WBAUnofficial
Mason - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Mason (/showthread.php?tid=39225)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Mason - MrBater - 11-04-2025

I firmly believe that we need a manager, not a puppet picking the team. The manager should have a massive influence on which players come in, rather than the President ordering them off Shein and Temu from his laptop.

The last manager I can remember influencing signings was Slav (maybe Val with Mowatt and Dike? although those 2 never really had the same impact )... and look where we ended up.

I don't care if it's antiquated thinking, this moneyball is what all clubs are trying to do now, and only a few are making it work. There is far more to data with players, just glancing at their injury records for a start, but Pres doesn't seemingly let that influence how much he pays.

On that basis I have some sympathy with Mason, in that we basically have had no real fit attack minded players for most of the season, however he could try doing something different with them, rather than just hoping ti works by a fluke... the energy and interest are dying fast.


RE: Mason - Tom Joad 25 - 11-04-2025

(11-04-2025, 10:03 AM)MrBater Wrote: I firmly believe that we need a manager, not a puppet picking the team. The manager should have a massive influence on which players come in, rather than the President ordering them off Shein and Temu from his laptop.

The last manager I can remember influencing signings was Slav (maybe Val with Mowatt and Dike? although those 2 never really had the same impact )... and look where we ended up.

I don't care if it's antiquated thinking, this moneyball is what all clubs are trying to do now, and only a few are making it work. There is far more to data with players, just glancing at their injury records for a start, but Pres doesn't seemingly let that influence how much he pays.

On that basis I have some sympathy with Mason, in that we basically have had no real fit attack minded players for most of the season, however he could try doing something different with them, rather than just hoping ti works by a fluke... the energy and interest are dying fast.

Slav went into an all out bidding war with himself with no one else interested yet somehow we ended up paying hugely over the odds for KG. Val spent the January budget on Dike and was sacked straight after. Then Bruce signed his players from the nearest A and E. They are the perfect examples of why we shouldn't let a manager with an average term of 12-18 months dictate transfer policy.


RE: Mason - MrBater - 11-04-2025

(11-04-2025, 10:48 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 10:03 AM)MrBater Wrote: I firmly believe that we need a manager, not a puppet picking the team. The manager should have a massive influence on which players come in, rather than the President ordering them off Shein and Temu from his laptop.

The last manager I can remember influencing signings was Slav (maybe Val with Mowatt and Dike? although those 2 never really had the same impact )... and look where we ended up.

I don't care if it's antiquated thinking, this moneyball is what all clubs are trying to do now, and only a few are making it work. There is far more to data with players, just glancing at their injury records for a start, but Pres doesn't seemingly let that influence how much he pays.

On that basis I have some sympathy with Mason, in that we basically have had no real fit attack minded players for most of the season, however he could try doing something different with them, rather than just hoping ti works by a fluke... the energy and interest are dying fast.

Slav went into an all out bidding war with himself with no one else interested yet somehow we ended up paying hugely over the odds for KG. Val spent the January budget on Dike and was sacked straight after. Then Bruce signed his players from the nearest A and E. They are the perfect examples of why we shouldn't let a manager with an average term of 12-18 months dictate transfer policy.

Yeah, that Pereira was utter wank wasn't he...


RE: Mason - Tom Joad 25 - 11-04-2025

(11-04-2025, 10:53 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 10:48 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 10:03 AM)MrBater Wrote: I firmly believe that we need a manager, not a puppet picking the team. The manager should have a massive influence on which players come in, rather than the President ordering them off Shein and Temu from his laptop.

The last manager I can remember influencing signings was Slav (maybe Val with Mowatt and Dike? although those 2 never really had the same impact )... and look where we ended up.

I don't care if it's antiquated thinking, this moneyball is what all clubs are trying to do now, and only a few are making it work. There is far more to data with players, just glancing at their injury records for a start, but Pres doesn't seemingly let that influence how much he pays.

On that basis I have some sympathy with Mason, in that we basically have had no real fit attack minded players for most of the season, however he could try doing something different with them, rather than just hoping ti works by a fluke... the energy and interest are dying fast.

Slav went into an all out bidding war with himself with no one else interested yet somehow we ended up paying hugely over the odds for KG. Val spent the January budget on Dike and was sacked straight after. Then Bruce signed his players from the nearest A and E. They are the perfect examples of why we shouldn't let a manager with an average term of 12-18 months dictate transfer policy.

Yeah, that Pereira was utter wank wasn't he...

