WBAUnofficial
Ratings v Derby - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings v Derby (/showthread.php?tid=40331)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Ratings v Derby - KRO - 01-24-2026

(01-24-2026, 07:34 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: MOL - 5 - Gains a mark for his distribution. Loses 2 for his fuck up as it was that bad. 

Bielik - 6 - Did well at times especially considering he was playing with a shoulder injury. Proper man but seems his body doesn't agree, his passing is a big plus from the back. 
Phillips - 6 Better today, but hard to really judge as we had so many players screening him and Derby didn't offer much. 
Campbell - 6 - Has to play. But again wasn't challenged in what was a really poor game. 

Price - 6 - Monster shift as usual. One moment of quality with his cross. Wasted at RWB when asked to play so deep and square. If we are going to clunky our way to safety with a flat back 5 like last night, play a defensive RB there. 
Molumby - 7 - Usual graft, usual benefits, usual issues, gets an assist too for his flick. 
Diakite - 7 - Good screening for the back 5. Recycled the ball. Not their fault, but Dialumby, won't work long term though. Unless we get the rest of the team absolutely purring.
Styles - 6 - Worked hard, struggled to get an involvement in the game though really. But like Price was so deep and square and fixed to his position. Probably instructional. 

MJ - 6 - Kept trying to make stuff happen, a few nearly moments but largely frustrating, but did lack support and runners so was often crowded out by Derbys midfield and defence. 
Heggebo - 6 - Usual shift and 3/4 genuinely world class bits of link up play. Like MJ, suffered with lack of runners and support. 
Grant - Can't judge as was off too early. 

Subs:

SIJ - 5 - Shit further forward. Less shit at LWB.
Wallace - 6 - Ran a lot, not much impact. 
Mepham - 7 - Did well when he came on. Aggressive in the tackle at the back and got his goal. 
Dike & Maja - ? - To be fair to them they had hardly any service, and we rarely got up to support them. Hard to mark them. 

Ramsay - 6 - Got it more wrong than right for me last night. Wrong starting XI for the way he set us up - If you're going with a flat back 5 with the instructions to defend from a shape and not really break out from it play Gilchrist as a RB not price, because last night they definitely weren't 'wingbacks'. Wrong subs, we were, as always crying out for more of a threat in the centre of the pitch, but I do kind of understand the reluctance to lose that solidity in CM. Then the straight swap when Bielik went off showed the lack of ambition, fortunately, luck was with us and Mepham scored the equaliser, so I have to separate my feelings and opinions on the game management and the end result a little. It's also worth noting, that whilst I didn't agree with the changes in full, the swaps at 60 mins were technically attacking in nature and timely which is far more than Mason ever dished up.

As I said in the match Fred, I will clock it down as the last 'pre season friendly' of his during his first week. He now has a full week having seen his entire squad and would expect to see more threat on the break and more ambition in our attacking play and line ups.

Overall - Many got what they wanted last night. "Back to Basics". Deep, compact, little ambition and all of our decent opportunities came via set pieces, bar Molumbys tame effort from the edge of the box. Will that be enough over the remaining if the season? Probably, and I am willing to cut him some slack as long as we are well organised.
Watching it as a neutral I wouldn’t argue with any of those really. Fair do’s


RE: Ratings v Derby - wba13 - 01-24-2026

So O’Leary gets a 5 which would have been a 7 but for his fuck up, yet golden boy Mickey gets a 6 and loses nothing for his fuck up which led to the free kick which led to the goal. He gets a 4 from me.Campbell a seven helped shore the back up.
The rest I agree with.
As I said on another thread last night wouldn’t mind if Mickey was sold can be excellent but also does stupid things in the wrong half of pitch. Just my opinion though.


RE: Ratings v Derby - 1952 - 01-24-2026

(01-24-2026, 10:06 AM)wba13 Wrote: So O’Leary gets a 5 which would have been a 7 but for his fuck up, yet golden boy Mickey gets a 6 and loses nothing for his fuck up which led to the free kick which led to the goal. He gets a 4 from me.Campbell a seven helped shore the back up.
The rest I agree with.
As I said on another thread last night wouldn’t mind if Mickey was sold can be excellent but also does stupid things in the wrong half of pitch. Just my opinion though.

MJ's elaborate cock ups have cost us quite a few times this season. He's not alone though.


