RE: Villa FFP - B36baggie - 05-31-2019
(05-31-2019, 07:22 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: The key point is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations to enable the assessment to be made in the third year of the 3-year cycle, having recognised that it’s far too late if the breach by them isn’t disclosed until next March when their accounts for this season are filed.
Now we just need the EFL to actually apply those regulations.
It is why Villa, Derby, Wednesday and Blues have had to file monthly financial updates to the EFL in recent months. If it is found, as it will surely be, that Villa have been allowed to be promoted whilst massively breaking the rules, the mother of all legal battles against the EFL by other clubs will break out. Gibson is quite right to have lit the touchpaper.
It would appear that for the 2017/18 3-year calculation, Villa just scraped through by making FFP losses of £59.4m when they were allowed to lose £61m for that 3-year period. For the 2018-19 3-year period their maximum 3-year loss reduces to £39m because all 3 seasons were in the EFL. Based on the first 2 seasons of that cycle, their maximum loss for the season was £7m. They lost nearly 4 times that figure in 2017/18 when they had around £20m more parachute funding than they had in 2018/9. With that reduced income, and with their big wage bill, there is not a cat in hell’s chance that they have only made FFP losses of £7m in 2018/9, and unless they have been blatantly lying to the EFL, they are in major difficulty.
The one sole possibility is that they sell Villa Park for a huge profit since the end of the season (and before the end of their financial year) to reverse the FFP loss. Any such sale has to be carried out for fair market value with independent valuations. I just cannot see any other way out of it for them.
I saw recently that Villa Park ownership has been moved so they most likely are shifting it in a similar way to Derby.
RE: Villa FFP - Pragmatist - 05-31-2019
(05-31-2019, 07:54 AM)B36baggie Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:22 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: The key point is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations to enable the assessment to be made in the third year of the 3-year cycle, having recognised that it’s far too late if the breach by them isn’t disclosed until next March when their accounts for this season are filed.
Now we just need the EFL to actually apply those regulations.
It is why Villa, Derby, Wednesday and Blues have had to file monthly financial updates to the EFL in recent months. If it is found, as it will surely be, that Villa have been allowed to be promoted whilst massively breaking the rules, the mother of all legal battles against the EFL by other clubs will break out. Gibson is quite right to have lit the touchpaper.
It would appear that for the 2017/18 3-year calculation, Villa just scraped through by making FFP losses of £59.4m when they were allowed to lose £61m for that 3-year period. For the 2018-19 3-year period their maximum 3-year loss reduces to £39m because all 3 seasons were in the EFL. Based on the first 2 seasons of that cycle, their maximum loss for the season was £7m. They lost nearly 4 times that figure in 2017/18 when they had around £20m more parachute funding than they had in 2018/9. With that reduced income, and with their big wage bill, there is not a cat in hell’s chance that they have only made FFP losses of £7m in 2018/9, and unless they have been blatantly lying to the EFL, they are in major difficulty.
The one sole possibility is that they sell Villa Park for a huge profit since the end of the season (and before the end of their financial year) to reverse the FFP loss. Any such sale has to be carried out for fair market value with independent valuations. I just cannot see any other way out of it for them.
I saw recently that Villa Park ownership has been moved so they most likely are shifting it in a similar way to Derby.
It will be very interesting indeed to see the value attributed to the sale.
RE: Villa FFP - Logic1 - 05-31-2019
(05-31-2019, 07:57 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:54 AM)B36baggie Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:22 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: The key point is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations to enable the assessment to be made in the third year of the 3-year cycle, having recognised that it’s far too late if the breach by them isn’t disclosed until next March when their accounts for this season are filed.
Now we just need the EFL to actually apply those regulations.
It is why Villa, Derby, Wednesday and Blues have had to file monthly financial updates to the EFL in recent months. If it is found, as it will surely be, that Villa have been allowed to be promoted whilst massively breaking the rules, the mother of all legal battles against the EFL by other clubs will break out. Gibson is quite right to have lit the touchpaper.
