WBAUnofficial
NI Fund Surplus - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: NI Fund Surplus (/showthread.php?tid=38175)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: NI Fund Surplus - Derek Hardballs - 08-07-2025

(08-07-2025, 05:54 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You’ll get your chance to find out pretty soon I reckon, and it wouldn’t need the ‘British public’ to swallow tax rises, it would have taken a small % of the electorate to have changed their vote or not voted at all, based on the fear of tax rises, to have changed the result dramatically.

They would have won the election despite themselves anyway, such was the absolute mess that the Tories were/are and in turn the country. The real grown up thing to have done, would have been honest with the public that it was likely they would need to pay more in tax. The problem has been they are happy to take on those who cannot fight back or are just too busy making ends meet than make decisions that upset those with the ‘broadest shoulders’.


RE: NI Fund Surplus - baggy1 - 08-07-2025

Fucks sake Dekka, I would love to live in your world. Labour hold a 146 seat majority else it would be a hung parliament, or likely a minority government. About 220 (all parties) were won with less than 10% and of that about 115 of them with less than 5% (of that 5% about half of those were won by Labour). If you can't get your head around what an announcement that taxes would rise and the ensuing press feeding frenzy would have done to the electorate then you are seeing what you want.

The average Labour margin was less than 20% - therefore half of those 400 odd won seats were less than that.


RE: NI Fund Surplus - man in the corner shop - 08-07-2025

(08-07-2025, 07:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-07-2025, 05:54 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You’ll get your chance to find out pretty soon I reckon, and it wouldn’t need the ‘British public’ to swallow tax rises, it would have taken a small % of the electorate to have changed their vote or not voted at all, based on the fear of tax rises, to have changed the result dramatically.

They would have won the election despite themselves anyway, such was the absolute mess that the Tories were/are and in turn the country. The real grown up thing to have done, would have been honest with the public that it was likely they would need to pay more in tax. The problem has been they are happy to take on those who cannot fight back or are just too busy making ends meet than make decisions that upset those with the ‘broadest shoulders’.

It's a most bizarre position of the centrist dads own making. "We will completely box ourselves in so that we are in a position of not being able to do anything that will change peoples lives". It's just getting into  power for the sake of being in power.

Keef was embarrassing on telly yesterday - all he could muster up was that mortgages were going down and he had raised the minimum wage.

Whilst they fail to lead, u turn on everything, miss housing targets (which if achieved will make peoples lives better), and promise growth by finger-crossing.

I see little difference between this lot and the last lot.

More importantly, the British public are of the same view and turning to Reform.

Well done Labour and well done centrist dads


RE: NI Fund Surplus - CarlosCorbewrong - 08-07-2025

(08-07-2025, 08:24 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(08-07-2025, 07:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-07-2025, 05:54 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You’ll get your chance to find out pretty soon I reckon, and it wouldn’t need the ‘British public’ to swallow tax rises, it would have taken a small % of the electorate to have changed their vote or not voted at all, based on the fear of tax rises, to have changed the result dramatically.

They would have won the election despite themselves anyway, such was the absolute mess that the Tories were/are and in turn the country. The real grown up thing to have done, would have been honest with the public that it was likely they would need to pay more in tax. The problem has been they are happy to take on those who cannot fight back or are just too busy making ends meet than make decisions that upset those with the ‘broadest shoulders’.

It's a most bizarre position of the centrist dads own making. "We will completely box ourselves in so that we are in a position of not being able to do anything that will change peoples lives". It's just getting into  power for the sake of being in power.

Keef was embarrassing on telly yesterday - all he could muster up was that mortgages were going down and he had raised the minimum wage.

Whilst they fail to lead, u turn on everything, miss housing targets (which if achieved will make peoples lives better), and promise growth by finger-crossing.

I see little difference between this lot and the last lot.

More importantly, the British public are of the same view and turning to Reform.

Well done Labour and well done centrist dads

Is fooking right.

We've got a massive majority and 5 years to fix things.  Let's hamstring ourselves and do nothing.  Wankers.


