![]() |
|
How did it come to this? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: How did it come to this? (/showthread.php?tid=41518) |
RE: How did it come to this? - Tippobaggie - 05-07-2026 (05-07-2026, 05:55 AM)Protheroe Wrote: What about the RRA? What about taxes on employers? What about fiscal drag? What about SDLT hikes? What about the minimum wage hikes rendering kids unemployable? What about welfare spending going i the opposite direction to that in the manifesto? The Iran war is the new "get out of jail" card for Labour, the old one "14 years of tory rule, £22 billion black hole" had been played far too many times, so boringly predictable so this new one should get them through to the next general election . RE: How did it come to this? - baggy1 - 05-07-2026 Proth conveniently forgetting him saying that whoever wins the next election will be in a shitshow shocker. Dekka in Tick Tock shocker Tippy in, well just being a Tippy shocker RE: How did it come to this? - Protheroe - 05-07-2026 (05-07-2026, 06:40 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Proth conveniently forgetting him saying that whoever wins the next election will be in a shitshow shocker. I haven't forgotten that. However it takes a very special government to go beyond utterly abandoning the welfare reforms they promised to actually increasing the welfare budget, it takes a very special government to price youngsters lacking experience out of a job, it takes a very special government to outlaw discrimination in letting rental homes yet lock out a whole cohort of low income and benefit dependent tenants from housing and it takes a monumental degree of hubris to suggest your government is laser focused on growth whilst doing everything in your power to strangle it. RE: How did it come to this? - Pontificator - 05-07-2026 (05-07-2026, 07:36 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(05-07-2026, 06:40 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Proth conveniently forgetting him saying that whoever wins the next election will be in a shitshow shocker. It takes a very special government to inherit stagnant growth, crumbling public services and record welfare dependency, yet still choose long-term reform over short-term headlines. It takes a very special government to recognise that simply slashing welfare without creating opportunity solves nothing, and that supporting vulnerable people while rebuilding the economy is not weakness but realism. It takes a very special government to believe young workers deserve decent pay rather than a race to the bottom in wages, and to accept that stronger employment rights and fairer standards are part of building a higher-productivity economy. It takes a very special government to try to end discrimination in the rental market because access to housing should not depend on prejudice, even while wrestling with a chronic housing shortage created over decades. And it takes remarkable political courage to stay focused on growth while asking powerful interests to pay more, investing in infrastructure, skills and green industry, and attempting to rebuild economic stability after years of chaos. Because genuine growth is not built on cheap labour, insecure housing and shrinking support for the vulnerable — it is built on investment, security and confidence in the future. I asked ChatGPT to write the counterfactual - what a spectacular result RE: How did it come to this? - baggy1 - 05-07-2026 You know my thoughts on the welfare changes, you need to speak to Dekka on that one. Youth unemployment running at about the average of the last 35 years and raising the minimum wage is a bad thing in your world I guess. And you'll have to explain to me how the RRA means 'a whole cohort of low income and benefit dependant tenants' are being locked out. I see you have got over the mental gymnastics involved with them closing the IHT loophole with the pension inclusion. A PENSION IS FOR YOUR RETIREMENT SPENDING NOT A WAY OF STORING MONEY TO PASS ONTO YOUR KIDS TAX FREE. (05-07-2026, 07:45 AM)Pontificator Wrote:(05-07-2026, 07:36 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(05-07-2026, 06:40 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Proth conveniently forgetting him saying that whoever wins the next election will be in a shitshow shocker. Nice one Ponty - this approach should improve productivity in my office spectacularly. RE: How did it come to this? - Derek Hardballs - 05-07-2026 (05-07-2026, 06:40 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Proth conveniently forgetting him saying that whoever wins the next election will be in a shitshow shocker. Ok, if you want to carry on burying your head in the sand when it comes to Starmer that’s up to you. He’s part of the problem not the solution, you may not like the fact he’s unpopular but that is something Labour will have to face up to at some point, unless they want to sleep walk into defeat at the next general election. Your eagerness to to see Labour kick the most vulnerable whist appeasing the most powerful is very ‘on message’… sadly at a local level you’ve enabled Green and Reform to what degree we will have to wait and see. RE: How did it come to this? - baggy1 - 05-07-2026 And what or who is the solution Dekka. I’ve asked dozens of times who you think should become the leader and what policies they will bring to solve the problems but tumbleweed every time. I don’t want to upset you either but I won’t be voting Labour tonight if that helps you understand my ‘blind allegiance’ And Arf, I’ve enabled Reform and Greens. A real loff with that one RE: How did it come to this? - Ted Maul - 05-07-2026 This Labour Government haven't been perfect and despite making some measurable improvements their PR remains awful. Compare and contrast to the Reform UK PR machine who when faced with Farage's most recent breach of HoC Code of Conduct simply shouted louder about the only Jewish leader of a political party in this country being an anti-semite. The lack of critical thinking skills in this country is alarming. RE: How did it come to this? - Protheroe - 05-07-2026 (05-07-2026, 07:45 AM)Pontificator Wrote:(05-07-2026, 07:36 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(05-07-2026, 06:40 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Proth conveniently forgetting him saying that whoever wins the next election will be in a shitshow shocker. Can you ask ChatGPT what the "long-term reform" of welfare actually comprises? Every model suggests welfare spending rising in real terms, every year, forever. I have no problem supporting vulnerable people - after all that's what the welfare state is for. The welfare state is not for supporting those who can work but choose not to. Can ChatGPT inform us why any employer would choose to take a chance on an inexperienced teen when they can employ someone in their mid 20s for the same money? Can ChatGPT explain why an employee would take on extra responsibility at work for a pittance above the Minimum Wage? Can ChatGPT explain how increasing workers rights translates into greater productivity? Because the only way I can see that working is firms replacing people with machinery and AI. Is that what Rayner was getting at? "Housing should not depend on prejudice", oh my aching sides. The RRA actually CREATES PREJUDICE because rights and responsibilities are no longer balanced. I think you've found the limitations of AI Ponty. RE: How did it come to this? - Derek Hardballs - 05-07-2026 (05-07-2026, 08:14 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And what or who is the solution Dekka. I’ve asked dozens of times who you think should become the leader and what policies they will bring to solve the problems but tumbleweed every time. When I say you, I meant those who continue to believe and defend Starmer as a leader and his blue Labour policies. Blaming immigrants and the disabled has pushed those on the right towards Reform and those who dislike the right of centre ‘message’ that Labour pushed for their first year in charge at least have headed to the Greens. I had a ‘loff’ when you declared I was ruining your children’s future for defending the disabled. |