Bought and sold for about the same as KG cost. Personally I expect both DoF and manager to combine to choose targets. Any manager going all out for one player often ends badly, likewise a DoF providing the wrong tools for what is required.  The Thomas Frank you mention upthread had his best years to date at Brentford where the managers come and go but the system remains. Having appointed Mason, just 13 games in now, our hierarchy now need to see if he is actually the problem,  or is the issue with Nestor, who appointed him and supplies the players?


RE: Mason - SW4Baggie - 11-04-2025

(11-04-2025, 11:11 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 10:53 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 10:48 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 10:03 AM)MrBater Wrote: I firmly believe that we need a manager, not a puppet picking the team. The manager should have a massive influence on which players come in, rather than the President ordering them off Shein and Temu from his laptop.

The last manager I can remember influencing signings was Slav (maybe Val with Mowatt and Dike? although those 2 never really had the same impact )... and look where we ended up.

I don't care if it's antiquated thinking, this moneyball is what all clubs are trying to do now, and only a few are making it work. There is far more to data with players, just glancing at their injury records for a start, but Pres doesn't seemingly let that influence how much he pays.

On that basis I have some sympathy with Mason, in that we basically have had no real fit attack minded players for most of the season, however he could try doing something different with them, rather than just hoping ti works by a fluke... the energy and interest are dying fast.

Slav went into an all out bidding war with himself with no one else interested yet somehow we ended up paying hugely over the odds for KG. Val spent the January budget on Dike and was sacked straight after. Then Bruce signed his players from the nearest A and E. They are the perfect examples of why we shouldn't let a manager with an average term of 12-18 months dictate transfer policy.

Yeah, that Pereira was utter wank wasn't he...

Bought and sold for about the same as KG cost. Personally I expect both DoF and manager to combine to choose targets. Any manager going all out for one player often ends badly, likewise a DoF providing the wrong tools for what is required.  The Thomas Frank you mention upthread had his best years to date at Brentford where the managers come and go but the system remains. Having appointed Mason, just 13 games in now, our hierarchy now need to see if he is actually the problem,  or is the issue with Nestor, who appointed him and supplies the players?

Exactly a DoF and a manager should work in tandem, it is absolutely fine for managers to provide targets and to have preferences but the role of a DoF is to assemble a squad that plays a particular style of football and to appoint managers that will fit with that. 

The issue we currently have is that our DoF does not currently seem to be able to recruit players for a coherent system and Mason does not appear to have a preferred way of playing - "winning football" is a nice soundbite but it's not easy to coach!


RE: Mason - Johnnykayeengland - 11-04-2025

(11-04-2025, 11:11 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 10:53 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 10:48 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 10:03 AM)MrBater Wrote: I firmly believe that we need a manager, not a puppet picking the team. The manager should have a massive influence on which players come in, rather than the President ordering them off Shein and Temu from his laptop.

The last manager I can remember influencing signings was Slav (maybe Val with Mowatt and Dike? although those 2 never really had the same impact )... and look where we ended up.

I don't care if it's antiquated thinking, this moneyball is what all clubs are trying to do now, and only a few are making it work. There is far more to data with players, just glancing at their injury records for a start, but Pres doesn't seemingly let that influence how much he pays.

On that basis I have some sympathy with Mason, in that we basically have had no real fit attack minded players for most of the season, however he could try doing something different with them, rather than just hoping ti works by a fluke... the energy and interest are dying fast.

Slav went into an all out bidding war with himself with no one else interested yet somehow we ended up paying hugely over the odds for KG. Val spent the January budget on Dike and was sacked straight after. Then Bruce signed his players from the nearest A and E. They are the perfect examples of why we shouldn't let a manager with an average term of 12-18 months dictate transfer policy.

Yeah, that Pereira was utter wank wasn't he...

Bought and sold for about the same as KG cost. Personally I expect both DoF and manager to combine to choose targets. Any manager going all out for one player often ends badly, likewise a DoF providing the wrong tools for what is required.  The Thomas Frank you mention upthread had his best years to date at Brentford where the managers come and go but the system remains. Having appointed Mason, just 13 games in now, our hierarchy now need to see if he is actually the problem,  or is the issue with Nestor, who appointed him and supplies the players?
13 games. That's the main point surely?
I don't disagree with any of the above criticism. But he's barely started. We have to be patient. Three games ago he was doing well - according to most of us.


