WBAUnofficial
At what point - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: At what point (/showthread.php?tid=40718)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: At what point - Cheshire East Baggie - 02-21-2026

(02-21-2026, 02:43 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(02-21-2026, 02:14 PM)Peachofacross Wrote:
(02-21-2026, 02:09 PM)johntoewba Wrote: Just something else to cheer us up we are in the bottom 3

Exactly where we deserve to be though...

it is, but we're not.

Cov and Boro are where they are because they play forwards (apart from when already winning against us and they can't be arsed to try).

You win by scoring, any manager that sets up to not lose is always going to fail, unless their plans actually have an attacking chapter in them.

Playing forward helps your defence, because it makes the opposition think they have to defend, we do not do either.. we seem to think that tossing the ball around the centre circle and back to the goalkeeper instead of attacking is clever.

It's a load of modern old wank and it needs binning. Maybe it works when your team has £150m players in it.

Tossing the ball around the centre circle and back to the goalkeeper instead of attacking is pretty much what we did from October onwards when CC was boss. Our lack of attacking threat goes back far beyond Ramsay and Mason. Carlos drilled an absolute no-risk attitude into these players. Three coaches since have failed to change the mindset.


RE: At what point - TartanRug - 02-21-2026

(02-21-2026, 10:59 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(02-21-2026, 02:43 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(02-21-2026, 02:14 PM)Peachofacross Wrote:
(02-21-2026, 02:09 PM)johntoewba Wrote: Just something else to cheer us up we are in the bottom 3

Exactly where we deserve to be though...

it is, but we're not.

Cov and Boro are where they are because they play forwards (apart from when already winning against us and they can't be arsed to try).

You win by scoring, any manager that sets up to not lose is always going to fail, unless their plans actually have an attacking chapter in them.

Playing forward helps your defence, because it makes the opposition think they have to defend, we do not do either.. we seem to think that tossing the ball around the centre circle and back to the goalkeeper instead of attacking is clever.

It's a load of modern old wank and it needs binning. Maybe it works when your team has £150m players in it.

Tossing the ball around the centre circle and back to the goalkeeper instead of attacking is pretty much what we did from October onwards when CC was boss. Our lack of attacking threat goes back far beyond Ramsay and Mason. Carlos drilled an absolute no-risk attitude into these players. Three coaches since have failed to change the mindset.

For a no-risk mindset we sure as hell concede a lot


RE: At what point - Merkinagogo - 02-21-2026

(02-21-2026, 10:59 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(02-21-2026, 02:43 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(02-21-2026, 02:14 PM)Peachofacross Wrote:
(02-21-2026, 02:09 PM)johntoewba Wrote: Just something else to cheer us up we are in the bottom 3

Exactly where we deserve to be though...

it is, but we're not.

Cov and Boro are where they are because they play forwards (apart from when already winning against us and they can't be arsed to try).

You win by scoring, any manager that sets up to not lose is always going to fail, unless their plans actually have an attacking chapter in them.

Playing forward helps your defence, because it makes the opposition think they have to defend, we do not do either.. we seem to think that tossing the ball around the centre circle and back to the goalkeeper instead of attacking is clever.

It's a load of modern old wank and it needs binning. Maybe it works when your team has £150m players in it.

Tossing the ball around the centre circle and back to the goalkeeper instead of attacking is pretty much what we did from October onwards when CC was boss. Our lack of attacking threat goes back far beyond Ramsay and Mason. Carlos drilled an absolute no-risk attitude into these players. Three coaches since have failed to change the mindset.

I don't think the goal keeper or any of the defenders from Carlos' last game are still at the club, tbh


RE: At what point - Lightnin - 02-21-2026

My issue is that we try to keep it tight but we can’t, end up going 2 or 3 down and then we try the more positive approach. Why don’t we try the positive approach first, give ourselves something to defend if we need to rather than a 0-0 and then trying to pinch it. 8 games for Ramsay and we’ve scored 3, you’ll win nothing with a record like that.


RE: At what point - Tom Joad 25 - 02-22-2026

(02-21-2026, 11:34 PM)Lightnin Wrote: My issue is that we try to keep it tight but we can’t, end up going 2 or 3 down and then we try the more positive approach. Why don’t we try the positive approach first, give ourselves something to defend if we need to rather than a 0-0 and then trying to pinch it. 8 games for Ramsay and we’ve scored 3, you’ll win nothing with a record like that.

True 'nuff. That said though, we were on the front foot yesterday, attacking their box, one long ball out and we found ourselves a goal down. It is the same problems that haunted us under Mason and Mowbray, conceding soft goals. Our defence is aots, our midfield gets passed through/ran through regularly and our strikers are often nowhere near a position where they will score. I don't know if Ramsey is or isn't up to the job but first and foremost he has to make us more difficult to score against. Whether the fans will tolerate that and whether he is up to coaching just that, I have no clue. One obvious problem though is confidence,  it visibly drains out of these players way too fast. At some point they need to man up, be their own leader and the coach has to be the one that instills this.


