WBAUnofficial
FAB - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: FAB (/showthread.php?tid=41622)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: FAB - MrBater - 05-21-2026

Pop fab, fab pop? Most of us took the piss out out of the data driven bollox be ause it was so obviously based on shit data.


RE: FAB - Sliced - 05-21-2026

(05-21-2026, 06:09 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: We recruited well individually this season, the problem was not the system or the analytics... The issue was no joined up thinking in terms of squad balance, and the misjudgment on the Fellows fee leaving us without a right winger, needing to sell Furlong and having no time or funds to replace them. We did not need to sign Bielik and had we spent that fee/wage on a right winger, I think we'd have had a better season.

As Morrison has shown, we built a squad that was capable of finishing much higher, it was just poorly used and lacked balance.

Let's hope Price can build on the positives of what Nestor introduced and add some more strategic thinking... I'll take our data based analytics approach over the massive recruitment success we had based on who Gourlay had heard of, knew the agent of and whoever was either Bruce's neighbour or shagging his daughter.

No analytics were needed to establish that having 5 centre backs but only two senior fit wide players was gonna be a problem


RE: FAB - SW4Baggie - 05-22-2026

(05-21-2026, 09:52 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-21-2026, 06:09 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: We recruited well individually this season, the problem was not the system or the analytics... The issue was no joined up thinking in terms of squad balance, and the misjudgment on the Fellows fee leaving us without a right winger, needing to sell Furlong and having no time or funds to replace them. We did not need to sign Bielik and had we spent that fee/wage on a right winger, I think we'd have had a better season.

As Morrison has shown, we built a squad that was capable of finishing much higher, it was just poorly used and lacked balance.

Let's hope Price can build on the positives of what Nestor introduced and add some more strategic thinking... I'll take our data based analytics approach over the massive recruitment success we had based on who Gourlay had heard of, knew the agent of and whoever was either Bruce's neighbour or shagging his daughter.

No analytics were needed to establish that having 5 centre backs but only two senior fit wide players was gonna be a problem

Exactly - and that's the point I'm making.

Derek wont be happy until every spreadsheet and computer in the club is thrown away and we go back to common sense scouting by sending people all round the world watching players, whereas I believe a lot of what Nestor did added value from a recruitment perspective as we were able to isolate some very talented, high potential players that we brought in at very good prices.

Where we've been too reliant on data for me is that we didn't consider the full balance of the squad. The model is working fine in isolating good players, but we have struggled to build a coherent unit and we still lack balance, however that's been an issue for 5-6 seasons, and isn't solely down to us deciding to use a laptop instead of someone's dad with a Cortina.


RE: FAB - Fido - 05-22-2026

(05-21-2026, 05:55 PM)RamsAy it Wrote: I prefer a Solero myself.  FAB are for kids

Don’t forget to remind us Derek, how you were the last person on this board that wanted Pulis out.  <Just thought I’d jog your memory Big Grin>

Reminding people of things they posted historically can be very much a double-edged sword. Might be worth remembering that.


RE: FAB - MrBater - 05-22-2026

(05-22-2026, 07:24 AM)Fido Wrote:
(05-21-2026, 05:55 PM)RamsAy it Wrote: I prefer a Solero myself.  FAB are for kids

Don’t forget to remind us Derek, how you were the last person on this board that wanted Pulis out.  <Just thought I’d jog your memory Big Grin>

Reminding people of things they posted historically can be very much a double-edged sword. Might be worth remembering that.

You're replying to the Marquis of ancient post retrieval there lad, he probably uses Python to automate it.


RE: FAB - Bob Fossil - 05-22-2026

(05-22-2026, 07:22 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-21-2026, 09:52 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-21-2026, 06:09 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: We recruited well individually this season, the problem was not the system or the analytics... The issue was no joined up thinking in terms of squad balance, and the misjudgment on the Fellows fee leaving us without a right winger, needing to sell Furlong and having no time or funds to replace them. We did not need to sign Bielik and had we spent that fee/wage on a right winger, I think we'd have had a better season.

As Morrison has shown, we built a squad that was capable of finishing much higher, it was just poorly used and lacked balance.

Let's hope Price can build on the positives of what Nestor introduced and add some more strategic thinking... I'll take our data based analytics approach over the massive recruitment success we had based on who Gourlay had heard of, knew the agent of and whoever was either Bruce's neighbour or shagging his daughter.

No analytics were needed to establish that having 5 centre backs but only two senior fit wide players was gonna be a problem

Exactly - and that's the point I'm making.

