WBAUnofficial
Rattings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Rattings (/showthread.php?tid=43126)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Rattings - Carlos Quiver - 10-24-2026

(10-24-2026, 04:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: MOL - 7 - 2 good but expected saves. Did his job. 

Pereira - 6 - Some good some bad. Like a wish.com AWB. 
Mepham - 6 - Solid enough and good in possession
Campbell - 6 - More Erratic, but wins so many duels and drives us in well. Good partnership developing with Meps. 
Styles - 8 - Really good understated performance. No mistakes, defended well, got forward, passed progressively. Very good. 

Whitwell - 5 - Stinker. If we can do some business in Jan he needs another loan. 
Molumby - 8 (MoTM) - Everything bar a goal threat. As good as he's got and it's good enough when he plays like that. Great ball for the equaliser too. 
Diakite - 8 - Excellent, won so many headers and really helped us with some of their more direct play especially at the start of the second half. 
Price - 8 - Even when he doesn't score or assist his contribution is massive. Always a threat and always grafts. 

Myhre - 7 - Busy, some lovely touches and turns, but isn't ruthless enough, especially playing on the final line. Need to replace Whitwell wide for now and another forward has to play if we need to accommodate both Diakite and Molumby. 
Barney - 6 - Tried, put himself about, but didn't get any service. 

Subs:

Heggebo - 7 - Good showing. Involved in most things we did and gave us a focal point after Barney had grafted for 60. Got the goal too of course. 
JJ - 6 - Did okay. Not involved enough. 
Tunde - One run shows there might be an athlete in there somewhere. Won't go as far as a footballer yet. 
Rabby - All action, but so erratic. 

Mozza - 8 - Didn't get it right from the start for me, which will surprise very few people. But reacted well and got it right in game.

Pretty much how I saw it. I really want it to work for Whitwell, and you can see he’s trying,  but atm he’s looking miles off it. I’ve only seen it once but think Diakite was lucky to get away with a challenge near the end that could’ve resulted in a penalty.
Overall I think in better conditions we would’ve controlled the game more than we did anyway & probably come away with a win.


RE: Rattings - Peachy - 10-24-2026

Let's not all forget Whitwell had a cracking start to the season against some good opposition. He's found himself out of the starting line up recently and that showed a bit today. I was very surprised he started today but you can only assume he has trained really well and Mozza likes him.

Talk of loaning him out is premature imo. Young players coming up through the ranks are always patchy whilst they find their feet. He's doing fine imo.


RE: Rattings - Hughie Reed 31 - 10-24-2026

(10-24-2026, 08:37 PM)Peachy Wrote: Let's not all forget Whitwell had a cracking start to the season against some good opposition. He's found himself out of the starting line up recently and that showed a bit today. I was very surprised he started today but you can only assume he has trained really well and Mozza likes him.

Talk of loaning him out is premature imo. Young players coming up through the ranks are always patchy whilst they find their feet. He's doing fine imo.

Pretty much spot on this lad will be a big player for us in the coming seasons
The fans need to have a bit of patience with the younger lads
If the gaffer thinks he’ll Make it that’s good enough for me.


RE: Rattings - Birdman1811 - 10-24-2026

Ah yes, my amazing ability to foretell football fans and youth strikes again: Whitwell hasn't suddenly become shit, like all players starting out; he's struggling for consistency. He isn't an unknown now; he isn't the biggest lad, so the opposition can bully him. The only way to get better if that's the issue is to go through it, as many have. A loan does him no benefit; playing for us, as he is, does.

Fellows had the same; the difference is Fellows did stuff fans always like, so even when he fiucked up, he did enough for fans to love him. It's why defenders find it hard to break through, unless they are the type that fly into tackles needlessly, and finally fans are seeing through that. Fellows also had no competition (fans would have cheered a one-legged horse over Wallace at points), and our expectations were, well, shit for the whole team.

Morrison rates him, the club as a whole obviously do, players seem to, I'll trust them.


RE: Rattings - 1952 - 10-24-2026

(10-24-2026, 06:19 PM)Jerry Wrote: My main comment is that Campbell has struggled over the last 2 to 4 games and today was probably his worse game. Not sure if he is carrying an injury or the captaincy weighs to heavy but we need him to improve.
He seemed to have a slight limp when walking off after applauding the fans.


RE: Rattings - Carlos Quiver - 10-24-2026

(10-24-2026, 08:53 PM)1952 Wrote:
(10-24-2026, 06:19 PM)Jerry Wrote: My main comment is that Campbell has struggled over the last 2 to 4 games and today was probably his worse game. Not sure if he is carrying an injury or the captaincy weighs to heavy but we need him to improve.
He seemed to have a slight limp when walking off after applauding the fans.

It was a bad challenge on him near the end, the PNE player got booked for it I think

(10-24-2026, 08:52 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Ah yes, my amazing ability to foretell football fans and youth strikes again: Whitwell hasn't suddenly become shit, like all players starting out; he's struggling for consistency. He isn't an unknown now; he isn't the biggest lad, so the opposition can bully him. The only way to get better if that's the issue is to go through it, as many have. A loan does him no benefit; playing for us, as he is, does.

