WBAUnofficial
Ben Stokes - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ben Stokes (/showthread.php?tid=41752)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: Ben Stokes - Beachboysbaggie - 06-09-2026

(06-09-2026, 10:00 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 09:47 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: In isolation, this would be a nothing story.

However, given previous indiscretions and the obvious strict curfew in place, it's absolutely a dereliction of duty for the captain to still be out at a club and enabling this behaviour in other team members, regardless of whether hew as drunk or not.

It all points to an complete absence of discipline, which seeps into things like training and practising etc. Not good enough.

This is what my above rant should have been. A lot more concise and less angry. 

I'm glad I'm not the only one that feels like this. If it was a once off incident, you could brush it off as 'one of those things', move on and learn, you could excuse it, 'they've just finished a match, it's fair enough to let their hair down'. 

However, it's not a one off. When you look at the bigger picture, how the team conduct themselves in the lead up to series, with the lack of preparation, and the general laissez-faire approach to our play, then it all adds up to a general culture that isn't right, there's a distinct lack of discipline and leadership, and the mentality is not right. It's not acceptable.

We’ve won the opening test in 8 of our last 9 series so, last winter excepted, maybe the preparation in the lead up to series is working quite well


RE: Ben Stokes - AnelkasBeard - 06-09-2026

(06-09-2026, 10:00 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 09:47 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: In isolation, this would be a nothing story.

However, given previous indiscretions and the obvious strict curfew in place, it's absolutely a dereliction of duty for the captain to still be out at a club and enabling this behaviour in other team members, regardless of whether hew as drunk or not.

It all points to an complete absence of discipline, which seeps into things like training and practising etc. Not good enough.

This is what my above rant should have been. A lot more concise and less angry. 

I'm glad I'm not the only one that feels like this. If it was a once off incident, you could brush it off as 'one of those things', move on and learn, you could excuse it, 'they've just finished a match, it's fair enough to let their hair down'. 

However, it's not a one off. When you look at the bigger picture, how the team conduct themselves in the lead up to series, with the lack of preparation, and the general laissez-faire approach to our play, then it all adds up to a general culture that isn't right, there's a distinct lack of discipline and leadership, and the mentality is not right. It's not acceptable.

No, you rant is also very correct and needed.

This is in the main reason why I was amazed Key and McCullum were allowed to retain their positions. As you point out, this current attitude comes from the top and it simply won't change until those two are removed from position.

I was previously of the opinion that Stokes would be able to continue under different leadership, but I think this event points to the opposite. As you said, he doesn't really warrant selection as a batter any more, and as 4th choice seamer he isn't exactly providing much beyond captaincy.


RE: Ben Stokes - Josh1873 - 06-09-2026

(06-09-2026, 10:14 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 10:00 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 09:47 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: In isolation, this would be a nothing story.

However, given previous indiscretions and the obvious strict curfew in place, it's absolutely a dereliction of duty for the captain to still be out at a club and enabling this behaviour in other team members, regardless of whether hew as drunk or not.

It all points to an complete absence of discipline, which seeps into things like training and practising etc. Not good enough.

This is what my above rant should have been. A lot more concise and less angry. 

I'm glad I'm not the only one that feels like this. If it was a once off incident, you could brush it off as 'one of those things', move on and learn, you could excuse it, 'they've just finished a match, it's fair enough to let their hair down'. 

However, it's not a one off. When you look at the bigger picture, how the team conduct themselves in the lead up to series, with the lack of preparation, and the general laissez-faire approach to our play, then it all adds up to a general culture that isn't right, there's a distinct lack of discipline and leadership, and the mentality is not right. It's not acceptable.

We’ve won the opening test in 8 of our last 9 series so, last winter excepted, maybe the preparation in the lead up to series is working quite well
You prepare for a while series, a whole tour, a tournament, you need a long-term plan with clear goals, and a clear route/plan to achieve those goals. 

None of the above is present. It's all 'supply teachery', just turn up, have a laugh, and see what happens. It's a joke of an approach. 

I couldn't give a toss what our record is in the first Test. The fact of the matter is that we're losing a lot of series at the moment, that tells me we're not planning or preparing for a series in the correct way.


RE: Ben Stokes - CA Baggie - 06-09-2026

You wonder just how often this protocol is actually broken as this is far from the first incident, we only get to here about the nights out that end up in altercations.