It would appear that for the 2017/18 3-year calculation, Villa just scraped through by making FFP losses of £59.4m when they were allowed to lose £61m for that 3-year period. For the 2018-19 3-year period their maximum 3-year loss reduces to £39m because all 3 seasons were in the EFL. Based on the first 2 seasons of that cycle, their maximum loss for the season was £7m. They lost nearly 4 times that figure in 2017/18 when they had around £20m more parachute funding than they had in 2018/9. With that reduced income, and with their big wage bill, there is not a cat in hell’s chance that they have only made FFP losses of £7m in 2018/9, and unless they have been blatantly lying to the EFL, they are in major difficulty.
The one sole possibility is that they sell Villa Park for a huge profit since the end of the season (and before the end of their financial year) to reverse the FFP loss. Any such sale has to be carried out for fair market value with independent valuations. I just cannot see any other way out of it for them.
I saw recently that Villa Park ownership has been moved so they most likely are shifting it in a similar way to Derby.
It will be very interesting indeed to see the value attributed to the sale.
https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/aston-villa-just-posted-update-16353909
RE: Villa FFP - Pragmatist - 05-31-2019
(05-31-2019, 08:01 AM)Logic1 Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:57 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:54 AM)B36baggie Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:22 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: The key point is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations to enable the assessment to be made in the third year of the 3-year cycle, having recognised that it’s far too late if the breach by them isn’t disclosed until next March when their accounts for this season are filed.
Now we just need the EFL to actually apply those regulations.
It is why Villa, Derby, Wednesday and Blues have had to file monthly financial updates to the EFL in recent months. If it is found, as it will surely be, that Villa have been allowed to be promoted whilst massively breaking the rules, the mother of all legal battles against the EFL by other clubs will break out. Gibson is quite right to have lit the touchpaper.
It would appear that for the 2017/18 3-year calculation, Villa just scraped through by making FFP losses of £59.4m when they were allowed to lose £61m for that 3-year period. For the 2018-19 3-year period their maximum 3-year loss reduces to £39m because all 3 seasons were in the EFL. Based on the first 2 seasons of that cycle, their maximum loss for the season was £7m. They lost nearly 4 times that figure in 2017/18 when they had around £20m more parachute funding than they had in 2018/9. With that reduced income, and with their big wage bill, there is not a cat in hell’s chance that they have only made FFP losses of £7m in 2018/9, and unless they have been blatantly lying to the EFL, they are in major difficulty.
The one sole possibility is that they sell Villa Park for a huge profit since the end of the season (and before the end of their financial year) to reverse the FFP loss. Any such sale has to be carried out for fair market value with independent valuations. I just cannot see any other way out of it for them.
I saw recently that Villa Park ownership has been moved so they most likely are shifting it in a similar way to Derby.
It will be very interesting indeed to see the value attributed to the sale.
https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/aston-villa-just-posted-update-16353909
The change of directors looks like an attempt to show independence between the club and the company which will buy the stadium.
Unless Recon files a resolution to change its financial year end from 31st May, the sale needs to complete today. The 2018 accounts show that the stadium has a depreciated value of around £38m. If their “normal” losses are otherwise similar to last season’s, but with £19m less parachute funding than in 2017/18, then the stadium sale price is probably going to need to be in the region of £75m to £80m to make them FFP-compliant.
RE: Villa FFP - Peachy - 05-31-2019
(05-31-2019, 08:01 AM)Logic1 Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:57 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:54 AM)B36baggie Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:22 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: The key point is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations to enable the assessment to be made in the third year of the 3-year cycle, having recognised that it’s far too late if the breach by them isn’t disclosed until next March when their accounts for this season are filed.
Now we just need the EFL to actually apply those regulations.
It is why Villa, Derby, Wednesday and Blues have had to file monthly financial updates to the EFL in recent months. If it is found, as it will surely be, that Villa have been allowed to be promoted whilst massively breaking the rules, the mother of all legal battles against the EFL by other clubs will break out. Gibson is quite right to have lit the touchpaper.
It would appear that for the 2017/18 3-year calculation, Villa just scraped through by making FFP losses of £59.4m when they were allowed to lose £61m for that 3-year period. For the 2018-19 3-year period their maximum 3-year loss reduces to £39m because all 3 seasons were in the EFL. Based on the first 2 seasons of that cycle, their maximum loss for the season was £7m. They lost nearly 4 times that figure in 2017/18 when they had around £20m more parachute funding than they had in 2018/9. With that reduced income, and with their big wage bill, there is not a cat in hell’s chance that they have only made FFP losses of £7m in 2018/9, and unless they have been blatantly lying to the EFL, they are in major difficulty.
