WBAUnofficial
An argument for keeping Mason? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: An argument for keeping Mason? (/showthread.php?tid=39770)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - CIM - 12-21-2025

(12-21-2025, 10:22 AM)Old Fart Wrote: I saw Alan F Irvine sitting next to David Moyes on MOTD last night.  

He too is a coach destined never to have what it takes to be a successful manager. 

The unfounded optimism that somehow Mason is going to stumble across a winning formula is deluded. 

He's going to get sacked.  It's just a case of how much damage is going to be caused first by a stupidly tolerant but naive club hierarchy.

+1


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Mouse - 12-21-2025

Go on I’ll bite, the guy (in the nicest way possible) is a loser and that feeds down into the team and through the club. People are accepting this as ok because we've been told we're lucky to be in this position and we need to be patient.

I can accept that it'll take time to rebuild and that we are closer to league one than premier league but what I can't accept is poor decision making without learning from his mistakes, delusional assessments post game and lack of any real inspiration. 

The gu couldn't inspire a dog to chase a ball let alone inspire a football team. When the chips are downs the players are looking to him for guidance all they get is a bloke folding his arms shaking his head. But it’s ok because he’s a nice bloke.

All our recent success has come with someone in charge who can motivate a group of players to perform and in most cases those people aren’t always liked, but they are respected.

Even Bryan Robson managed to motivate for a short period (although probably a bad example).

We need a bit of nastiness, and with Mason we haven’t got that.


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Cheshire East Baggie - 12-21-2025

The question I'm asking myself is, "what do posters on here want?"

I want our results to improve, but I also want us to build sustainability of the playing side of things - improving squad, competent coach, all the things that lead to promotion. I don't care whether that's with or without Ryan Mason. I don't know whether Mason can be that coach or whether Nestor can build that squad.

I think a lot of posters on here can't see past sacking Mason and Nestor. Is that a guaranteed fix or just a continuation of the risk-taking?


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - SW4Baggie - 12-21-2025

I am absolutely in the Mason Out camp and have been for quite some time, and a couple of decent home results haven’t done anywhere near enough to convince me he has a long term future here.

The only 3 reasons that people continually give to justify retaining Mason are frankly not good enough.

1. If we sack him we will look like the type of club that sacks managers regularly - Val was sacked too soon IMO, but we had parachute payment advantage and a clueless ownership, Carlos would still be here had he not left for Valencia, and all of Bruce, Mowbray and Mason have been given too much time.

2. You don’t appoint a rookie manager and not expect a learning curve - this is fine if he is actually demonstrating improvement, but he is not. Since Mason arrived we have been a team that plays well for 45 minutes in most games but struggles for long periods too. We have also shown a weakness for conceding silly goals and making numerous routine defensive errors, he’s had over 20 games in charge now and there is no sign of improvement. The only variation is now when we concede the inevitable goal, and which spell of the game we play well in. We are still a side that struggles to execute a game plan for longer than one half, and we struggle to adapt in game.

3. We have a weak and unbalanced squad - us and 20 other teams in this league. Every club always needs one or 2 more players, it’s a manager’s job to find a way to get points from the players he has available and RM does not do this well enough. He doggedly sticks to the same players, fails to try new things unless injury forces his hand, and seems absolutely unwilling to use certain members of his squad. It’s all well and good moaning about lack of options but when you’re not using several squad members, you can’t use this as an excuse.

It’s been said many times, that good coaches do not always make good mangers and it seems we have another one in Mason. I do not doubt he can prep a team to execute a game plan, and I do not doubt that players enjoy training under him as he’s worked with outstanding coaches, and must have something about him to earn their trust, but he simply does not have what it takes to step up and lead a team on match days. His time at Spurs was a complete mess of formation and tactical changes, and it seems we are going the same way here. After 20 games I still can’t tell you how we play, and I still can’t tell you our best XI. I’m not sure what Mason wants to accomplish here, and I’m seeing no signs of us working consistently towards a style of play, hell I’m not even seeing consistent patterns or elements of a game plan being built between games.

