WBAUnofficial
Ratings v Oxford - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings v Oxford (/showthread.php?tid=39289)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Ratings v Oxford - BasingBaggie - 11-08-2025

Not having Mowatt as a 7, slows our whole play down and his running in treacle for their goal when he was covering for Styles was appalling


RE: Ratings v Oxford - Borin' Baggie - 11-08-2025

SIJ does not deserve more than a 5.

He selfishly shot well wide when he could have very easily squared the ball for a much better chance to kill the game. He stupidly ran the ball out which gave Oxford a long throw out of nothing instead of just clearing the bloody ball. He tamely gave the ball to the keeper at 96:45 instead of running the ball into the corner and they immediately created a chance.

I'm sick of him, send him back to Villa. Selfish twat. 3 times he could have cost us there when he was specifically brought on to see out the game.


RE: Ratings v Oxford - Jacko - 11-08-2025

Griffiths 7

Gilchrist 6
Phillips 6
Taylor 6
Styles 6

Mowatt 6
Diakite 6

Grant 6
Price 6
Johnston 7 MOTM

Maja 5

Molumby 6
Heggebø 7
SIJ 5
Collyer 6
Bielik 6

(11-08-2025, 09:11 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: SIJ does not deserve more than a 5.

He selfishly shot well wide when he could have very easily squared the ball for a much better chance to kill the game. He stupidly ran the ball out which gave Oxford a long throw out of nothing instead of just clearing the bloody ball. He tamely gave the ball to the keeper at 96:45 instead of running the ball into the corner and they immediately created a chance.

I'm sick of him, send him back to Villa. Selfish twat. 3 times he could have cost us there when he was specifically brought on to see out the game.

Don't necessarily disagree, but I don't believe he's ever played Right Wing regularly at any kind of level before this season (and apparently I'd know, hyuk hyuk hyuk - Pinky and The Brain).


RE: Ratings v Oxford - waffle - 11-08-2025

Spot on OP.  Would give Molumby an extra 0.5/1.0 just for adding a little passion/leadership that was severely lacking.


RE: Ratings v Oxford - Jacko - 11-08-2025

(11-08-2025, 09:08 PM)BasingBaggie Wrote: Not having Mowatt as a 7, slows our whole play down and his running in treacle for their goal when he was covering for Styles was appalling

I gave Mowwy a 6, he had an easy game against a poor side and kept us ticking over nicely, but there is no disgrace in him being out paced by a winger when covering out of position ffs.


RE: Ratings v Oxford - sickParrot - 11-08-2025

(11-08-2025, 09:47 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(11-08-2025, 09:11 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: SIJ does not deserve more than a 5.

He selfishly shot well wide when he could have very easily squared the ball for a much better chance to kill the game. He stupidly ran the ball out which gave Oxford a long throw out of nothing instead of just clearing the bloody ball. He tamely gave the ball to the keeper at 96:45 instead of running the ball into the corner and they immediately created a chance.

I'm sick of him, send him back to Villa. Selfish twat. 3 times he could have cost us there when he was specifically brought on to see out the game.

Don't necessarily disagree, but I don't believe he's ever played Right Wing regularly at any kind of level before this season (and apparently I'd know, hyuk hyuk hyuk - Pinky and The Brain).

That goal vs leesta seems like a long time ago


RE: Ratings v Oxford - chasetownbaggie - 11-09-2025

Re:OP. I think both Grant and Gilchrist maybe 6.5 but I disagree with last line. At Charlton we was worth a point. Derby at home, we was worthy of 3 points. We play well for most of the time in most games. Most sides that we play, come with a plan to make it hard for us to break them down. Mason is coming up shortly with working out to deal with that. Will he sort it? No idea, but I don't think we've been as bad as some make out - and there's definitely room for improvement.