The one sole possibility is that they sell Villa Park for a huge profit since the end of the season (and before the end of their financial year) to reverse the FFP loss. Any such sale has to be carried out for fair market value with independent valuations. I just cannot see any other way out of it for them.
I saw recently that Villa Park ownership has been moved so they most likely are shifting it in a similar way to Derby.
It will be very interesting indeed to see the value attributed to the sale.
https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/aston-villa-just-posted-update-16353909
This is fucking unbelievable. So this is the loophole and the reason Purslow was so smuggly confident Villa were going to be ok!
They sell their ground to a newco set up by their own fucking owners. What an absolute fucking whitewash. At least Derby did it quietly whilst hoping no one would notice.
Villa just do it now and brazenly laugh.
Something has to be done surely. Every Champ club should get together on this and ask for action....Or failing that ask that this can now be fair game for all clubs to do it.
We all know the outcome. They will get away with it and then the efl will close down the loophole for everyone else.
Cunts....the lot of 'em. I can't abide smug cheats.
RE: Villa FFP - Logic1 - 05-31-2019
(05-31-2019, 08:11 AM)Peachy Wrote: (05-31-2019, 08:01 AM)Logic1 Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:57 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:54 AM)B36baggie Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:22 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: The key point is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations to enable the assessment to be made in the third year of the 3-year cycle, having recognised that it’s far too late if the breach by them isn’t disclosed until next March when their accounts for this season are filed.
Now we just need the EFL to actually apply those regulations.
It is why Villa, Derby, Wednesday and Blues have had to file monthly financial updates to the EFL in recent months. If it is found, as it will surely be, that Villa have been allowed to be promoted whilst massively breaking the rules, the mother of all legal battles against the EFL by other clubs will break out. Gibson is quite right to have lit the touchpaper.
It would appear that for the 2017/18 3-year calculation, Villa just scraped through by making FFP losses of £59.4m when they were allowed to lose £61m for that 3-year period. For the 2018-19 3-year period their maximum 3-year loss reduces to £39m because all 3 seasons were in the EFL. Based on the first 2 seasons of that cycle, their maximum loss for the season was £7m. They lost nearly 4 times that figure in 2017/18 when they had around £20m more parachute funding than they had in 2018/9. With that reduced income, and with their big wage bill, there is not a cat in hell’s chance that they have only made FFP losses of £7m in 2018/9, and unless they have been blatantly lying to the EFL, they are in major difficulty.
The one sole possibility is that they sell Villa Park for a huge profit since the end of the season (and before the end of their financial year) to reverse the FFP loss. Any such sale has to be carried out for fair market value with independent valuations. I just cannot see any other way out of it for them.
I saw recently that Villa Park ownership has been moved so they most likely are shifting it in a similar way to Derby.
It will be very interesting indeed to see the value attributed to the sale.
https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/aston-villa-just-posted-update-16353909
This is fucking unbelievable. So this is the loophole and the reason Purslow was so smuggly confident Villa were going to be ok!
They sell their ground to a newco set up by their own fucking owners. What an absolute fucking whitewash. At least Derby did it quietly whilst hoping no one would notice.
Villa just do it now and brazenly laugh.
Something has to be done surely. Every Champ club should get together on this and ask for action....Or failing that ask that this can now be fair game for all clubs to do it.
We all know the outcome. They will get away with it and then the efl will close down the loophole for everyone else.
Cunts....the lot of 'em. I can't abide smug cheats.
We pay money to watch a competition that has integrity. As far as I'm concerned this is akin to doping, all be it financial. Was FFP set up to to create incentives like this? Whereby clubs sell grounds that they have owned for 100s of years to owners who could just fuck off any minute and sell the ground to a supermarket chain. How on earth can they be allowed to get away with it. The Albion won't want to do anything though because we may end up resorting to this. If that is the case, I'm not sure I want to watch this farce anymore.
RE: Villa FFP - Kit Kat Chunky - 05-31-2019
This.
