WBAUnofficial
HS2 - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: HS2 (/showthread.php?tid=37873)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: HS2 - Ted Maul - 06-18-2025

(06-18-2025, 01:27 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 01:09 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A slightly faster train to nearly London. Money would have been better spent building a standard parallel line to the WCLM to alleviate some of the capacity issues.

4-tracking Rugby-Wolverhampton would dwarf the cost of HS2 and be significantly more disruptive for the same capacity benefits and little scope for fixing other cities which HS2 at least offers in theory if they decide to actually build it in full at some point. Realistically the only practical 4-tracking is between Stechford and Berkswell where works were started prior to WWII already, that doesn't address the issues into New Street, congestion into Wolverhampton and the shitshow that is Coventry and it's also reliant on HS2 to enable capacity to be relieved to mitigate the disruption to services.

I was only complaining, I didn't want any practical solutions, thank you very much.

Nothing like an expert to make one feel well and truly told.

Haven't we had enough of experts?!


RE: HS2 - Tom Joad - 06-18-2025

Whatever the plan was, it has ended up the equivalent of building half a bridge for all the money. I spend a good portion of working time being held up in temporary lights watching numerous bored workers studying their mobiles while nothing seems to be happening. A licence to print money for Boris's pals.
People would have had a totally different viewpoint had the then government been honest and said it was about capacity, not high speed, and then took some interest in actually getting it done and done properly.


RE: HS2 - SW4Baggie - 06-18-2025

(06-18-2025, 01:09 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A slightly faster train to nearly London. Money would have been better spent building a standard parallel line to the WCLM to alleviate some of the capacity issues.

4-tracking Rugby-Wolverhampton would dwarf the cost of HS2 and be significantly more disruptive for the same capacity benefits and little scope for fixing other cities which HS2 at least offers in theory if they decide to actually build it in full at some point. Realistically the only practical 4-tracking is between Stechford and Berkswell where works were started prior to WWII already, that doesn't address the issues into New Street, congestion into Wolverhampton and the shitshow that is Coventry and it's also reliant on HS2 to enable capacity to be relieved to mitigate the disruption to services.

I was only complaining, I didn't want any practical solutions, thank you very much.

Big Grin Big Grin


RE: HS2 - Josh1873 - 06-18-2025

I didn't realise getting tickets to a steam train would be a joke to some, but here we are! If it's sad, so be it, I'm happy! Big Grin


RE: HS2 - Morley - 06-18-2025

(06-18-2025, 12:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A slightly faster train to nearly London. Money would have been better spent building a standard parallel line to the WCLM to alleviate some of the capacity issues.

4-tracking Rugby-Wolverhampton would dwarf the cost of HS2 and be significantly more disruptive for the same capacity benefits and little scope for fixing other cities which HS2 at least offers in theory if they decide to actually build it in full at some point. Realistically the only practical 4-tracking is between Stechford and Berkswell where works were started prior to WWII already, that doesn't address the issues into New Street, congestion into Wolverhampton and the shitshow that is Coventry and it's also reliant on HS2 to enable capacity to be relieved to mitigate the disruption to services.

Would a standard railway on the HS2 route be cheaper than the HS2?


RE: HS2 - Borin' Baggie - 06-18-2025

(06-18-2025, 03:25 PM)Morley Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A slightly faster train to nearly London. Money would have been better spent building a standard parallel line to the WCLM to alleviate some of the capacity issues.

4-tracking Rugby-Wolverhampton would dwarf the cost of HS2 and be significantly more disruptive for the same capacity benefits and little scope for fixing other cities which HS2 at least offers in theory if they decide to actually build it in full at some point. Realistically the only practical 4-tracking is between Stechford and Berkswell where works were started prior to WWII already, that doesn't address the issues into New Street, congestion into Wolverhampton and the shitshow that is Coventry and it's also reliant on HS2 to enable capacity to be relieved to mitigate the disruption to services.

Would a standard railway on the HS2 route be cheaper than the HS2?

Probably the same cost, the effect of the wider loading guage is going to be minimal to none. The biggest issues with HS2 have been abysmal project governance and planning and constantly changing the plan (like a new tunnel under the Chiltern). You might get some benefit from being more flexible with the route not needing to be as straight but that's it.


RE: HS2 - KRO - 06-18-2025

HS2 will open capacity on lines already full to capacity.
And will allow us to expand Adderley Park Station to be used for The Sports Quarter as well as the Tram


RE: HS2 - SW4Baggie - 06-18-2025

(06-18-2025, 03:49 PM)KRO Wrote: HS2 will open capacity on lines already full to capacity.
And will allow us to expand Adderley Park Station to be used for The Sports Quarter as well as the Tram

I hope they’re preparing for the 240,000 fans attending your Champs League games Big Grin

(06-18-2025, 03:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 03:25 PM)Morley Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A slightly faster train to nearly London. Money would have been better spent building a standard parallel line to the WCLM to alleviate some of the capacity issues.

4-tracking Rugby-Wolverhampton would dwarf the cost of HS2 and be significantly more disruptive for the same capacity benefits and little scope for fixing other cities which HS2 at least offers in theory if they decide to actually build it in full at some point. Realistically the only practical 4-tracking is between Stechford and Berkswell where works were started prior to WWII already, that doesn't address the issues into New Street, congestion into Wolverhampton and the shitshow that is Coventry and it's also reliant on HS2 to enable capacity to be relieved to mitigate the disruption to services.

Would a standard railway on the HS2 route be cheaper than the HS2?

Probably the same cost, the effect of the wider loading guage is going to be minimal to none. The biggest issues with HS2 have been abysmal project governance and planning and constantly changing the plan (like a new tunnel under the Chiltern). You might get some benefit from being more flexible with the route not needing to be as straight but that's it.

If I’ve learned anything from this board recently is that spending money doesn’t guarantee success Big Grin


RE: HS2 - KRO - 06-18-2025

It’s a fact.
However many attend Blues games there’ll be people attending it regularly for gigs and other sports. It’s a huge lift for the West Midlands and Brum economy as a whole, and of course for Blues on the footballing side of things


RE: HS2 - Vinebaggie - 06-18-2025

(06-18-2025, 03:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 03:25 PM)Morley Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A slightly faster train to nearly London. Money would have been better spent building a standard parallel line to the WCLM to alleviate some of the capacity issues.

4-tracking Rugby-Wolverhampton would dwarf the cost of HS2 and be significantly more disruptive for the same capacity benefits and little scope for fixing other cities which HS2 at least offers in theory if they decide to actually build it in full at some point. Realistically the only practical 4-tracking is between Stechford and Berkswell where works were started prior to WWII already, that doesn't address the issues into New Street, congestion into Wolverhampton and the shitshow that is Coventry and it's also reliant on HS2 to enable capacity to be relieved to mitigate the disruption to services.

Would a standard railway on the HS2 route be cheaper than the HS2?

Probably the same cost, the effect of the wider loading guage is going to be minimal to none. The biggest issues with HS2 have been abysmal project governance and planning and constantly changing the plan (like a new tunnel under the Chiltern). You might get some benefit from being more flexible with the route not needing to be as straight but that's it.

Don't know anything about HS2 but the issue on these big public sector projects tends to be weak, poor, leadership and governance.  I worked for a while on the aircraft carrier alliance a project that went from a budget of £3.9 Billion, included about £500M contingency, to a final bill of £6.2 Billion and both carriers are still plagued by technical problems.  It was basically run by a committee of people from BAe, Thales and Babcock who couldn't agree on anything, absolute disaster, doesn't seem much better on HS2.