WBAUnofficial
This Squad - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: This Squad (/showthread.php?tid=40274)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: This Squad - Logic1 - 01-21-2026

(01-21-2026, 08:24 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: A post about the squad and our transfer dealings without really going into the Fellows transfer, we took the only offer on the table and we needed to sell. Same goes for Taylor. The job of Nestor and his team is to replace them and that's where I'm going with this.

There were a few posters on here shouted down for pointing out the lack of balance we'd been left with in this squad. After a performance like that, under our second manager of the season and with a completely different system you can really see how hard it is to produce a coherent XI from the players available. Mason, for all of his faults, managed with the help of a full pre-season to have them functioning to start with but once it started to go wrong he had nowhere to go, there are no major changes that can be made with this group.

- Our goalkeeping department is as weak as it's been in years and we've got a young keeper hung out to dry behind a non-existent defence.

- We sold Furlong because we had to, he was everyone's favourite spacegoat but it turns out he was one of the most consistent RBs in the division. Funny that. He could defend, he could offer an overlap and he occasionally cropped up with a goal. He's not been replaced.

- Our options at RB are a centre half and a lad who's best position is the very niche, RB but one that tucks in to make a three when you're in possession. He's also 21 and still very much learning his way in the game. Given his age it's probably time to stick him in the team and play to his strengths.

- No one saw it coming with Mepham and Phillips and they were lauded as good signings. Phillips drops a bollock every game. Mepham is better on the ball but at the moment he barely looks like a footballer. Can't drop them both so it's probably time for Campbell to get a few games at CB

- LB probably the least of our worries, Styles has done a good job there and even SIJ is showing some promise when played in his actual position (lol). SIJ also capable of playing the wing back role on this side.

- CM, still going with Molumby and Mowatt doing the job of one player. Price should have been playing here from much earlier in the season but people thought because he scored a few goals in August he simply must play as far up the pitch as possible. M&M are the best we can do but they lack the running power to trouble a team meaning we play really nicely in front of everyone.

- On the wings we have SIJ who can play left but spent 25 games on the bench or wide right. We have Grant who's niche position is running around a lot and cutting in off the left, we have MJ who can do this but is also a threat from the right. We have Wallace who was put in the dungeon by Mason and who's legs are going but is probably called for now we're in such dire straits, more from the perspective of morale than anything else.

- Upfront Dike is off, Maja has gone already and Heggebo looks every bit a young lad in a strange land trying to learn how to play at this level. 

We have individual players with enough quality at this level as was the criticism of Mason not doing enough with them. For all his faults, one of the reasons I didn't go as early with the Mason Out is that I didn't see the options that many others thought he had. He had his issues with in game management but could set a team up as we saw at the start of the season with the benefit of a full pre-season.

Ramsay has shown that he probably has a bit more nous in terms of game management as we saw with changes on Friday and at HT last night but doesn't have the benefit of a long pre-season to get to know his squad. Across both managers the same issues persist.

I see a squad that has quality but realistically only gives us one way of playing and that is the fault of Nestor and his recruitment team, I hope Ramsay can figure that out quickly.  Between now and the end of the season I'd like to see the following.

Griffiths; Gilchrist, Campbell, Bielik, Styles; Mowatt, Molumby; Johnston, Price, Grant; Heggebo.

Get Gilchrist tucked into a back three when we've got the ball, LB be it Styles of SIJ really high and wide to allow Grant inside, MJ wide on the right. The only loser is Price who I don't think is a ten but at this stage we just need to get to may an make sure we're not in the third division.

What a fucking miserable state of affairs.

If you think playing with a back three is going to keep us in this division, you are on cloud-cuckoo land just like our new manager. Management needs time, but our manager does not have time. He needs to realise that he has made a msitake, own it and rectify it.


RE: This Squad - WorcsWBA - 01-21-2026

(01-21-2026, 09:38 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(01-21-2026, 09:33 AM)AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke Wrote: Lack of leadership on the pitch is evident and killing us. Corberan patched over it by drilling them to death, the wheels have fallen off since the place started being run like a consultancy. Hopefully someone in that squad summons up their testicles from somewhere and starts putting them to use. It's not all on the manager.

Over the last 25 years where we've been in a perilous position and needed a manager to get us out of a scrape, whether it be Megson, Hodgson, Pulis or Carlos, they all based it on getting the squad organised and well drilled. That is exactly what is needed at the moment and what Ramsay needs to learn fast rather than being another Pepe Mel as others have already said.

