WBAUnofficial
Gilchrist - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Gilchrist (/showthread.php?tid=42269)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Gilchrist - Jacko - 08-02-2026

Never a right back and has only had one half decent performance in his time at the club (at centre back). Entirely happy to move him on, he's bobbins.


RE: Gilchrist - Baggie23 - 08-02-2026

Hope we move him on permanently, Williams & Galves seem like better options so we don't need him as a 3rd choice right back and 5th choice centre back


RE: Gilchrist - aj21 - 08-02-2026

(08-02-2026, 03:06 PM)Jacko Wrote: Never a right back and has only had one half decent performance in his time at the club (at centre back). Entirely happy to move him on, he's bobbins.

Agree, he’s absolutely gone at the game. Dined off a few games for Chelsea but clearly regressed massively, his positional sense is dreadful and he has multiple mistakes in him every game.


RE: Gilchrist - AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke - 08-02-2026

I'm not writing him off, potential there as a centre half I think, but we're over subscribed in that area anyway, so if there's a decent offer move him on. Would still rather him than Mepham on showings to date mind.


RE: Gilchrist - Bob Fossil - 08-02-2026

Any deal is a good deal. Those that say there’s a player on there, ask yourself if you envisage saying that in 3 years, from what we’ve seen so far?
Another one that got a move based solely on being on the books of a big club.
Good luck to him, hope he has decent EFL career. But he’s nothing like what we need right now. 5th choice CH and 3rd choice RB.


RE: Gilchrist - SW4Baggie - 08-02-2026

Some very talented football scouts and coaches in this thread!

He’s 22, made 11 appearances under Pochettino in the PL when Chelsea finished in the top 6, and then played over 30 games for a Sheff Utd side that nearly won automatic promotion and finished with 90 points, yet he’s not a Championship player?

He’s been chopped and changed between CB in a 4 and 3 and put out at both right back and wingback under 3 managers in a struggling team that didn’t have a settled defence for a whole season. In the 1 game that mattered when he played CB under Morrison he was excellent, and then he was dire in the Wednesday game where everyone downed tools.

He can afford a season on loan. We paid a million quid, we will absolutely be able to get more than that for him before his contract is up IMO.


RE: Gilchrist - Bob Fossil - 08-02-2026

(08-02-2026, 06:20 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Some very talented football scouts and coaches in this thread!

He’s 22, made 11 appearances under Pochettino in the PL when Chelsea finished in the top 6, and then played over 30 games for a Sheff Utd side that nearly won automatic promotion and finished with 90 points, yet he’s not a Championship player?

He’s been chopped and changed between CB in a 4 and 3 and put out at both right back and wingback under 3 managers in a struggling team that didn’t have a settled defence for a whole season. In the 1 game that mattered when he played CB under Morrison he was excellent, and then he was dire in the Wednesday game where everyone downed tools.

He can afford a season on loan. We paid a million quid, we will absolutely be able to get more than that for him before his contract is up IMO.

If he was excellent at CH he would have played. All of Phillips, Mepham and Bielik were poor for large periods of time yet he didn’t get picked not only by the coaches but in the team selections on here. Did you have him on your best 11?
We can’t afford to keep hoping and praying that poor performers come good.


RE: Gilchrist - MancBaggie - 08-02-2026

(08-02-2026, 02:07 PM)HLS Wrote:
(08-02-2026, 02:03 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Honestly, I don’t think we should be moving him on. There is a player in there.

If there is, can we extract him before we sell Gilchrist?

Big Grin Big Grin

Based on seeing him for SU in a few games I thought he would do well - but he’s been dreadful

Saw him at CH at SW - accident waiting to happen


RE: Gilchrist - Elon's Musk - 08-02-2026

All my chelsea mates reckon he's quality so fuck knows what's happened


RE: Gilchrist - SW4Baggie - 08-02-2026

(08-02-2026, 07:00 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-02-2026, 06:20 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Some very talented football scouts and coaches in this thread!

He’s 22, made 11 appearances under Pochettino in the PL when Chelsea finished in the top 6, and then played over 30 games for a Sheff Utd side that nearly won automatic promotion and finished with 90 points, yet he’s not a Championship player?

He’s been chopped and changed between CB in a 4 and 3 and put out at both right back and wingback under 3 managers in a struggling team that didn’t have a settled defence for a whole season. In the 1 game that mattered when he played CB under Morrison he was excellent, and then he was dire in the Wednesday game where everyone downed tools.

He can afford a season on loan. We paid a million quid, we will absolutely be able to get more than that for him before his contract is up IMO.

If he was excellent at CH he would have played. All of Phillips, Mepham and Bielik were poor for large periods of time yet he didn’t get picked not only by the coaches but in the team selections on here. Did you have him on your best 11?
We can’t afford to keep hoping and praying that poor performers come good.

Because at the time the pairing of Campbell and Phillips was doing very well, but Phillips missed one game. Plenty on here wouldn’t have been disappointed if he played the next game but Mozza rightfully reverted to the partnership that was a massive part of our survival.

If we are moving any CB out permanently this summer it should be Mepham (huge wages) or Bielik who can’t do more than 20 games.