WBAUnofficial
State pension age - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: State pension age (/showthread.php?tid=38115)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: State pension age - Protheroe - 07-21-2025

It's remarkable that Labour needs a commission to discover why future generations of pensioners will be less well off:

"Gordon Brown’s infamous raid on the UK’s pension funds seemed innocuous. He raised £5bn a year by abolishing the dividend tax credit that pension funds enjoyed at the time, slipping the measure through in his first Budget in 1997 with barely a murmur of dissent. But it was not just that pensioners lost the benefit of a 20p in the pound top up to their dividend income. The cumulative loss of the growth in funds that would have accrued from the reinvestment of those credits may have cost pensioners £250bn over the following 20 years. Worse still, the reduced incentive for UK pension funds to invest in British companies means that they and other institutional investors now own just 4% of UK-quoted shares compared with half of them in 1997."

and

"The 2009 decision by then Chancellor Alistair Darling to reduce the personal income tax allowance by £1 for every £2 of extra income earned over £100,000. Effectively this creates a 60% tax band for earnings between this threshold and £125,140 at which point the personal allowance has been tapered away entirely. The unfairness of this was pointed out to me recently by my son-in-law. He said that, while he was aware that he could circumvent the problem by diverting his bonus into his pension, this is actually not an option. He is in his early thirties and trying to drag himself and my daughter one rung further up the housing ladder. He needs the cash now not when he retires, even if he only gets to keep 40% of it. Generational unfairness that I’m quite sure Alistair Darling didn’t intend 15 years ago."


RE: State pension age - Borin' Baggie - 07-21-2025

The former statement makes no sense as the people who were middle aged in 1997 are eligible for the state pension now so would be included in the "better off" comparison instead of future comparator and the latter makes no sense as the vast majority of workers don't earn £100k - the 90th percentile for full time workers is less than £75k - and those that are would be incentivised to contribute to their pension pots by the marginal rate fuckery.

This is a housing and infrastructure problem that is strangling productivity growth and eating into incomes making it unaffordable to contribute to pensions, two things that can be levelled at the complete disaster of long-term infrastructure planning between 1979 and 2007.


RE: State pension age - tHEgLASSdOORS - 07-21-2025

(07-21-2025, 05:39 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote:
(07-21-2025, 04:51 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: It is already based on how long you’ve paid, you can login and check. Think I’m about 7 years shy of the finishing post

Cheers Mon, just checked and as long I pay in 3 more years before 2046, I can expect to receive £230.25 from February 2047!

Slow and steady on that one fella


RE: State pension age - Protheroe - 07-21-2025

(07-21-2025, 07:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The former statement makes no sense 

Over £250bn has been taken from us all in the last 20 years, and that figure grows every single year. What doesn't make sense about that?

What doesn't make sense about pension funds dumping UK equities when the Dividend Tax credit went? You know, the same equities Rachel is desperate to get pension funds to invest in these days? It's just another Labour FAFO moment - but on a grand scale. Brown was a fucking idiot. Don't even get me started on his gold sales.


RE: State pension age - greetsgreenbaggie - 07-22-2025

(07-21-2025, 05:51 PM)HugeHons Wrote: Talking to a mate at work who will receive his State Pension from October. He’s worked full-time since 16 ( 50 years). He’s been told he won’t get a full state pension because he was ‘contracted out’ for a few years. He can’t afford to retire for another 5 or so years as his Private Pensions are not worth much ( despite him contracting out), admittedly he doesn’t know much about pensions. My lazy brother, on the other hand, is 54, probably worked 6 years full time since he left school, hasn’t worked at all for the last 7 years and he will receive a full state pension. His partner and he claim for everything going with no intention of working.

Your brother is a massive part of the problem.


RE: State pension age - Ted Maul - 07-22-2025

(07-21-2025, 04:08 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote:
(07-21-2025, 03:35 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(07-21-2025, 02:55 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: I don't think there's many folk my age I speak to who even think about getting a state pension.

If you're not making private provisions for yourself in your retirement (if you get one that is) then you're playing a very risky game.

I suspect it’ll exist in some format because without it you’ll end up with absolute chaos society wise. It may well, of course, become means tested

Can’t see how they can deny anyone who’s paid NI for 40+ years, a state pension, maybe if you’ve not paid in enough you get a reduced amount on a sliding scale would be a fair compromise.
There’s lazy cunts my age (46) who will get a state pension having paid sweet FA into the system, that’s where some of problem lies, along with people living longer etc etc.

I'm in my thirties and have more than enough to survive comfortably regardless of my NI contributions. I'd have no issues paying into a pot for 40 years and not claiming a penny back providing it's spent in a way that benefits those who need it most.


RE: State pension age - SW4Baggie - 07-22-2025

(07-22-2025, 07:11 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-21-2025, 04:08 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote:
(07-21-2025, 03:35 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(07-21-2025, 02:55 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: I don't think there's many folk my age I speak to who even think about getting a state pension.

If you're not making private provisions for yourself in your retirement (if you get one that is) then you're playing a very risky game.

I suspect it’ll exist in some format because without it you’ll end up with absolute chaos society wise. It may well, of course, become means tested

Can’t see how they can deny anyone who’s paid NI for 40+ years, a state pension, maybe if you’ve not paid in enough you get a reduced amount on a sliding scale would be a fair compromise.
There’s lazy cunts my age (46) who will get a state pension having paid sweet FA into the system, that’s where some of problem lies, along with people living longer etc etc.