It's been reported a fair bit that Eric's approach is based on players being well-drilled and knowing exactly what's expected of them (whether they can do it or not is another matter of course), hence his regular comments about "clarity". He's been here 8 days with games coming thick and fast, and it's been raining for a lot of that time, so I think we need to take a collective deep breath, get through the Derby game and then see what happens once Eric gets a decent run of time on the training pitch without there being a game looming. I don't think it makes any sense to be drawing conclusions about his capabilities or his approach at this juncture. Just one example, as we know, he's an advocate of players looking to make forward passes with purpose as much as possible, yet there's been scant evidence of that so far. He needs time to get them up to speed on it. If they can implement it, I'm sure we'll look much better for it. Obviously we need to start picking up points urgently, but everyone at the club will be very well aware of that.

Ted's OP is excellent, although I'm very eager to see Dike getting game time, rather than being written off, because I think he could offer us a lot more than the mostly disinterested Maja.


RE: This Squad - Ted Maul - 01-21-2026

(01-21-2026, 09:52 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(01-21-2026, 08:24 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: A post about the squad and our transfer dealings without really going into the Fellows transfer, we took the only offer on the table and we needed to sell. Same goes for Taylor. The job of Nestor and his team is to replace them and that's where I'm going with this.

There were a few posters on here shouted down for pointing out the lack of balance we'd been left with in this squad. After a performance like that, under our second manager of the season and with a completely different system you can really see how hard it is to produce a coherent XI from the players available. Mason, for all of his faults, managed with the help of a full pre-season to have them functioning to start with but once it started to go wrong he had nowhere to go, there are no major changes that can be made with this group.

- Our goalkeeping department is as weak as it's been in years and we've got a young keeper hung out to dry behind a non-existent defence.

- We sold Furlong because we had to, he was everyone's favourite spacegoat but it turns out he was one of the most consistent RBs in the division. Funny that. He could defend, he could offer an overlap and he occasionally cropped up with a goal. He's not been replaced.

- Our options at RB are a centre half and a lad who's best position is the very niche, RB but one that tucks in to make a three when you're in possession. He's also 21 and still very much learning his way in the game. Given his age it's probably time to stick him in the team and play to his strengths.

- No one saw it coming with Mepham and Phillips and they were lauded as good signings. Phillips drops a bollock every game. Mepham is better on the ball but at the moment he barely looks like a footballer. Can't drop them both so it's probably time for Campbell to get a few games at CB

- LB probably the least of our worries, Styles has done a good job there and even SIJ is showing some promise when played in his actual position (lol). SIJ also capable of playing the wing back role on this side.

- CM, still going with Molumby and Mowatt doing the job of one player. Price should have been playing here from much earlier in the season but people thought because he scored a few goals in August he simply must play as far up the pitch as possible. M&M are the best we can do but they lack the running power to trouble a team meaning we play really nicely in front of everyone.

- On the wings we have SIJ who can play left but spent 25 games on the bench or wide right. We have Grant who's niche position is running around a lot and cutting in off the left, we have MJ who can do this but is also a threat from the right. We have Wallace who was put in the dungeon by Mason and who's legs are going but is probably called for now we're in such dire straits, more from the perspective of morale than anything else.

- Upfront Dike is off, Maja has gone already and Heggebo looks every bit a young lad in a strange land trying to learn how to play at this level. 

We have individual players with enough quality at this level as was the criticism of Mason not doing enough with them. For all his faults, one of the reasons I didn't go as early with the Mason Out is that I didn't see the options that many others thought he had. He had his issues with in game management but could set a team up as we saw at the start of the season with the benefit of a full pre-season.

Ramsay has shown that he probably has a bit more nous in terms of game management as we saw with changes on Friday and at HT last night but doesn't have the benefit of a long pre-season to get to know his squad. Across both managers the same issues persist.

I see a squad that has quality but realistically only gives us one way of playing and that is the fault of Nestor and his recruitment team, I hope Ramsay can figure that out quickly.  Between now and the end of the season I'd like to see the following.

Griffiths; Gilchrist, Campbell, Bielik, Styles; Mowatt, Molumby; Johnston, Price, Grant; Heggebo.

Get Gilchrist tucked into a back three when we've got the ball, LB be it Styles of SIJ really high and wide to allow Grant inside, MJ wide on the right. The only loser is Price who I don't think is a ten but at this stage we just need to get to may an make sure we're not in the third division.

What a fucking miserable state of affairs.

If you think playing with a back three is going to keep us in this division, you are on cloud-cuckoo land just like our new manager. Management needs time, but our manager does not have time. He needs to realise that he has made a msitake, own it and rectify it.

The team I've picked is a back four out of possession.


RE: This Squad - 1952 - 01-21-2026

Some great posts and comments here. 
I don't think anyone saw that coming last night, least of all Eric. I'm sure him and his management team will be working very hard to try to rectify it (as I'm sure Mason did). New Mananager and bounce hardly go together for us.
I think we have to rely on Oxford and Portsmouth or Blackburn being worse than us and a change of luck to survive.
I've no hope of getting anything Friday against a bogey team. 
Going to be a long hard journey to the seasons end.
We need players to step up, quickly.


