WBAUnofficial
England v SA - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: England v SA (/showthread.php?tid=38583)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: England v SA - AnelkasBeard - 09-03-2025

(09-02-2025, 10:24 PM)Cuzer Wrote: The result has absolutely fuck all to do with The Hundred

What is this blind obsession with the tournament you pair of clowns go on about?

Lunatics

Bottom line is we’ve been crap at OFI cricket for ages, we’re 8th in the world for a reason….

The reason isn’t the Hundred or that IPL nonsense for the record

Cuzer

And why is that the bottom line Cuzer?

Because after 2019, no focus or drive was given to the ODI team. It was T20, TheHundred, and getting Bazball set up. So by way of neglect, we're now shit. So yes, The Hundred has of course had an impact. It also means players haven't been playing the ODI format (because of The Hundred, because centrally contracted players HAVE to play it), so are totally out of practice in the ODI format.

You're also allowed to disagree without turning yourself purple.


RE: England v SA - Cheshire East Baggie - 09-03-2025

It's easy to blame The Hundred for English cricket's woes, but that's a symptom not a cause. Now the franchises have been sold off and the ECB has netted a profit, we'll see the real problems kick in with player availability and priorities.

Yesterday's debacle was more to do with the Bazball vibe. Sonny Baker isn't ready for international cricket. With Mahmood in the squad, Tongue in sparking form and Potts doing well (but apparently discarded) there was no need for Baker to play. It's just as stupid as keep on picking Bashir for the Test side instead of Leach.

Vaughan kept on about "This is England's top 7 batters" - the trouble is they all know it and there is no threat to their places in the side. Selection is on McCullum's whim and is not related to form, attitude or performance. Trouble is, they don't look like a world- beating line-up, despite the obvious talent on display.

Final point - the Test side performs (mostly) because of the charisma and mentality of Ben Stokes. I guess the players, even the old stagers, are in awe of him as a cricketer and a human being. He gave the GOATS Broad and Anderson a good talking to about bowling to take wickets instead of to preserve their figures. He ruthlessly discarded media darling Bairstow when the time was right. My question is, do the ODI players have the same respect for, even fear of Harry Brook? I kind of doubt it, and that reflects poorly on the players more than it does the captain.


RE: England v SA - Loanee - 09-04-2025

Maybe we should play the players who have played 50 over cricket in county cricket over the last 2 months.


RE: England v SA - Cheshire East Baggie - 09-04-2025

Maybe if Sam Curran was in the side, or even captain of the side, our ODI team would do better. Or is his recent sparkling form irrelevant in the all-knowing view of Brendan McCullum?

I know we shouldn't criticise Baz, because he delivers "winning cricket", but at the moment he's delivering rubbish.


RE: England v SA - Jacko - 09-04-2025

Not sure how anyone can moan after that match? Really good ODI, very competitive, high-scoring, high quality cricket which South Africa narrowly won. Great evening aside from the result.


RE: England v SA - pindgill - 09-05-2025

SA woeful death bowling brought some respectability to Englands defeat!!..
England really need to win some ODIs to remain in the world top 8 in ODI rankings currently 7th otherwise they will need to qualify for next WC!!..
Our 50 over competition has been totally devalued by the the 100.


RE: England v SA - ChamonixBaggie - 09-05-2025

(09-04-2025, 07:52 PM)Loanee Wrote: Maybe we should play the players who have played 50 over cricket in county cricket over the last 2 months.

That would require England cricket to be even vaguely a meritocracy


RE: England v SA - Josh1873 - 09-05-2025

When the ECB bastardise the County One Day cup so they can push a format no one asked for, wants, or likes, then it should come as no surprise when the international side struggle in the format.

The ECB is destroying County Cricket, and it's so sad to see it play out and die with a whimper.


RE: England v SA - Cheshire East Baggie - 09-05-2025

(09-04-2025, 09:37 PM)Jacko Wrote: Not sure how anyone can moan after that match? Really good ODI, very competitive,  high-scoring, high quality cricket which South Africa narrowly won. Great evening aside from the result.

True, but if we want to win, we need to give ourselves the best chance. The two part time bowlers went for over 100 runs in their 10 overs. If one of them was replaced by a better bowling all rounder, we'd probably have won.

I've not always been a fan of Sam Curran, but he's on fire at the moment and his left arm seam is a good variation to have. McCullum's off-beat selections for white ball and Test teams aren't working out IMO.


RE: England v SA - Bob Fossil - 09-07-2025

Looks like they’ve recovered from the 100.