This points to a culture of not sticking to the rules laid down from above, the "above" not actually acting upon the rule breaking and the players themselves not holding each other to the standards they should expect from each other. The fact it's the team captain just makes it worse. This is not the beaviour of a team least of all what they should wish to be - a high perfoming team.

Can you imagine Clive Woodward, Fergie or other true leaders accepting this? SGM would headlock the fuckers.

It then comes back to this - how do you punish the most talented players? The threat/loss of their central contract isn't enough of a punishment, they'll earn the money, even maybe more, elsewehere so you've got to hope they have enough sporting desire and drive to want to do and be better. Most that get to elite level have that already, some lack the discipline to remain there which is probably where we are with a few of these players and management are happy to let it go.

The lack of discipline does creep in to other areas, too tired/hungover to concentrate on catching practice etc.

I remember a quote from Gary Linekar and saying footballers are the most prompt people in existence "To be early is on time, to be on time is late and to be late is unaccpetable". Or the Roy Keane story on leaving a restaurant and refusing to eat with Ian Wright becasue he was 10 minites late and hadn't let him know. Maintaining the highest standards in the simplest things sets a tone and culture.

PS: Clive Woodward's book Winning is a good read and should probably be given to someone at the ECB to read.


RE: Ben Stokes - Beachboysbaggie - 06-09-2026

(06-09-2026, 10:33 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 10:14 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 10:00 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-09-2026, 09:47 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: In isolation, this would be a nothing story.

However, given previous indiscretions and the obvious strict curfew in place, it's absolutely a dereliction of duty for the captain to still be out at a club and enabling this behaviour in other team members, regardless of whether hew as drunk or not.

It all points to an complete absence of discipline, which seeps into things like training and practising etc. Not good enough.

This is what my above rant should have been. A lot more concise and less angry. 

I'm glad I'm not the only one that feels like this. If it was a once off incident, you could brush it off as 'one of those things', move on and learn, you could excuse it, 'they've just finished a match, it's fair enough to let their hair down'. 

However, it's not a one off. When you look at the bigger picture, how the team conduct themselves in the lead up to series, with the lack of preparation, and the general laissez-faire approach to our play, then it all adds up to a general culture that isn't right, there's a distinct lack of discipline and leadership, and the mentality is not right. It's not acceptable.

We’ve won the opening test in 8 of our last 9 series so, last winter excepted, maybe the preparation in the lead up to series is working quite well
You prepare for a while series, a whole tour, a tournament, you need a long-term plan with clear goals, and a clear route/plan to achieve those goals. 

None of the above is present. It's all 'supply teachery', just turn up, have a laugh, and see what happens. It's a joke of an approach. 

I couldn't give a toss what our record is in the first Test. The fact of the matter is that we're losing a lot of series at the moment, that tells me we're not planning or preparing for a series in the correct way.

In the 15 series that Stokes/McCullum have been in charge we’ve lost 2


RE: Ben Stokes - Bob Fossil - 06-09-2026

Why can’t they celebrate a win?
They don’t play again for while so don’t see the issue unless they’ve proper played up.


RE: Ben Stokes - MGalea - 06-09-2026

(06-09-2026, 01:34 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Why can’t they celebrate a win?
They don’t play again for while so don’t see the issue unless they’ve proper played up.

They've probably been given a bit of a green light to forget the rules but as they've gone and got themselves in trouble they'll have to be punished in line with breaking the curfew etc..


RE: Ben Stokes - Wednesburybaggie - 06-09-2026

Rumours have it that he will resign the captaincy. Well, he's not worth his place in the team as either a bowler or Batter right now. Bring in Rehan Ahmed. Better spinner than Bashir, and could easily bat 7 for us. Replace Bashir with Archer, and hopefully Atkinson keeps his place.


RE: Ben Stokes - Hudds2 - 06-09-2026

(06-09-2026, 01:34 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Why can’t they celebrate a win?
They don’t play again for while so don’t see the issue unless they’ve proper played up.

Course they can.  But the midnight curfew was brought in to prevent exactly what has again happened.  Stay clear of night clubs and stay in your hotel by then.  They are paid enough to be responsible and professional enough.


RE: Ben Stokes - AnelkasBeard - 06-09-2026

(06-09-2026, 01:34 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Why can’t they celebrate a win?
They don’t play again for while so don’t see the issue unless they’ve proper played up.

Celebrating the win is fine. Completely ignoring the curfew put in place because of repeated previous incidents, which then causes another incident, is not fine.

This isn't difficult to grasp.