WBAUnofficial
Going Direct - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Going Direct (/showthread.php?tid=39166)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Going Direct - Pontificator - 10-29-2025

(10-29-2025, 09:40 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(10-29-2025, 09:15 AM)Pontificator Wrote: You can't argue with the fact that he was our most succesful manager in over 45 years. Yes we played some dire football but he nearly got us into Europe. The football he played wasn't the best to watch but look at us now. Maybe if the board had backed him, bigged him up etc he wouldn't have behaved like he did towards the end. I believe he engineered his own demise and for that I haven't any time for him. I'll never forget that Chelsea game in '17.

I can argue with it because he factually wasn’t.

Pulls got us to 10th
Roy got us to 10th
Clarke got us to 8th
Old Umble got us a championship.

Both in terms of PPG and win ratio, Hodgson was our most successful premier league manager.

I can’t think of an objective measure that places Pulis 1st.

After 14 games in 2016/17 we were sixth in the premier league, is that not objective? We finished 10 but it was an excellent season and but for a little more quality whonose. For quite some time we were 8th nearly 20 games


RE: Going Direct - HawkingsHalfpint - 10-29-2025

(10-29-2025, 09:15 AM)Pontificator Wrote: You can't argue with the fact that he was our most succesful manager in over 45 years. Yes we played some dire football but he nearly got us into Europe. The football he played wasn't the best to watch but look at us now. Maybe if the board had backed him, bigged him up etc he wouldn't have behaved like he did towards the end. I believe he engineered his own demise and for that I haven't any time for him. I'll never forget that Chelsea game in '17.

Someone else has argued it for me. Yes, it was stable while it lasted, but it’s this bit that’s the abiding memory for me; which allowed a rot to set in from which we still haven’t yet recovered. 

Seasons last longer than 14 games. I’m sure someone had us higher than sixth at one point. Pulis perhaps could have eclipsed the finishes of Hodgson and Clark, but we’ll never know given his fondness for downing tools in February/March.

Of course he can’t be blamed for the failings of Pardew, sacking Big Dave, Fat Sam, appointing that moron Val on a 4-year deal, Bruce and Mowbray afterwards etc. But that Pulis era truly was the beginning of the end. Whilst Pardew will never, ever have been the right successor for anyone (let alone us), what Pulis left behind was a team who had completely forgotten how to play football at the expense of his ailing ideals. I don’t think Big Dave quite gets enough credit for doing his bit to change that (even if he did lose his way in listening too much to others). 

All water under the bridge now, but the pendulum will one day swing again back in favour of teams that can defend set-pieces and play a bit as well. Nothing stays in vogue forever and I’m hardly surprised to see him milking this while it is.


RE: Going Direct - Pontificator - 10-29-2025

(10-29-2025, 10:23 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(10-29-2025, 09:15 AM)Pontificator Wrote: You can't argue with the fact that he was our most succesful manager in over 45 years. Yes we played some dire football but he nearly got us into Europe. The football he played wasn't the best to watch but look at us now. Maybe if the board had backed him, bigged him up etc he wouldn't have behaved like he did towards the end. I believe he engineered his own demise and for that I haven't any time for him. I'll never forget that Chelsea game in '17.

Someone else has argued it for me. Yes, it was stable while it lasted, but it’s this bit that’s the abiding memory for me; which allowed a rot to set in from which we still haven’t yet recovered. 

Seasons last longer than 14 games. I’m sure someone had us higher than sixth at one point. Pulis perhaps could have eclipsed the finishes of Hodgson and Clark, but we’ll never know given his fondness for downing tools in February/March.

Of course he can’t be blamed for the failings of Pardew, sacking Big Dave, Fat Sam, appointing that moron Val on a 4-year deal, Bruce and Mowbray afterwards etc. But that Pulis era truly was the beginning of the end. Whilst Pardew will never, ever have been the right successor for anyone (let alone us), what Pulis left behind was a team who had completely forgotten how to play football at the expense of his ailing ideals. I don’t think Big Dave quite gets enough credit for doing his bit to change that (even if he did lose his way in listening too much to others). 

All water under the bridge now, but the pendulum will one day swing again back in favour of teams that can defend set-pieces and play a bit as well. Nothing stays in vogue forever and I’m hardly surprised to see him milking this while it is.

Indeed it is water under the bridge but you cant argue with the facts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016%E2%80%9317_West_Bromwich_Albion_F.C._season


RE: Going Direct - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 10-29-2025

Recall that season when we beat Arsenal, put us on 43 points or whatever, with 10 games left, Pulis then, as has been said, didn`t care. We went up, ( rare for me due to work ) against a struggling side, no win in 6 or something, may have been Everton, can`t remember. We made no attempt to win, 8 / 9 behind the ball constantly, as we came out, I said to our Al , `thats it, I`m not paying to watch this, not coming again while Pulis is here`.
Then, of course, they double crossed me by having Pardew !


RE: Going Direct - CIM - 10-29-2025

(10-29-2025, 08:40 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(10-29-2025, 08:38 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: 'My job, whoever I was manager of, was to get results. Yes, I was pragmatic, but I was also purposeful. I worked on my basic beliefs of being effective in a way that would help my club win games'.

So what the fuck was that 0-0 at home to one of the worst (if not then THE) Villa sides I've ever seen in the Premier League all about then?

Abso bloody lutely.

And who can forget the week from hell. 2 defeats at Vile Park.


