WBAUnofficial
Steven Reid - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Steven Reid (/showthread.php?tid=4809)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Steven Reid - Hopalong - 05-29-2019

(05-28-2019, 10:11 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-28-2019, 09:40 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote: Good luck to them. Clarke like Moore for me deserved more time when they hit a slump. Especially when the replacement recruitment was so hit and miss and amateur. Makes the sackings look just knee jerk and unprofessional.

It shows you how important Prem money was to our respective owners at the time.

We must be one of the most disliked clubs in the whole country at the moment. 

Very sad.  

We did dump the likes of Clarke and Moore - even though it looked like they had lost it - maybe they just needed a bit of time to sort things out?  We'll never know. 

And yet we kept Pulis 2 yrs longer than we should have - but of course we all know why.  Thank you Baldilocks, you fucking greedy prick.

We're a fucking shambles and laughing stock.  Embarassing.


RE: Steven Reid - Squid - 05-29-2019

(05-29-2019, 12:23 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(05-28-2019, 10:11 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-28-2019, 09:40 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote: Good luck to them. Clarke like Moore for me deserved more time when they hit a slump. Especially when the replacement recruitment was so hit and miss and amateur. Makes the sackings look just knee jerk and unprofessional.

It shows you how important Prem money was to our respective owners at the time.

We must be one of the most disliked clubs in the whole country at the moment. 

Very sad.  

We did dump the likes of Clarke and Moore - even though it looked like they had lost it - maybe they just needed a bit of time to sort things out.  We'll never know. 

And yet we kept Pulis 2 yrs longer than we should have - but of course we all know why.  

What a fucking shambles.  Embarassing.

We aren't really on people's radar enough for that.

However, sacking Moore is one of those decisions that made sense to those who know the club, but not to click-bate mongerers who don't. Particularly as Moore in his public appearances has been such a shining beacon of dignity.


RE: Steven Reid - KratosBaggie - 05-29-2019

(05-28-2019, 09:40 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote: Good luck to them. Clarke like Moore for me deserved more time when they hit a slump. Especially when the replacement recruitment was so hit and miss and amateur. Makes the sackings look just knee jerk and unprofessional.

Steve Clarke lost a succession of games covering the back end of one season and the beginning of another season.

Now, I'm interested in Birdman's comments, and would ask where he got that information from, as it would partly explain why Clarke went from 4th in November, to losing a lot of games which saw us limp to 8th, and then saw us fighting relegation the season after.

Darren Moore lost 2 games and drew 1. It's hardly a fair comparison.


RE: Steven Reid - Birdman1811 - 05-29-2019

(05-29-2019, 07:09 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(05-28-2019, 09:40 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote: Good luck to them. Clarke like Moore for me deserved more time when they hit a slump. Especially when the replacement recruitment was so hit and miss and amateur. Makes the sackings look just knee jerk and unprofessional.

Steve Clarke lost a succession of games covering the back end of one season and the beginning of another season.

Now, I'm interested in Birdman's comments, and would ask where he got that information from, as it would partly explain why Clarke went from 4th in November, to losing a lot of games which saw us limp to 8th, and then saw us fighting relegation the season after.

Darren Moore lost 2 games and drew 1. It's hardly a fair comparison.

It was pretty well known at the time. 

Mcdonough and Clarke didn't get on back from their days at Liverpool together. McDonut really, really fucked this club over. Unsubscribed from the scouting systems Ashworth had in place losing years of scouting data, replaced that with an excel spreadsheet. 

After every single game, win lose or draw went to Peace with everything Clarke did wrong, bearing in mind in that summer he was one of the guilty parties for why we couldn't get players in. Partly due to the destruction of our scouting data. He wanted to be the key man at the club and wanted to make us into a completely different type of team, bearing in mind we had a squad built a certain way by Ashworth, RDM, Hodgson and Clarke. 

Clarke became very nervous, the players saw him being undermined, he didn't have the squad he was promised and he became too.scated.of losing, leading to the chaos towards the end of his time. All he wanted that summer was a player to replace the power of Lukaku, an inside forward to replace Odemwingie, or sort his head out, and a clever wide player to cover and replace Gera. All things Ashworth would have probably found. We bought on Anichebe, Anelka, Sessegnon, Sinclair and Amalfiltano. Anelka was his mistake, but Ashworth would have probably said no, as he would have done with chasing an uninterested Kalou all summer, Clarke was a head coach, not a manager, his input in transfers should have been, pick one of these. Not give names.