Derek wont be happy until every spreadsheet and computer in the club is thrown away and we go back to common sense scouting by sending people all round the world watching players, whereas I believe a lot of what Nestor did added value from a recruitment perspective as we were able to isolate some very talented, high potential players that we brought in at very good prices.

Where we've been too reliant on data for me is that we didn't consider the full balance of the squad. The model is working fine in isolating good players, but we have struggled to build a coherent unit and we still lack balance, however that's been an issue for 5-6 seasons, and isn't solely down to us deciding to use a laptop instead of someone's dad with a Cortina.

Agree. Analytics are only as good as the person interpreting them. I think Nestor was trying to find gems that others were either overlooking or dodging. It's now become clear why the likes of Bielik and Bany were dodged and SIJ, the other Villa kid and him from Palace were overlooked.
Data is great but it has to be viewed through a football lens, not just a business one.


RE: FAB - Derek Hardballs - 05-22-2026

(05-22-2026, 07:39 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(05-22-2026, 07:24 AM)Fido Wrote:
(05-21-2026, 05:55 PM)RamsAy it Wrote: I prefer a Solero myself.  FAB are for kids

Don’t forget to remind us Derek, how you were the last person on this board that wanted Pulis out.  <Just thought I’d jog your memory Big Grin>

Reminding people of things they posted historically can be very much a double-edged sword. Might be worth remembering that.

You're replying to the Marquis of ancient post retrieval there lad, he probably uses Python to automate it.

What ancient posts have I dug up out of curiosity?

(05-22-2026, 07:22 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-21-2026, 09:52 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-21-2026, 06:09 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: We recruited well individually this season, the problem was not the system or the analytics... The issue was no joined up thinking in terms of squad balance, and the misjudgment on the Fellows fee leaving us without a right winger, needing to sell Furlong and having no time or funds to replace them. We did not need to sign Bielik and had we spent that fee/wage on a right winger, I think we'd have had a better season.

As Morrison has shown, we built a squad that was capable of finishing much higher, it was just poorly used and lacked balance.

Let's hope Price can build on the positives of what Nestor introduced and add some more strategic thinking... I'll take our data based analytics approach over the massive recruitment success we had based on who Gourlay had heard of, knew the agent of and whoever was either Bruce's neighbour or shagging his daughter.

No analytics were needed to establish that having 5 centre backs but only two senior fit wide players was gonna be a problem

Exactly - and that's the point I'm making.

Derek wont be happy until every spreadsheet and computer in the club is thrown away and we go back to common sense scouting by sending people all round the world watching players, whereas I believe a lot of what Nestor did added value from a recruitment perspective as we were able to isolate some very talented, high potential players that we brought in at very good prices.

Where we've been too reliant on data for me is that we didn't consider the full balance of the squad. The model is working fine in isolating good players, but we have struggled to build a coherent unit and we still lack balance, however that's been an issue for 5-6 seasons, and isn't solely down to us deciding to use a laptop instead of someone's dad with a Cortina.

I argued that we relied on data too much with decision making, not that we shouldn’t use it.

That said, Megson and his dads success rate was pretty darned successful Wink


RE: FAB - Ted Maul - 05-22-2026

Any data model is only as good as the person using it. Who'd have thought it. Price will have his own model, and Morrison has done coaching badges too so I'm not sure what the point of the OP is? Other than another Dekka "look at me I know everything" that once again misses the mark.


RE: FAB - Derek Hardballs - 05-22-2026

(05-22-2026, 08:39 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Any data model is only as good as the person using it. Who'd have thought it. Price will have his own model, and Morrison has done coaching badges too so I'm not sure what the point of the OP is? Other than another Dekka "look at me I know everything" that once again misses the mark.

I argued that we relied too much on data, rather than a more rounded model of assessing players, tactics and managers. The quote I posted supports that argument. 

Please show me where I have said managers shouldn’t get coaching badges or use data?


RE: FAB - Ted Maul - 05-22-2026

(05-22-2026, 08:48 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-22-2026, 08:39 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Any data model is only as good as the person using it. Who'd have thought it. Price will have his own model, and Morrison has done coaching badges too so I'm not sure what the point of the OP is? Other than another Dekka "look at me I know everything" that once again misses the mark.

I argued that we relied too much on data, rather than a more rounded model of assessing players, tactics and managers. The quote I posted supports that argument. 

Please show me where I have said managers shouldn’t get coaching badges or use data?

This you?

(05-21-2026, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (pop your coaching qualifications up your bottom Wink )