RE: Mason - Jacko - 11-04-2025

He needs a win and a good performance and he needs it tonight or Saturday, once you lose the match-going fans there's no coming back, however new to the role or unfair it seems.


RE: Mason - MrBater - 11-04-2025

(11-04-2025, 11:36 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 11:11 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 10:53 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 10:48 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(11-04-2025, 10:03 AM)MrBater Wrote: I firmly believe that we need a manager, not a puppet picking the team. The manager should have a massive influence on which players come in, rather than the President ordering them off Shein and Temu from his laptop.

The last manager I can remember influencing signings was Slav (maybe Val with Mowatt and Dike? although those 2 never really had the same impact )... and look where we ended up.

I don't care if it's antiquated thinking, this moneyball is what all clubs are trying to do now, and only a few are making it work. There is far more to data with players, just glancing at their injury records for a start, but Pres doesn't seemingly let that influence how much he pays.

On that basis I have some sympathy with Mason, in that we basically have had no real fit attack minded players for most of the season, however he could try doing something different with them, rather than just hoping ti works by a fluke... the energy and interest are dying fast.

Slav went into an all out bidding war with himself with no one else interested yet somehow we ended up paying hugely over the odds for KG. Val spent the January budget on Dike and was sacked straight after. Then Bruce signed his players from the nearest A and E. They are the perfect examples of why we shouldn't let a manager with an average term of 12-18 months dictate transfer policy.

Yeah, that Pereira was utter wank wasn't he...

Bought and sold for about the same as KG cost. Personally I expect both DoF and manager to combine to choose targets. Any manager going all out for one player often ends badly, likewise a DoF providing the wrong tools for what is required.  The Thomas Frank you mention upthread had his best years to date at Brentford where the managers come and go but the system remains. Having appointed Mason, just 13 games in now, our hierarchy now need to see if he is actually the problem,  or is the issue with Nestor, who appointed him and supplies the players?
13 games. That's the main point surely?
I don't disagree with any of the above criticism. But he's barely started. We have to be patient. Three games ago he was doing well - according to most of us.

3 games ago there were cracks appearing, 3 games later those cracks look like subsidence.

I think it's the lack of, well anything, that's coming from him that's the bigger worry. We've seen it before and so maybe that's why the concerns are being aired sooner this time around?

I agree the DoF and manager should be working together, that was my point, we seem to have Pres doing what he wants based on data that allows crocked buys, and Mason who it seems doesn't have much of a clue. A perfect storm of shit really. At least in the old days we knew it was the manager's fault, now there's multiple layers of obfuscation which hide who is really at fault. So, the manager still gets it, even though he might have been hamstrung by the DoF or whoever...


RE: Mason - BaggieSloth - 11-04-2025

Whilst this year is the start of a project, i accept it has not been pretty and does seem to be getting worse.
That being said, i do hope that he manages to turn it around because the start of the season was very promising.
Every team goes through a blip, im optimistically hoping this is ours this season.

He needs to change something, but is he brave enough to do it. Time will tell but i fear it does need to be over the next couple of games.
Also, if we win the next two - whilst putting in a decent display im sure the fans heads will be back on team Mason.

Football turns us into Fickle creatures.


RE: Mason - MrBater - 11-04-2025

(11-04-2025, 12:02 PM)BaggieSloth Wrote: Whilst this year is the start of a project, i accept it has not been pretty and does seem to be getting worse.
That being said, i do hope that he manages to turn it around because the start of the season was very promising.
Every team goes through a blip, im optimistically hoping this is ours this season.

He needs to change something, but is he brave enough to do it. Time will tell but i fear it does need to be over the next couple of games.
Also, if we win the next two - whilst putting in a decent display im sure the fans heads will be back on team Mason.

Football turns us into Fickle creatures.

it does.

I just can't see a good performance coming, I'm not that sure we've actually had a really good one yet, even with our good start.

The Opposition View threads have all pretty much said the same thing, we don't look that good at all.

I think most can accept that the squad is weaker, but I think what's doing it for him is the lack of trying anything different, so I don't think he's brave enough.

I think the bigger issue is that if the next 3 games go awry or Wednesday like, that we could well be double digits off 6th place, and going into Winter that would be a pretty bad position... Sure if we win all 3 we could be back in the mix, and the way this division is I wouldn't bet against either scenario!

Reading the match threads, the biggest concern is that he seems to have no plan / idea... and that is a concern, they don't just happen, but after 13 games there should already be a semblance of something.