He made mistakes yes, but we made the environment for him so hostile here, he was basically being shat on constantly, he was moaned at after we beat Man Utd for the style of play ffs. 

As always, choose to believe me if you want or don't, it came from a player at the club at the time, but I swore to not reveal who since they are still playing, though elsewhere. But these are the facts as I have been able to understand them by what's been told to me, with a lot of it also seconded from other places too.


RE: Steven Reid - KratosBaggie - 05-29-2019

(05-29-2019, 07:55 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-29-2019, 07:09 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(05-28-2019, 09:40 PM)Thurso Pickle Rick Wrote: Good luck to them. Clarke like Moore for me deserved more time when they hit a slump. Especially when the replacement recruitment was so hit and miss and amateur. Makes the sackings look just knee jerk and unprofessional.

Steve Clarke lost a succession of games covering the back end of one season and the beginning of another season.

Now, I'm interested in Birdman's comments, and would ask where he got that information from, as it would partly explain why Clarke went from 4th in November, to losing a lot of games which saw us limp to 8th, and then saw us fighting relegation the season after.

Darren Moore lost 2 games and drew 1. It's hardly a fair comparison.

It was pretty well known at the time. 

Mcdonough and Clarke didn't get on back from their days at Liverpool together. McDonut really, really fucked this club over. Unsubscribed from the scouting systems Ashworth had in place losing years of scouting data, replaced that with an excel spreadsheet. 

After every single game, win lose or draw went to Peace with everything Clarke did wrong, bearing in mind in that summer he was one of the guilty parties for why we couldn't get players in. Partly due to the destruction of our scouting data. He wanted to be the key man at the club and wanted to make us into a completely different type of team, bearing in mind we had a squad built a certain way by Ashworth, RDM, Hodgson and Clarke. 

Clarke became very nervous, the players saw him being undermined, he didn't have the squad he was promised and he became too.scated.of losing, leading to the chaos towards the end of his time. All he wanted that summer was a player to replace the power of Lukaku, an inside forward to replace Odemwingie, or sort his head out, and a clever wide player to cover and replace Gera. All things Ashworth would have probably found. We bought on Anichebe, Anelka, Sessegnon, Sinclair and Amalfiltano. Anelka was his mistake, but Ashworth would have probably said no, as he would have done with chasing an uninterested Kalou all summer, Clarke was a head coach, not a manager, his input in transfers should have been, pick one of these. Not give names.

He made mistakes yes, but we made the environment for him so hostile here, he was basically being shat on constantly, he was moaned at after we beat Man Utd for the style of play ffs. 

As always, choose to believe me if you want or don't, it came from a player at the club at the time, but I swore to not reveal who since they are still playing, though elsewhere. But these are the facts as I have been able to understand them by what's been told to me, with a lot of it also seconded from other places too.

Thanks for that, interesting post. I'll take it with a pinch of salt, which is now reflection on yourself, but it does add up.


RE: Steven Reid - Birdman1811 - 05-29-2019

I'd expect you to.

It's why I defend Clarke a lot though. Had we replaced Ashworth properly, continued down that road as we were, I think Clarke would have got us into Europe in time, but we wanted to replace Ashworth, the main man at the club, as cheap as possible, with a wage a Championship DoF would say no to.


RE: Steven Reid - KratosBaggie - 05-29-2019

(05-29-2019, 08:15 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'd expect you to.

It's why I defend Clarke a lot though. Had we replaced Ashworth properly, continued down that road as we were, I think Clarke would have got us into Europe in time, but we wanted to replace Ashworth, the main man at the club, as cheap as possible, with a wage a Championship DoF would say no to.

In hindsight losing Ashworth fucked us up. I'm not sure whether he'd come back, but the club should pay him whatever he wants. He's worth the price.


RE: Steven Reid - Birdman1811 - 05-29-2019

I think there is some truth in the old adage, never go back.

We'd expect very quick miracles from Ashworth but it took him a long time to get it right, and part of that was bringing an experienced man in Roy to the club to get him to look over stuff too.


RE: Steven Reid - Birdman1811 - 05-29-2019

There are others out there, Dowling may be a good choice yet, this summer is going to be telling for him, gets it wrong we are in real trouble, but the potential to get it right and prove himself is there.