RE: NI Fund Surplus - baggy1 - 08-07-2025

Interested in your views then on the points around taxation - Do you think that Labour promising Tax rises in their manifesto would have made:
a) no difference to the turn out and vote share
b) improved the vote share because the public would have seen it as a good thing
c) decreased the vote share and / or turn out


RE: NI Fund Surplus - CarlosCorbewrong - 08-07-2025

(08-07-2025, 10:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Interested in your views then on the points around taxation - Do you think that Labour promising Tax rises in their manifesto would have made:
a) no difference to the turn out and vote share
b) improved the vote share because the public would have seen it as a good thing
c) decreased the vote share and / or turn out

Nobody knows and it doesn't matter.  Nobody gives two shits about what was in a manifesto 5 years on and given that Reeves is about to raise taxes, after just over a year in office, it clearly doesn't matter to the government either.  They had a sufficient majority to be transformational and they've neglected that opportunity.  Nobody gives a fuck about your hand wringing about how difficult it is, they just give a fuck about how they feel.

This lot haven't even tried.

It's been a pathetic show from the 'grown ups' and even the most blind can see it and those who are supporting them are allowing a lurch further to the right than even the biggest shitcunt of Tory governments would have dared to get away with.  What comes next is as equally on Starmer and his supporters as it is the Tories and Farage.  Some of us still care enough to get angry about it, despite being well protected from the ideologies of Farage et al.


RE: NI Fund Surplus - Derek Hardballs - 08-07-2025

(08-07-2025, 11:15 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(08-07-2025, 10:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Interested in your views then on the points around taxation - Do you think that Labour promising Tax rises in their manifesto would have made:
a) no difference to the turn out and vote share
b) improved the vote share because the public would have seen it as a good thing
c) decreased the vote share and / or turn out

Nobody knows and it doesn't matter.  Nobody gives two shits about what was in a manifesto 5 years on and given that Reeves is about to raise taxes, after just over a year in office, it clearly doesn't matter to the government either.  They had a sufficient majority to be transformational and they've neglected that opportunity.  Nobody gives a fuck about your hand wringing about how difficult it is, they just give a fuck about how they feel.

This lot haven't even tried.

It's been a pathetic show from the 'grown ups' and even the most blind can see it and those who are supporting them are allowing a lurch further to the right than even the biggest shitcunt of Tory governments would have dared to get away with.  What comes next is as equally on Starmer and his supporters as it is the Tories and Farage.  Some of us still care enough to get angry about it, despite being well protected from the ideologies of Farage et al.

Exactly, offering practically nothing but a continuation of Sunak’s incredibly unpopular policies with an extra dollop of condescension.

The most depressing thing is, those that Starmer surrounds himself with still don’t understand they’ve already dropped the Ming vase and they have no fugging idea how to put it back together.


RE: NI Fund Surplus - man in the corner shop - 08-07-2025

(08-07-2025, 10:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Interested in your views then on the points around taxation - Do you think that Labour promising Tax rises in their manifesto would have made:
a) no difference to the turn out and vote share
b) improved the vote share because the public would have seen it as a good thing
c) decreased the vote share and / or turn out

I'm getting on but recall many parties going into a GE saying " we can't give a definitive view on tax rises until we see the state of the books". It's a bit shite, yes, but at least it leaves the door open and would've got Labour over the line imo.

Reeves needlessly invented her own constraints as if she was running an S and M dungeon.


RE: NI Fund Surplus - baggy1 - 08-07-2025

I think they were very clear on the fact they would't be raising taxes on working people during the election.


RE: NI Fund Surplus - man in the corner shop - 08-07-2025

"They had a sufficient majority to be transformational and they've neglected that opportunity."

This in spades.

What the UK needs is transformation along the lines seen of the 45-51 Labour government. Labour's majority is so big it can do whatever it wants. It clearly wants to do 9 10ths of fuck all. With cabinet sitting tight until after the next GE when they can all individually earn millions on Boards or in consulting. Thus rolling out the red carpet for Farage.