WBAUnofficial
Does player power work - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Does player power work (/showthread.php?tid=38297)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Does player power work - Josh1873 - 08-12-2025

I think there's ways of going about leaving, and throwing your toys out of the pram and acting like a knob isn't one of them.

However, in what other industry are people prevented from leaving their current role to move to another employer?

Also, what are Newcastle gaining by holding on to him? You may as well just accept the player wants to leave and the relationship has broken down, and open negotiations with Liverpool to get the best price for the player. That doesn't sit right with some, as it's undermining the club and letting the player 'win', but at some point you have to accept the situation and do what's best for the club.

The alternative is to reject all bids, carry on paying his wage, and bomb him out of the club until his contract runs down, or try and mend the broken bridge, and potentially try and integrate a player back into the squad that clearly doesn't want to be there. Neither of those two are ideal.


RE: Does player power work - fuzzbox - 08-12-2025

(08-12-2025, 04:30 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I think there's ways of going about leaving, and throwing your toys out of the pram and acting like a knob isn't one of them.

However, in what other industry are people prevented from leaving their current role to move to another employer?

Also, what are Newcastle gaining by holding on to him? You may as well just accept the player wants to leave and the relationship has broken down, and open negotiations with Liverpool to get the best price for the player. That doesn't sit right with some, as it's undermining the club and letting the player 'win', but at some point you have to accept the situation and do what's best for the club.

The alternative is to reject all bids, carry on paying his wage, and bomb him out of the club until his contract runs down, or try and mend the broken bridge, and potentially try and integrate a player back into the squad that clearly doesn't want to be there. Neither of those two are ideal.

They're not in football. They can always sign a short term contract. They don't because it's not in their interest. No signing on  fee to begin with, and crucially, no enhanced payment because the club value them as an asset they could sell, rather than just a  payroll expense with no recoverable value (which is why players towards the end of their careers don't get paid as much - or shouldn't!). On top of that, imagine the position Dike would be in if the club could just get rid of him after his second injury. If he was worth nothing as an asset, you may as well just let him go. Or even Cole and Friabotta (?) we would have stopped paying them months ago!