WBAUnofficial
Runners & Riders for Chancellor - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Runners & Riders for Chancellor (/showthread.php?tid=41899)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Runners & Riders for Chancellor - Shabby Russian - 06-27-2026

(06-26-2026, 10:16 PM)CIM Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 12:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Shabana Mahmood, I reckon.

Agreed. I don't think Burnham is silly enough to promote Mad Ed

Miliband is the only logical choice, if Burnham is sincere in his desire for ",real' change.

Objective political commentators consider him to be currently the most effective minister, perhaps the only competent one. It's almost certainly the reason why he is being so heavily briefed against, because those who disagree with his objectives are worried that if he got his hands on the treasury he would have the experience and nous to effect the changes he wants.

If he does not get the job, then it's clear that the Labour right have in Burnham another continuty Blair leader, who like Starmer fluttered his eyelashes at the centre left and left of the party, when he was seeking to be leader, but soon reneged on his flirtations once installed as leader.

Problem this time is that so many have already left Labour. A sincere Burnham Govt might have got the majority back. But one that maintains the status quo won't.


RE: Runners & Riders for Chancellor - Borin' Baggie - 06-27-2026

(06-26-2026, 09:31 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 08:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You should have seen who the Tories put into senior ministerial positions over the previous 14yrs!

I don't recall them stooping quite that low.

Lansley, Grayling, Truss, Kwarteng, Coutinho, Williamson, Braverman, Jenrick, Zahawi, Brine, Raab and Philp right off the top of my head.


RE: Runners & Riders for Chancellor - tHEgLASSdOORS - 06-27-2026

Truss. Debate ends.


RE: Runners & Riders for Chancellor - CIM - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 09:40 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 10:16 PM)CIM Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 12:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Shabana Mahmood, I reckon.

Agreed. I don't think Burnham is silly enough to promote Mad Ed

Miliband is the only logical choice, if Burnham is sincere in his desire for ",real' change.

Objective political commentators consider him to be currently the most effective minister, perhaps the only competent one. It's almost certainly the reason why he is being so heavily briefed against, because those who disagree with his objectives are worried that if he got his hands on the treasury he would have the experience and nous to effect the changes he wants.

If he does not get the job, then it's clear that the Labour right have in Burnham another continuty Blair leader, who like Starmer fluttered his eyelashes at the centre left and left of the party, when he was seeking to be leader, but soon reneged on his flirtations once installed as leader.

Problem this time is that so many have already left Labour. A sincere Burnham Govt might have got the majority back. But one that maintains the status quo won't.

Calling Miliband the "only logical choice" ignores the elephant in the room: his economic and energy policies are exactly why many voters have drifted away from Labour.
His obsession with net zero at any cost risks piling yet more carbon taxes, levies and regulation onto households and businesses that are already among the most heavily taxed in decades. Energy affordability and economic growth should come before ideological targets.
Being "effective" at implementing policies people disagree with isn't necessarily a virtue. If those policies mean higher bills, reduced competitiveness and more state intervention, then many would argue competence simply makes the consequences arrive faster.
If Burnham really wants to win back voters, doubling down on Miliband's agenda is hardly the answer. Labour lost millions of working-class voters because they felt the party cared more about climate symbolism than the cost of living. Ignoring that lesson would be a mistake.


RE: Runners & Riders for Chancellor - tHEgLASSdOORS - 06-27-2026

I think the direction of travel of climate - and the cost to the economy of episodes like the current one - only make Net Zero ever more urgent


RE: Runners & Riders for Chancellor - Protheroe - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 10:20 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 09:31 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 08:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You should have seen who the Tories put into senior ministerial positions over the previous 14yrs!

I don't recall them stooping quite that low.

Lansley, Grayling, Truss, Kwarteng, Coutinho, Williamson, Braverman, Jenrick, Zahawi, Brine, Raab and Philp right off the top of my head.

Arf. I guess you’d call that a bite.

(06-27-2026, 12:58 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I think the direction of travel of climate - and the cost to the economy of episodes like the current one - only make Net Zero ever more urgent

How will achieving net zero in the UK avoid episodes like the current one?

FWIW I don’t know anyone personally who isn’t completely aghast at the prospect of Miliband getting anywhere near Chancellor. And that includes several members of the Labour Party.