Frankly we have to end this managerial experiment as soon as possible because it’s just not working. We are not winning games, we are not improving as a 90 minute team, we are merely getting better in spells but still falling victim to the same mistakes and in game hesitancy, none of our players are showing any improvement, and indeed many are regressing (Phillips and Mepham should be one of the best CB pairings in this division!), and crucially our manager is not showing anything to suggest he can fix our frailties.

Ultimately we are in the bottom half with a team that’s budget should be comfortably top half, and we don’t look improving any time soon, and that means Mason has to go, and go now.


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Squid - 12-21-2025

I can see why people want him out and a few weeks ago, I would have been one of them. But, sitting in the Hawthorns, things feel a bit different. I just don't feel like we are a million miles away from clicking.

I also don't think that the ownership will make any change unless things start to seriously slide, because it feels like this is a watching and learning season for them, too. Unlike more cynical types, I actually do think they plan to spend a decent amount once PSR is lifted, but they'll try to make sure it's spent wisely.


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - tHEgLASSdOORS - 12-21-2025

We’ve looked like clicking through on and off all season to me but now we are nearly half way through and still not yielding results. How long do you wait before it becomes obvious he gets out thought during matches way too often.


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - SW4Baggie - 12-21-2025

(12-21-2025, 11:49 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: We’ve looked like clicking through on and off all season to me but now we are nearly half way through and still not yielding results. How long do you wait before it becomes obvious he gets out thought during matches way too often.

Exactly.

Football is decided with the finest of margins, and I don’t think Mason has that last 5% that will help us click.


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Man from delmonte - 12-21-2025

(12-21-2025, 11:46 AM)Squid Wrote: I can see why people want him out and a few weeks ago, I would have been one of them. But, sitting in the Hawthorns, things feel a bit different. I just don't feel like we are a million miles away from clicking.

I also don't think that the ownership will make any change unless things start to seriously slide, because it feels like this is a watching and learning season for them, too. Unlike more cynical types, I actually do think they plan to spend a decent amount once PSR is lifted, but they'll try to make sure it's spent wisely.

This is why I find us so incredibly infuriating at the moment. We've got some very good players for this level and at times look like the real deal. But you never know which Albion will turn up and when we are bad, we look really bad.

I just don't feel any confidence in Mason that he will turn things around. It's not all his fault, Nestor has to shoulder a fair portion of the blame in terms of the balance of the squad and what Mason has to work with. Despite that though, Mason's judgement on certain players (Dike being the main example) and his terrible in-game management is a huge red flag for me. He doesn't help himself at all.


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Seat109 - 12-21-2025

Don’t think Mason it going to improve us so needs to go, this run of defeats for a rookie manager is curtains as he has zero experience of this type of situation and this must feed to the squad , would a different manager has more success with this squad - probably but the ‘football department’ needs scrutiny from the owner , if there’s a plan to rectify the missing components of the squad in January fair enough ,if not Nestorian/Pearce need to be gone at the end of the season .
They rectified the centre forward issue and on the face of it improved the centre back department ( hindsight is convenient but did anyone say the signings were poor at the time ? No).
Don’t know how much input Mason has on incomings but the refusal to give Bany/ Dike is ridiculous and then not to give them U21 minutes is bordering on scandalous given that potentially in 2 weeks time the club could be wanting to move both on , we invested a substantial resource into Bany almost a year ago with zero return.
If we finish where we are and push on next season well fair enough but need to end this experiment and get someone in place to oversee the next steps


RE: An argument for keeping Mason? - Jerry - 12-21-2025

We got Mason because he is a young coach who’s had lots of coaching experience especially bringing through kids at Tottenham. At this moment he is being found out that he can’t put together a winning team and more importantly unlike CC does not seem to be improving players. My big negative of him is that he is not including the kids, ie our future, which should in all honesty be his strength up to the point of playing two goalies.