![]() |
|
Gary's Economics - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Gary's Economics (/showthread.php?tid=42041) |
RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-10-2026 (07-10-2026, 09:34 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Although Grifter is probably a bit harsh, Is "Grifter" a bit harsh? Taxing inflationary rather than real gains raises the rate of return needed on investment. That inevitably reduces investment. A lack of investment makes the country less wealthy. That's why we ALL feel poorer. Russia has been at war since 2022. Despite that it's wealth per adult since 2020 has gone up nearly 37%. The UK is down 23%. UK prices have risen 31% since Covid. Personal allowances are frozen until the next decade. IHT threshold hasn't moved since 2009, CGT allowance has been cut from £12,300 to £3,000. CGT rates to be aligned with income tax? Wealth taxes? There is no tax relief for inflation. The average rate of tax paid by households in the UK is now 2% higher than under Teresa May. When governments give up on growth, they decide to tax the inflation that their own policies have created. They mistake it for real money. No one ever taxed their way to prosperity. Gary is a total Grifter. RE: Gary's Economics - Derek Hardballs - 07-10-2026 When Blue Labour and Tory both agree… it gives you an indication as to why people move towards Reform and Green. When Blue Labour types are positioning themselves to not address and reverse the ever growing and dangerously so inequality gap, and sounding like a dyed in the wool Tory, you can see why people are angry, cynical and throughly disillusioned with politics. ‘Something, something trickle down economics…’ RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 07-10-2026 So explain the benefits of Gary's ideas then. Instead of just wingeing that everything is shit tell us how the 'wealth tax' would work. And the irony of the person that wouldn't vote for Corbyn calling someone that did as Blue Labour is not lost here. RE: Gary's Economics - Derek Hardballs - 07-10-2026 (07-10-2026, 11:24 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So explain the benefits of Gary's ideas then. Instead of just wingeing that everything is shit tell us how the 'wealth tax' would work. And the irony of the person that wouldn't vote for Corbyn calling someone that did as Blue Labour is not lost here. I think saying everything is shit is Labour policy. Let’s hope Burnham offers a little more than the average person getting poorer and billionaires making ever bigger profits, disproportionate to what they bring to the world. RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 07-10-2026 That isn't the question, you simply avoid any direct question that puts a dent in your fantasies. And no it isn't, that is the media portrayal of the situation, Labour have put their successes out there but reducing waiting lists, clearing backlogs of immigration cases, and all of the others that have been mentioned are out there. RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-10-2026 (07-10-2026, 11:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: When Blue Labour and Tory both agree… it gives you an indication as to why people move towards Reform and Green. What I don't get about Gary is that he says the proceeds of a Wealth Tax will somehow trickle down to the least wealthy. But is consistently and frustratingly unable to explain how on Earth that would happen. Perhaps you can explain. RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 07-10-2026 Just a bit of context here for your response Dekka. According to Forbes there are 55 Billionaires that are British with a total wealth of 273.4Bn, if you apply the mentioned rate of 2% then that raises a maximum of 5.5Bn. I say maximum because most of them will be domiciled elsewhere or simply move if they are not already. Not all of them obviously and some will stay and pay but the figure collected will be between Nil and 5.5Bn. I would hedge on it being nearer the nil than the 5.5Bn. RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-10-2026 (07-10-2026, 11:22 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: When Blue Labour and Tory both agree… it gives you an indication as to why people move towards Reform and Green. It's even more of a thing when even mad MMT enthusiasts like Richard Murphy think he's way out of his depth: https://www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2026/07/10/how-to-get-filthy-rich-a-review/ RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 07-10-2026 Interesting read and sums up what is being said in this thread. One thing that doesn't get the 'wealth tax' coverage is Reeves' adding pensions into IHT (I know we don't agree on this one Proth), but that is a tax on the ultimate wealth of an individual. I've mentioned this many times but the fact that it isn't labelled 'wealth tax' appears to make it ignored. RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-10-2026 (07-10-2026, 01:56 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Interesting read and sums up what is being said in this thread. One thing that doesn't get the 'wealth tax' coverage is Reeves' adding pensions into IHT (I know we don't agree on this one Proth), but that is a tax on the ultimate wealth of an individual. I've mentioned this many times but the fact that it isn't labelled 'wealth tax' appears to make it ignored. Well quite, and as I've already said - the behavioural shift that will encourage will be for individuals to empty pensions before other assets which attract a less egregious penalty for your heirs. |