RE: At what point - WorcsWBA - 02-22-2026

In my view, both goals that we conceded yesterday were entirely the fault of Gilchrist, so we shouldn't blame the whole defence for them. Other than that, O'Leary didn't have a serious save to make. Whether that was down to Coventry coasting or not is up for debate, but to my mind by far our most serious problem is our lack of attacking threat and cohesion. I was expecting us to be showing signs of improvement in that area yesterday, but we didn't. Heggebo never even had a shot that I can recall. We also showed no sign of increasing our threat from set pieces.

Whilst I'm satisfied that our defending has improved markedly overall during the last 3 league games, if we can't score and don't even look like scoring not only does it make fans disgruntled more quickly, thus increasing the pressure on the players and creating a downward spiral, but it also means we'll have no hope of staying up. I'm sure Eric Ramsay realises this, so for us to be still as bad going forward as we are is a mystery. To not be showing signs of addressing this fundamental issue is ultimately as masochistic as it is baffling. With another quick turnaround ahead of Tuesday, it's hard to see that much can be done before we play Charlton either, but improve we must as we absolutely need to win the game.


RE: At what point - Tom Joad 25 - 02-22-2026

(02-22-2026, 09:18 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: In my view, both goals that we conceded yesterday were entirely the fault of Gilchrist, so we shouldn't blame the whole defence for them. Other than that, O'Leary didn't have a serious save to make. Whether that was down to Coventry coasting or not is up for debate, but to my mind by far our most serious problem is our lack of attacking threat and cohesion. I was expecting us to be showing signs of improvement in that area yesterday, but we didn't. Heggebo never even had a shot that I can recall. We also showed no sign of increasing our threat from set pieces.

Whilst I'm satisfied that our defending has improved markedly overall during the last 3 league games, if we can't score and don't even look like scoring not only does it make fans disgruntled more quickly, thus increasing the pressure on the players and creating a downward spiral, but it also means we'll have no hope of staying up. I'm sure Eric Ramsay realises this, so for us to be still as bad going forward as we are is a mystery. To not be showing signs of addressing this fundamental issue is ultimately as masochistic as it is baffling. With another quick turnaround ahead of Tuesday, it's hard to see that much can be done before we play Charlton either, but improve we must as we absolutely need to win the game.

Agree, and much as I don't like to spacegoat a player we looked fairly reassured in defence once Campbell came on. We need to work out how to get Heggebo 10 yards upfield. That can only come through carrying the ball forward either on the wing or through midfield.  The latter probably won't ever happen so wings it is.


RE: At what point - 1952 - 02-22-2026

I agree using the wings is our most viable option to create scoring chances. The problem is at least half the crosses attempted yesterday were awful, often clattering into the first defender. Why did Jimbho drift inside so much too? Was he obstructed to? The number of time Styles needed him when we had space and wasn't there. He was truly bad yesterday, never beat a man either. Bostock may not be better be he would have stayed out wide.


RE: At what point - Cheshire East Baggie - 02-22-2026

(02-22-2026, 09:18 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: In my view, both goals that we conceded yesterday were entirely the fault of Gilchrist, so we shouldn't blame the whole defence for them. Other than that, O'Leary didn't have a serious save to make. Whether that was down to Coventry coasting or not is up for debate, but to my mind by far our most serious problem is our lack of attacking threat and cohesion. I was expecting us to be showing signs of improvement in that area yesterday, but we didn't. Heggebo never even had a shot that I can recall. We also showed no sign of increasing our threat from set pieces.

Whilst I'm satisfied that our defending has improved markedly overall during the last 3 league games, if we can't score and don't even look like scoring not only does it make fans disgruntled more quickly, thus increasing the pressure on the players and creating a downward spiral, but it also means we'll have no hope of staying up. I'm sure Eric Ramsay realises this, so for us to be still as bad going forward as we are is a mystery. To not be showing signs of addressing this fundamental issue is ultimately as masochistic as it is baffling. With another quick turnaround ahead of Tuesday, it's hard to see that much can be done before we play Charlton either, but improve we must as we absolutely need to win the game.

I think it's fair to say that Gilchrist was entirely responsible for the first, which completely flattened the players. The second was a joint effort, as no-one got anywhere near the scorer. Both came from losing possession unnecessarily, which we do all the time. I can imagine Alan Hansen freezing the action at the point where we lose the ball and saying "Please don't tell me you're going to concede a goal from here" as he did so often during Mowbray's Great Surrender season.

Our best CB combo is probably two out of Bielik, Phillips and Taylor. Phillips needs a proper defender next to him, and probably benefits from a more vocal goalie than Josh. Campbell is our only option at RB IMO, otherwise he'd be in the middle. My question is why did Ramsay take a risk playing Gilchrist once Campbell was available? He left Campbell mostly on the bench while we were conceding goals for fun against Norwich - does he not rate him? Is ER really GreetsGreenBaggie?


RE: At what point - Hughie Reed 31 - 02-22-2026

I think we need to move Styles into central midfield only player other than Johnston who can carry the ball
And break the lines cannot understand why this season’s managers have not tried it this will help Heggebo and also the wide players to be higher up the pitch and so hopefully create more chances.