But they will have to pay market rent, which on an £80m stadium should be c£5M. Add this to their wage bill, and P&S rules of c£70M wages then they are in for a struggle next year.
RE: Villa FFP - Logic1 - 05-31-2019
(05-31-2019, 08:40 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: This.
But they will have to pay market rent, which on an £80m stadium should be c£5M. Add this to their wage bill, and P&S rules of c£70M wages then they are in for a struggle next year.
My mate reckons they can just inject equity to pay off all the debts. I'm not an accountant. Can they do that?
RE: Villa FFP - SW4Baggie - 05-31-2019
(05-31-2019, 08:40 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: This.
But they will have to pay market rent, which on an £80m stadium should be c£5M. Add this to their wage bill, and P&S rules of c£70M wages then they are in for a struggle next year.
They *SHOULD* be in for a struggle, but if the farce of the last 12 months has taught us anything, it's that the rules only apply if you choose to follow them.
The fact the play off final was allowed to be contested by two clubs under investigation for financial irregularities is absolutely absurd, let alone one of them now being allowed to clear all of the hurdles their over spending and cheating had brought on.
As I said before, the PL won't want to devalue their brand by creating an uncompetitive side through embargos, and certainly wont want the bad international press of a points deduction, and the EFL needing hand me downs from the PL more than ever will run off quietly when told "yeah we're not going to enforce anything" by the big boys upstairs.
RE: Villa FFP - Pragmatist - 05-31-2019
(05-31-2019, 08:43 AM)Logic1 Wrote: (05-31-2019, 08:40 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: This.
But they will have to pay market rent, which on an £80m stadium should be c£5M. Add this to their wage bill, and P&S rules of c£70M wages then they are in for a struggle next year.
My mate reckons they can just inject equity to pay off all the debts. I'm not an accountant. Can they do that?
Let’s be clear - they aren’t in financial difficulty any more. They are merely in FFP difficulty. Injecting equity is something they’ve already done and their balance sheet is now in good shape. But it makes no difference to their FFP position, as that relates to what they can spend, irrespective of how wealthy their backers are.
(05-31-2019, 08:37 AM)Logic1 Wrote: (05-31-2019, 08:11 AM)Peachy Wrote: (05-31-2019, 08:01 AM)Logic1 Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:57 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (05-31-2019, 07:54 AM)B36baggie Wrote: I saw recently that Villa Park ownership has been moved so they most likely are shifting it in a similar way to Derby.
It will be very interesting indeed to see the value attributed to the sale.
https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/aston-villa-just-posted-update-16353909
This is fucking unbelievable. So this is the loophole and the reason Purslow was so smuggly confident Villa were going to be ok!
They sell their ground to a newco set up by their own fucking owners. What an absolute fucking whitewash. At least Derby did it quietly whilst hoping no one would notice.
Villa just do it now and brazenly laugh.
Something has to be done surely. Every Champ club should get together on this and ask for action....Or failing that ask that this can now be fair game for all clubs to do it.
We all know the outcome. They will get away with it and then the efl will close down the loophole for everyone else.
Cunts....the lot of 'em. I can't abide smug cheats.
We pay money to watch a competition that has integrity. As far as I'm concerned this is akin to doping, all be it financial. Was FFP set up to to create incentives like this? Whereby clubs sell grounds that they have owned for 100s of years to owners who could just fuck off any minute and sell the ground to a supermarket chain. How on earth can they be allowed to get away with it. The Albion won't want to do anything though because we may end up resorting to this. If that is the case, I'm not sure I want to watch this farce anymore.
The new owners of the stadium won’t be able to “sell the ground to a supermarket chain” because the club would be granted a long term lease on arms length commercial terms.
Bear in mind that a club can’t sell their ground twice. Once it’s sold, it’s sold. They are stuck now with paying a commercial rent throughout the lease, which eats into the budget otherwise available for wages. What happens next time they have an FFP loss to cover in the future? The family silver will no longer be there to bail them out. It’s a one-off “get out of jail card” for every club to play if they ever need to. But once it’s been played, that’s it.
It is perfectly legitimate. Selling an asset for a gain is fine, whether it’s a player or whether it’s the stadium. But it doesn’t sit well.
|