RE: Going Direct - HawkingsHalfpint - 10-29-2025

(10-29-2025, 10:32 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-29-2025, 10:23 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(10-29-2025, 09:15 AM)Pontificator Wrote: You can't argue with the fact that he was our most succesful manager in over 45 years. Yes we played some dire football but he nearly got us into Europe. The football he played wasn't the best to watch but look at us now. Maybe if the board had backed him, bigged him up etc he wouldn't have behaved like he did towards the end. I believe he engineered his own demise and for that I haven't any time for him. I'll never forget that Chelsea game in '17.

Someone else has argued it for me. Yes, it was stable while it lasted, but it’s this bit that’s the abiding memory for me; which allowed a rot to set in from which we still haven’t yet recovered. 

Seasons last longer than 14 games. I’m sure someone had us higher than sixth at one point. Pulis perhaps could have eclipsed the finishes of Hodgson and Clark, but we’ll never know given his fondness for downing tools in February/March.

Of course he can’t be blamed for the failings of Pardew, sacking Big Dave, Fat Sam, appointing that moron Val on a 4-year deal, Bruce and Mowbray afterwards etc. But that Pulis era truly was the beginning of the end. Whilst Pardew will never, ever have been the right successor for anyone (let alone us), what Pulis left behind was a team who had completely forgotten how to play football at the expense of his ailing ideals. I don’t think Big Dave quite gets enough credit for doing his bit to change that (even if he did lose his way in listening too much to others). 

All water under the bridge now, but the pendulum will one day swing again back in favour of teams that can defend set-pieces and play a bit as well. Nothing stays in vogue forever and I’m hardly surprised to see him milking this while it is.

Indeed it is water under the bridge but you cant argue with the facts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016%E2%80%9317_West_Bromwich_Albion_F.C._season

Indeed you can’t. 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012–13_West_Bromwich_Albion_F.C._season

3rd in beginning, 4th after the same period you claim.


RE: Going Direct - Old Fart - 10-29-2025

(10-29-2025, 08:38 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: 'My job, whoever I was manager of, was to get results. Yes, I was pragmatic, but I was also purposeful. I worked on my basic beliefs of being effective in a way that would help my club win games'.

So what the fuck was that 0-0 at home to one of the worst (if not then THE) Villa sides I've ever seen in the Premier League all about then?

That game was dreadful.  At last I thought, we can humiliate the fishy fuckers.  We hardly got out of our own half and Villa were denied a clear penalty.  I was relieved when we got the draw in the end.


RE: Going Direct - Ted Maul - 10-29-2025

I didn't mind Pulis, he was exactly what we needed when he arrived and he laid the foundations for what should have been a long-term stint in the PL.

With better ownership we could have seized on the platform Pulis gave us and we could have gone on to something similar to Crystal Palace or Brentford. Wasn't Pulis' fault the owners at the time couldn't see this and had no ideas what they were doing.

Certainly a better manager than the likes of Bilic or Mowbray down here for me.


RE: Going Direct - HawkingsHalfpint - 10-29-2025

(10-29-2025, 11:25 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I didn't mind Pulis, he was exactly what we needed when he arrived and he laid the foundations for what should have been a long-term stint in the PL.

With better ownership we could have seized on the platform Pulis gave us and we could have gone on to something similar to Crystal Palace or Brentford. Wasn't Pulis' fault the owners at the time couldn't see this and had no ideas what they were doing.

Certainly a better manager than the likes of Bilic or Mowbray down here for me.

I think that’s a very rose-tinted view of it. 

I have no doubts about Pulis’ ability to manage us. Or many other Premier League clubs for that matter, and he is indeed far more capable than any you mention. But when he lost his court case against Palace, and was faced with an enormous legal bill not to mention repayment of his seven-figure severance, the only way he saw fit to balance his books was by getting himself fired by us. So I think laying the foundations for him (given than he’d already pretty-much reassumed control over transfer activity by then) is completely a moot point.


RE: Going Direct - Ted Maul - 10-29-2025

(10-29-2025, 11:28 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(10-29-2025, 11:25 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I didn't mind Pulis, he was exactly what we needed when he arrived and he laid the foundations for what should have been a long-term stint in the PL.

With better ownership we could have seized on the platform Pulis gave us and we could have gone on to something similar to Crystal Palace or Brentford. Wasn't Pulis' fault the owners at the time couldn't see this and had no ideas what they were doing.

Certainly a better manager than the likes of Bilic or Mowbray down here for me.

I think that’s a very rose-tinted view of it. 

I have no doubts about Pulis’ ability to manage us. Or many other Premier League clubs for that matter, and he is indeed far more capable than any you mention. But when he lost his court case against Palace, and was faced with an enormous legal bill not to mention repayment of his seven-figure severance, the only way he saw fit to balance his books was by getting himself fired by us. So I think laying the foundations for him (given than he’d already pretty-much reassumed control over transfer activity by then) is completely a moot point.

He may well have done but proper ownership would have prevented the dismantling of the scouting network, stepping in at the point where the Pulis job had been done. We left him in-situ about 18 months too long. No one is resigning from a number that cushy when they know it will be easy enough to get sacked. 

He got us doing the basics very well, we were fit, organised, miserable to play against (and watch at times in fairness), but I can't remember many games where we beat ourselves. He did all that at the highest level of football as well, so I'll always maintain he did a good job for us and was allowed to sour by the actions of an owner who stopped giving a shit and couldn't wait to get out the door followed by an owner who was a total crook.