RE: Nitpicking - Jacko - 11-03-2025
(11-03-2025, 08:51 AM)SussexBaggie Wrote: (11-02-2025, 03:29 PM)lemon Wrote: I know we've got bigger problems than this right now but there's something small that has been irritating me at home games for a while now.
They are playing the Liquidator too fast!
I first noticed it at the Southampton play off game and it's been happening ever since. I don't believe it's been mentioned on here by anyone but it would be useful to know I'm not going mad and that others have picked up on it too.
The faster playing speed seems to suck a little bit out of the pre match atmosphere and theres probably a reasoning behind it that can be traced back to the trouble at the FA cup game and the frowned upon audience participation in the song that comes up with the police and authorities every so often. Good spot & I thought the same too.
Digital blandness trying to imitate the original analogue magic, and failing- a bit like the whole deal at the moment. That’s why nothing feels right anymore.
The original was about 91/93 beats per minute, but more importantly the feel you hear in the mix is a bit behind the beat (rightly so, particularly in the prominent bass playing - that’s the whole point). In fact the time slips around a fair bit during the song; the days before the mindless click tracks of disco and 120 bpm.
Other versions available have been digitally cleaned up, so not that original 70s vibe we love. No vinyl hiss or feeling’..
Proof of this digital fuckwittery is that by speeding it up they changed the key it is played in. Original is in the key of B (at least the one I have always known and played) Digital versions are cleaned up, sped up and in the key of that nice, whitey, C major - no black keys in that thank you. (Eg the Uptown Ranking Chartbuster version). Put horns & guitars in B and you get a different feel and colour to putting them in C.
I think the club are playing the digitally cleaned white version. The piano is mixed right down (criminal) and drums stuck in the front line. No wonder it doesn’t sound right, and our PA helps that. Detail matters and you spotted it, which also matters.
What a brilliantly informative post this is by the way.
|