 seasons in a manager and recruitment they are simply not up to the job .

There have been different people at different times over the last five years, some of whom bear great responsibility and are no longer in post. Not disputing it hasn’t gone well at all recently, however..... 

Please tell me exactly what the club should have said about the current manager search other than what they actually have, which was that they are trying to get the right man and the fans need to allow them to complete that job. 

They could have appointed Cowley three weeks ago. He wanted it. It would have shown the decisive action and this perceived sense of direction so many are demanding. 

The same people would then be in meltdown of epic proportions if Bilic, Hughton, Labbadia and others  then rocked up at other clubs a week or two later. 

Getting it right is more important than getting it done quickly in this case. We can’t comment until it’s done. 

This apparent expectation that the club are going to publish the diary of a manager search on the website is laughable. Literally anything they said right now would be turned into a negative by the social media brigade. 

Apparently, the whole board, coaching staff and most of the players should fuck off out of our club immediately. I’m not 100% sure how that translates into getting the right manager and finishing as high as possible. 

There are lots of populistic soundbites being shouted very loudly with very little worthwhile substance about what people would actually do differently. It’s all very Farage-esque and equally as tiresome.


RE: Why I'm not stressing. - CA Baggie - 06-07-2019

(06-07-2019, 06:21 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(06-07-2019, 06:13 AM)clem4england Wrote: I am not stressed about it but the point a couple of days ago that the profile and style of all of the potential candidates is so varied that we don’t appear to have a clear idea of how we want to play is certainly very valid.

But wouldn't we leave the "style" of play up to the manager? What's it got to do with Dowling/Jenkins how we play?

Surely it's right that we look for the best candidates from a managerial sense and then leave it up to him to determine is own system.

We've had plenty of successful seasons down the years by loads of different managers playing hugely varying styles of football.

Megson, RDM, Mowbray, Clarke, Pulis etc all played different styles and systems.

My take Peachy is that if we’re bringing a Head Coach in and we have a club scouting structure, as opposed to a few hangers on of the manager, then they should be looking for certain types of players that fit a particular style of play.  We’re not buying the best players in the world, they all have something missing in their game which is why they end up at Albion and not Real Madrid.   That jigsaw needs to be put together in consideration of the playing style.

There’s no point buying, say Kyle Bartley, only to appoint someone who wants to play a passing out from the back style of play.  Or say an out and out winger like Montero and then play 3 at the back.

It’s not a project or philosophy as Softbollocks would label it, it’s a well thought out strategy to have the scouts actually looking at certain types of players and building dossiers up on these, rather than lurching from one style to another.  We can’t afford to reshape the squad every time a manger leaves.

At the moment we have a group of players and I’ve no idea what system or style would get the best out of them, we’re all over the place and it’s one of the biggest reasons why we’re in the position we’re in - failed to get promotion from the Champ.