I'm in my thirties and have more than enough to survive comfortably regardless of my NI contributions. I'd have no issues paying into a pot for 40 years and not claiming a penny back providing it's spent in a way that benefits those who need it most.

I agree with this - for me, the measure of how advanced a society is is how well it cares for those less fortunate and most vulnerable.

The issue that I have with the UK's welfare system is just how poor it is; in a quest for equality it gives too little too everyone, and those that pay the most in are usually completely frozen out of receiving anything should they need it. For example, I'm nearly 40 and have never been unemployed however should I lose my job I would not be eligible for any support due to savings, and I may still have to attend work coaching and appointments... Added to that, should the worst happen, I'd likely be at the very bottom of any support list due to being male and without children, and with retirement 25+ years away, it's unlikely I'll receive enough return on what I've paid in to keep the lights on in an evening.  This is on top of paying for private medical insurance, paying into a private pension, and in my final months in Birmingham, having to drive my own bloody rubbish and recycling to a tip in a different authority!

If I could rely on the system to come to my aid should I need it, I'd have no issue with paying in, but it doesn't and won't - this is why I think there's so much grief given to those who are considered to just sit on their arses all day and take a handout.


RE: State pension age - Borin' Baggie - 07-22-2025

(07-21-2025, 10:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-21-2025, 07:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The former statement makes no sense 

Over £250bn has been taken from us all in the last 20 years, and that figure grows every single year. What doesn't make sense about that?

What doesn't make sense about pension funds dumping UK equities when the Dividend Tax credit went? You know, the same equities Rachel is desperate to get pension funds to invest in these days? It's just another Labour FAFO moment - but on a grand scale. Brown was a fucking idiot. Don't even get me started on his gold sales.

Nice selective quoting to cut out where I explained why what you said makes no sense.

You are literally complaining about something that applies to current pensioners and therefore has no relevance to why future pensioners will be worse off because it gives you a chance to bash Labour, conveniently turning a blind eye at the disastrous policy decisions made in the 1980s and early 1990s that are the root cause of why people feel they cannot put more money from their income into their retirement pots.


RE: State pension age - Protheroe - 07-22-2025

(07-22-2025, 08:34 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-21-2025, 10:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-21-2025, 07:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The former statement makes no sense 

Over £250bn has been taken from us all in the last 20 years, and that figure grows every single year. What doesn't make sense about that?

What doesn't make sense about pension funds dumping UK equities when the Dividend Tax credit went? You know, the same equities Rachel is desperate to get pension funds to invest in these days? It's just another Labour FAFO moment - but on a grand scale. Brown was a fucking idiot. Don't even get me started on his gold sales.

Nice selective quoting to cut out where I explained why what you said makes no sense.

You are literally complaining about something that applies to current pensioners and therefore has no relevance to why future pensioners will be worse off because it gives you a chance to bash Labour, conveniently turning a blind eye at the disastrous policy decisions made in the 1980s and early 1990s that are the root cause of why people feel they cannot put more money from their income into their retirement pots.

What? I have no idea why you think Brown's tax raid only applies to current pensioners. It applies to me, you, anyone at all who has an investment in UK shares via a pension fund. We are and will continue to lose out.

And Reeves wonders why UK equities have been dumped by pension funds, and can't think of how she might get them investing in the UK again. I have an idea. Reverse the idiot's raid.

I have no idea how Brown gets such a free pass from so many people, he was a complete liability for 13 years.

(07-22-2025, 08:08 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I agree with this - for me, the measure of how advanced a society is is how well it cares for those less fortunate and most vulnerable.

The issue that I have with the UK's welfare system is just how poor it is; in a quest for equality it gives too little too everyone, and those that pay the most in are usually completely frozen out of receiving anything should they need it. For example, I'm nearly 40 and have never been unemployed however should I lose my job I would not be eligible for any support due to savings, and I may still have to attend work coaching and appointments... Added to that, should the worst happen, I'd likely be at the very bottom of any support list due to being male and without children, and with retirement 25+ years away, it's unlikely I'll receive enough return on what I've paid in to keep the lights on in an evening.  This is on top of paying for private medical insurance, paying into a private pension, and in my final months in Birmingham, having to drive my own bloody rubbish and recycling to a tip in a different authority!

If I could rely on the system to come to my aid should I need it, I'd have no issue with paying in, but it doesn't and won't - this is why I think there's so much grief given to those who are considered to just sit on their arses all day and take a handout.

You all might care very much in thirty years time when you realise everything you've saved will be taxed and means tested to the limit. Those who've never saved will need to be looked after by the state (taxpayers like you). Others will benefit from an unfunded public sector pension (£2.5 Trillion and counting).

If you think intergenerational inequality is a problem now, just wait for Pensions Apartheid.


RE: State pension age - Borin' Baggie - 07-22-2025

1997 was 28 years ago, it applies to current pensioners as the vast majority will have had pension pots covered by those changes. This is a comparison between current pensioners and future pensioners, therefore it's moot. How can something that applies to current pensioners be the cause for the discrepancy for future pensioners? That makes no sense.

The actual problem is people not putting enough money into their pension pots in their early career and the reason for that is they cannot afford to because of short-sighted infrastructure decisions that are coming home to roost.

And it's rich that you're trying to levy the blame here as starting in 1997 completely ignoring the infrastructure deficiencies can be traced to decisions made prior to that, under Thatcher especially as her governments squandered the golden opportunity for infrastructure renewal and development over the 1980s.