RE: Runners & Riders for Chancellor - Borin' Baggie - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 12:41 PM)CIM Wrote:
(06-27-2026, 09:40 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 10:16 PM)CIM Wrote:
(06-26-2026, 12:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Shabana Mahmood, I reckon.

Agreed. I don't think Burnham is silly enough to promote Mad Ed

Miliband is the only logical choice, if Burnham is sincere in his desire for ",real' change.

Objective political commentators consider him to be currently the most effective minister, perhaps the only competent one. It's almost certainly the reason why he is being so heavily briefed against, because those who disagree with his objectives are worried that if he got his hands on the treasury he would have the experience and nous to effect the changes he wants.

If he does not get the job, then it's clear that the Labour right have in Burnham another continuty Blair leader, who like Starmer fluttered his eyelashes at the centre left and left of the party, when he was seeking to be leader, but soon reneged on his flirtations once installed as leader.

Problem this time is that so many have already left Labour. A sincere Burnham Govt might have got the majority back. But one that maintains the status quo won't.

Calling Miliband the "only logical choice" ignores the elephant in the room: his economic and energy policies are exactly why many voters have drifted away from Labour.
His obsession with net zero at any cost risks piling yet more carbon taxes, levies and regulation onto households and businesses that are already among the most heavily taxed in decades. Energy affordability and economic growth should come before ideological targets.
Being "effective" at implementing policies people disagree with isn't necessarily a virtue. If those policies mean higher bills, reduced competitiveness and more state intervention, then many would argue competence simply makes the consequences arrive faster.
If Burnham really wants to win back voters, doubling down on Miliband's agenda is hardly the answer. Labour lost millions of working-class voters because they felt the party cared more about climate symbolism than the cost of living. Ignoring that lesson would be a mistake.

CIM, you do realise the whole point of CP2030 and CP2035 is energy security and cost, right? Our current energy situation is the culmination of the idiotic Thatcher-Blair energy axis, not Milliband.


RE: Runners & Riders for Chancellor - man in the corner shop - 06-27-2026

The voters that you describe CIM do not exist.

Virtually no one has deserted Labour because of their energy policy. Such people- including yourself- were never Labour voters anyway and never will be. They are dyed in the wool Tories or Faragist climate change deniers.

There is a similar myth that people can't abide Starmer because of his refusal to fund defence to their expectations. There might be a small number but most people took against Starmer long before Healey resigned.

These are inventions of the Daily Mail and right wing media that you have gobbled up so greedily for your whole life.

Fair enough. You believe what you want and I will gorge on woke shite.


RE: Runners & Riders for Chancellor - CIM - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 06:07 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: The voters that you describe CIM do not exist.

Virtually no one has deserted Labour because of their energy policy. Such people- including yourself- were never Labour voters anyway and never will be. They are dyed in the wool Tories or Faragist climate change deniers.

There is a similar myth that people can't abide Starmer because of his refusal to fund defence to their expectations. There might be a small number but most people took against Starmer long before Healey resigned.

These are inventions of the Daily Mail and right wing media that you have gobbled up so greedily for your whole life.

Fair enough. You believe what you want and I will gorge on woke shite.

Your argument falls apart for several reasons.
First, you claim that "virtually no one" has deserted Labour over energy policy. That's an absolute statement with no evidence whatsoever. Polling has consistently shown that the cost of living and energy bills are among voters' biggest concerns, and Labour's net zero policies have been a point of contention for many voters.
Second, dismissing anyone who disagrees as a "dyed-in-the-wool Tory", "Faragist" or "climate change denier" is lazy tribalism. Plenty of people accept climate change but question the affordability, pace or effectiveness of Labour's policies.
Third, you're confusing disagreement with media manipulation. You can't simply dismiss opinions by claiming they're inventions of the Daily Mail. People are perfectly capable of reaching their own conclusions.
Finally, if your argument relies on labelling rather than evidence, it suggests you don't have much confidence in the argument itself.
By all means disagree with my views, but don't pretend anyone who questions Labour's energy policy is imaginary or brainwashed. That's not an argument—it's an insult.


RE: Runners & Riders for Chancellor - Borin' Baggie - 06-27-2026

If you're going to use an LLM to come up with a response CIM at least comb through the reply to get rid of the em-dash.