RE: This Squad - Vinebaggie - 01-21-2026

(01-21-2026, 11:17 AM)1952 Wrote: Some great posts and comments here. 
I don't think anyone saw that coming last night, least of all Eric. I'm sure him and his management team will be working very hard to try to rectify it (as I'm sure Mason did). New Mananager and bounce hardly go together for us.
I think we have to rely on Oxford and Portsmouth or Blackburn being worse than us and a change of luck to survive.
I've no hope of getting anything Friday against a bogey team. 
Going to be a long hard journey to the seasons end.
We need players to step up, quickly.

It’d be lovely to see Maja supping his cornflakes quickly, maybe even combing his hair quickly, or hanging his trousers up quickly, doubt if we’ll ever see him or anyone else in this team do anything quickly


RE: This Squad - GunsOfNavarone - 01-21-2026

(01-21-2026, 11:22 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote:
(01-21-2026, 11:17 AM)1952 Wrote: Some great posts and comments here. 
I don't think anyone saw that coming last night, least of all Eric. I'm sure him and his management team will be working very hard to try to rectify it (as I'm sure Mason did). New Mananager and bounce hardly go together for us.
I think we have to rely on Oxford and Portsmouth or Blackburn being worse than us and a change of luck to survive.
I've no hope of getting anything Friday against a bogey team. 
Going to be a long hard journey to the seasons end.
We need players to step up, quickly.

It’d be lovely to see Maja supping his cornflakes quickly, maybe even combing his hair quickly, or hanging his trousers up quickly, doubt if we’ll ever see him or anyone else in this team do anything quickly......

.... other than regress into their shells. I've seen snails move quicker.


RE: This Squad - Tom Joad 25 - 01-21-2026

(01-21-2026, 09:38 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(01-21-2026, 09:33 AM)AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke Wrote: Lack of leadership on the pitch is evident and killing us. Corberan patched over it by drilling them to death, the wheels have fallen off since the place started being run like a consultancy. Hopefully someone in that squad summons up their testicles from somewhere and starts putting them to use. It's not all on the manager.

Over the last 25 years where we've been in a perilous position and needed a manager to get us out of a scrape, whether it be Megson, Hodgson, Pulis or Carlos, they all based it on getting the squad organised and well drilled. That is exactly what is needed at the moment and what Ramsay needs to learn fast rather than being another Pepe Mel as others have already said.

Agree here, and with the OP.  Comparisons with the previous manager are of no use, we are where we are. The only shred of positivity I'm clutching to is that due to fixtures Ramsay had only a couple or three, four at most, days on the training pitch. Same this week with Derby on Friday. I see no option other than to hope for improvement in a month. Fact is, there is still plenty of teams we can drag in with plenty of games to do so.
As the OP said, this is on Nestor and his inexperience. When Carlos left we needed another organised coach. I suggested Eustace (who applied for the job) but warned it wouldn't be a popular choice, we had different ideas then. If ER is the organiser we heard about then we will find out after a month or so. Meantime, he'll have one day's training before the Derby game so anyone expecting anything different will be disappointed.


RE: This Squad - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 01-21-2026

(01-21-2026, 11:22 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote:
(01-21-2026, 11:17 AM)1952 Wrote: Some great posts and comments here. 
I don't think anyone saw that coming last night, least of all Eric. I'm sure him and his management team will be working very hard to try to rectify it (as I'm sure Mason did). New Mananager and bounce hardly go together for us.
I think we have to rely on Oxford and Portsmouth or Blackburn being worse than us and a change of luck to survive.
I've no hope of getting anything Friday against a bogey team. 
Going to be a long hard journey to the seasons end.
We need players to step up, quickly.

It’d be lovely to see Maja supping his cornflakes quickly, maybe even combing his hair quickly, or hanging his trousers up quickly, doubt if we’ll ever see him or anyone else in this team do anything quickly
Except pick up their wages.


RE: This Squad - ElbowGrease73 - 01-21-2026

(01-21-2026, 09:33 AM)AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke Wrote: Lack of leadership on the pitch is evident and killing us. Corberan patched over it by drilling them to death, the wheels have fallen off since the place started being run like a consultancy. Hopefully someone in that squad summons up their testicles from somewhere and starts putting them to use. It's not all on the manager.

Exactly this - Who was handing out the bollockings on the pitch when the goals were flying in? Absolutely no one. Have some pride in your own performance and your profession. They should be taking this personally and they should be determined to make amends.

There should be a massive reaction on Friday, but I suspect it will be another toothless display.


RE: This Squad - bayliss - 01-21-2026

We are as fucked as a fucked thing.

Once the squad has given up (they have) there ain't any way back.

Last night, post match, Billy Hills and Bet365 went *16/1 about us being relegated.

Fucking clueless.

(*that soon went, but they were filled in first)