RE: Ratings v Derby - wba13 - 01-24-2026

(01-24-2026, 10:45 AM)1952 Wrote:
(01-24-2026, 10:06 AM)wba13 Wrote: So O’Leary gets a 5 which would have been a 7 but for his fuck up, yet golden boy Mickey gets a 6 and loses nothing for his fuck up which led to the free kick which led to the goal. He gets a 4 from me.Campbell a seven helped shore the back up.
The rest I agree with.
As I said on another thread last night wouldn’t mind if Mickey was sold can be excellent but also does stupid things in the wrong half of pitch. Just my opinion though.

MJ's elaborate cock ups have cost us quite a few times this season. He's not alone though.

I agree he’s not alone but because fans love his step overs and pirouettes they cut him some slack, well in the last few weeks he has done them in the wrong half of the pitch and last nights was ridiculous.


RE: Ratings v Derby - Lurker#3 - 01-24-2026

(01-24-2026, 10:06 AM)wba13 Wrote: So O’Leary gets a 5 which would have been a 7 but for his fuck up, yet golden boy Mickey gets a 6 and loses nothing for his fuck up which led to the free kick which led to the goal. He gets a 4 from me.Campbell a seven helped shore the back up.
The rest I agree with.
As I said on another thread last night wouldn’t mind if Mickey was sold can be excellent but also does stupid things in the wrong half of pitch. Just my opinion though.

Flair player in being hammered for doing flair-y things shocker! 

The same people who bash MJ are the same ones who couldn't see Grady's contribution when fit.


RE: Ratings v Derby - wba13 - 01-24-2026

(01-24-2026, 11:33 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-24-2026, 10:06 AM)wba13 Wrote: So O’Leary gets a 5 which would have been a 7 but for his fuck up, yet golden boy Mickey gets a 6 and loses nothing for his fuck up which led to the free kick which led to the goal. He gets a 4 from me.Campbell a seven helped shore the back up.
The rest I agree with.
As I said on another thread last night wouldn’t mind if Mickey was sold can be excellent but also does stupid things in the wrong half of pitch. Just my opinion though.

Flair player in being hammered for doing flair-y things shocker! 

The same people who bash MJ are the same ones who couldn't see Grady's contribution when fit.
I don’t care if he does outside the opposition penalty area, but your own surrounded by players when an easy pass is on its pathetic and un disciplined, as good a player as he is he is also a liability in his own half of the pitch. 
As for Grady what contribution he only played when Periera was here.very very inconsistent.


RE: Ratings v Derby - tHEgLASSdOORS - 01-24-2026

Agreed 13


RE: Ratings v Derby - Jacko - 01-24-2026

O'Leary 3 - had one thing to do, fucked it.

Bielik 7 - excellent, pity he's set for a spell on the sidelines.
Phillips 7 - back to something like his best, headed everything in sight.
Campbell 8 - we've got a good one here, right footer, playing left centre back and totally bossed it.

Price 7 - got up and down well, a few really good crosses in an unfamiliar role that doesnt get the most out of him.
Diakite 8 - intercepted everything, used the ball well, big beneficiary of the change in management I feel.
Molumby 7 - great flick on from the training ground setpiece, won a couple of freekicks he had no right to win. Poor on the ball.
Styles 7 - played well back out on the left flank a good foil for Campbell.

Johnston 6 - not his night, caught in possession in the build up to the freekick for their goal.
Heggebø 6.5 - couple of good buts of hold-up play against a back drop of not much protection from another poor ref, didn't offer any goal threat.
Grant NA - looks like a hammy so we're finally going to see something different in the attack.

Villacunt 2 - disinterested, lacking bottle, lacking quality. Every touch booed by the normally generous away fans from about 65 minutes onwards, if it's possible under the terms of the loan he has to be sent back to Bodymoor Heath.

Dike 6 - made some decent runs, a threat at setpieces but desperately needs minutes in his legs.
Maja 6 - still gets himself into good positions both dropping deep and goalscoring positions, not quite happening for him at present.
Wallace 7 - an all energy performance from the skipper, I'm firmly of a mind he can't play 90 minutes any more and he's not able to stretch defences, but used correctly is still an asset.

Mepham 10 - you fucking beauty  Big Grin

Ramsay 9 - Derby had no shots on target other than the goal which was dropped on the guys foot 2 yards out. The away performance we haven't seen for nearly 4 months. We were a threat and created several half chances which I daresay would have been goals if they'd fallen to random Norwich players 72 hours previous. Set up and performance deserved the point at the very least and it should not be underestimated how tough it will have been to pick the squad up off the floor and get those levels out of them.


RE: Ratings v Derby - Lurker#3 - 01-24-2026

Crikey, Jacko. You're in a good mood.


RE: Ratings v Derby - Jacko - 01-24-2026

I thought it was as good a performance as we could have expected 70 hours after the final whistle on Tuesday. Ticked every box.