Fellows had the same; the difference is Fellows did stuff fans always like, so even when he fiucked up, he did enough for fans to love him. It's why defenders find it hard to break through, unless they are the type that fly into tackles needlessly, and finally fans are seeing through that. Fellows also had no competition (fans would have cheered a one-legged horse over Wallace at points), and our expectations were, well, shit for the whole team.

Morrison rates him, the club as a whole obviously do, players seem to, I'll trust them.

I never said he was shit, just atm he’s looking off the pace a bit.


RE: Rattings - Birdman1811 - 10-24-2026

(10-24-2026, 08:58 PM)Carlos Quiver Wrote:
(10-24-2026, 08:53 PM)1952 Wrote:
(10-24-2026, 06:19 PM)Jerry Wrote: My main comment is that Campbell has struggled over the last 2 to 4 games and today was probably his worse game. Not sure if he is carrying an injury or the captaincy weighs to heavy but we need him to improve.
He seemed to have a slight limp when walking off after applauding the fans.

It was a bad challenge on him near the end, the PNE player got booked for it I think

(10-24-2026, 08:52 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Ah yes, my amazing ability to foretell football fans and youth strikes again: Whitwell hasn't suddenly become shit, like all players starting out; he's struggling for consistency. He isn't an unknown now; he isn't the biggest lad, so the opposition can bully him. The only way to get better if that's the issue is to go through it, as many have. A loan does him no benefit; playing for us, as he is, does.

Fellows had the same; the difference is Fellows did stuff fans always like, so even when he fiucked up, he did enough for fans to love him. It's why defenders find it hard to break through, unless they are the type that fly into tackles needlessly, and finally fans are seeing through that. Fellows also had no competition (fans would have cheered a one-legged horse over Wallace at points), and our expectations were, well, shit for the whole team.

Morrison rates him, the club as a whole obviously do, players seem to, I'll trust them.

I never said he was shit, just atm he’s looking off the pace a bit.

Oh I'd agree, I'd have him as a sub for a few games, but OP was straight in on the 'Loan him out' story.


RE: Rattings - Cheshire East Baggie - 10-24-2026

Harry Whitwell was right off it today, but I can see why Mozza gave him 15 mins of the second half. His non-performance skews the marking of Myrhe, Stewart and Price who had to carry him attacking-wise and also Pereira who was left exposed at times.

Nothing to disagree with in the markings above, I'd just observe that Myhre showed something of the player he can be. We desperately need a player who can take chances with confidence. Are there any 20 goal a season strikers out there, or has the game changed?

It was Valerian Ismael's worst nightmare at times, 3 minutes to go and we're rolling the ball around just outside our own penalty area. I don't know how that excess of caution can be fixed, but we certainly have a lot of aimless possession.


RE: Rattings - HawkingsHalfpint - 10-24-2026

There’s a definite player in Myrhe; we’ve/he’s just yet to learn to channel it for the full 90. Not just fits and starts.

Oddly enough I thought Price looked less composed as the game wore on. Not so much tired in terms of effort, but just a waywardness about his play that was exemplary of tiredness. When usually, he can be relied upon to be fit as a flea for 90. Conditions probably didn’t help.

Less said about Whitwell, the better. But I though the rest were OK, Stewart aside, who just can’t seem to find his way into games. At least Heggebø’s barren spell at the beginning of his Albion career was offset by his incredible work-rate, and chasing of every ball. Stewart has more support but seems to be achieving less.

He’s a fourth and not a third choice in an ideal world. As it is. It’s just a shame that there are only two others from whom to choose. But then - who’s to say he doesn’t suddenly find his form? Here’s hoping so.

The rest were all decent enough to a man, especially Styles and Molumby. I’d include Diakite among that but for one butt-clenching moment, and Campbell for switching off once or twice. Most unlike him as is focus his usually unwavering.

So, most a 6.5 or 7, Whitless a 4, Styles and Jayse an 8. Mozza gets a 7 for making earlier than expected changes, but he still has a number of things to address. Whilst we’re much better going forward it still all goes wrong in that last third, set pieces remain abysmal, and we have to stop conceding first (as said elsewhere). This tactic of wearing teams down and then bringing on the redeemeders is going to catch up with us at some point. It’s time he began really challenging some of the new boys to bring more, from minute one.


RE: Rattings - Boaz's Piehill - 10-25-2026

O'Leary 6 - nowt to do really

Pereira 6 - better going forwards than backuds
Mepham 7 - much better option than Np
Campbell 6 - average performance from an average player
Styles 6 - dip in form at the moment

Whitwell 4 - looks well off if, loan him out in Jan
Diakite 6 - lucky not concede and pen and get send off
Molumby 8* - everywhere today. First name on the team sheet for me
Horn Myhre 4 - not sure what he offers, much rather Zinger starts
Price 5 - poor today. Lack of consistency is why he’s at the Albion not a PL team

Stewart 5 - could do a loan spell, lack of options means that’s not possible

Heggebø 7 - needs a run in a front two with JJ
Morgan 7 - see above
Nzingoula 7 - things happen when he’s on the pitch
Tunde 6 - hardly touched the ball