WBAUnofficial
Does the government have a role in promoting healthy eating? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Does the government have a role in promoting healthy eating? (/showthread.php?tid=37693)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Does the government have a role in promoting healthy eating? - CarlosCorbewrong - 05-19-2025

(05-18-2025, 10:44 PM)Squid Wrote:
(05-18-2025, 09:10 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Back in the day fast food was less accessible and people were thinner. If you did have any you had to get off your arse and go for it mostly. Now fast food is in abundance in every town and all you have to do to get it from 90% of outlets is pick up your phone then answer the door. As a result people are fatter

We're in an obesogenic environment. Weight loss jabs probably will help, they've been genuinely life changing for a few people I know.

It's a complex problem but I'm not sure what it has to do with a failing local NHS trust. Heartlands and GHH were taken over by UHB because they were broke and it would seem that it is still the case.

The Trust returned to surplus, recurrently, pre pandemic and post takeover of BHH, GHH and Solihull.


RE: Does the government have a role in promoting healthy eating? - Lurker#3 - 05-19-2025

Sugar isn't the enemy, neither is fat.

Ultra processed, low quality foods are. They are hyper palatable and too easy to overconsume.

It's really hard to over eat whole foods. Get a whole cooked chicken, eat it, then see if you fancy anything else to eat. I would very much doubt it. That would be 1000-1500lcals depending on the size of the bird. Now I could eat a large big Mac meal and 20 nuggets and my brain would still be telling me to eat again soon.

The issue is the general populations lack of food knowledge and perceived lack of time to cook. The government also won't push a whole food revolution because so much money would be stripped from the economy in terms of food production and people would moan and whine about lack of choice and convenience.

It's a sad state of affairs that science is the best it's ever been keeping us alive and as a population our lifestyles are the worst they've ever been.


RE: Does the government have a role in promoting healthy eating? - Lurker#3 - 05-19-2025




RE: Does the government have a role in promoting healthy eating? - SW4Baggie - 05-19-2025

(05-19-2025, 09:57 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Sugar isn't the enemy, neither is fat.

Ultra processed, low quality foods are. They are hyper palatable and too easy to overconsume.

It's really hard to over eat whole foods. Get a whole cooked chicken, eat it, then see if you fancy anything else to eat. I would very much doubt it. That would be 1000-1500lcals depending on the size of the bird. Now I could eat a large big Mac meal and 20 nuggets and my brain would still be telling me to eat again soon.

The issue is the general populations lack of food knowledge and perceived lack of time to cook. The government also won't push a whole food revolution because so much money would be stripped from the economy in terms of food production and people would moan and whine about lack of choice and convenience.

It's a sad state of affairs that science is the best it's ever been keeping us alive and as a population our lifestyles are the worst they've ever been.

Exactly this.

But you have to dig deeper to find a cure… UPFs are popular because they’re cheaper, faster and more convenient than whole foods. We live in an age where folks have less time to shop, cook, and eat. 

Try raising a couple kids, with two parents in full time employment who are commuting a few times a week, and cooking fresh meals every day. Add in the time taken to plan and shop and it’s soon pretty obvious why people are gaining weight.

Southern Europeans are healthier because they have more free time, they often live closer to relatives or in multigenerational homes and every block has a fresh grocer, butcher and baker. 

We can’t fix our poor relationship with food until we give people the opportunity to cook and eat better.


RE: Does the government have a role in promoting healthy eating? - Fido - 05-19-2025

I think a lot of people feel they have less time but if you took out pissing about on your phone, social media et al, then you’ll probably find there is time. Personal priorities trump those for the greater population.


RE: Does the government have a role in promoting healthy eating? - SW4Baggie - 05-19-2025

(05-19-2025, 07:48 PM)Fido Wrote: I think a lot of people feel they have less time but if you took out pissing about on your phone, social media et al, then you’ll probably find there is time. Personal priorities trump those for the greater population.

Sadly Fido the stats don’t really back that up.

Even today, households where one parent doesn’t work spend 70 minutes daily preparing meals, in houses where both adults work it’s just over half that. 

You also see these households spending far greater amounts of their disposable income on food out of home (admittedly that’s probably down to having the means to) but it leads to less control over diet.


RE: Does the government have a role in promoting healthy eating? - Lurker#3 - 05-19-2025

(05-19-2025, 07:37 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-19-2025, 09:57 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Sugar isn't the enemy, neither is fat.

Ultra processed, low quality foods are. They are hyper palatable and too easy to overconsume.

It's really hard to over eat whole foods. Get a whole cooked chicken, eat it, then see if you fancy anything else to eat. I would very much doubt it. That would be 1000-1500lcals depending on the size of the bird. Now I could eat a large big Mac meal and 20 nuggets and my brain would still be telling me to eat again soon.

The issue is the general populations lack of food knowledge and perceived lack of time to cook. The government also won't push a whole food revolution because so much money would be stripped from the economy in terms of food production and people would moan and whine about lack of choice and convenience.

It's a sad state of affairs that science is the best it's ever been keeping us alive and as a population our lifestyles are the worst they've ever been.

Exactly this.

But you have to dig deeper to find a cure… UPFs are popular because they’re cheaper, faster and more convenient than whole foods. We live in an age where folks have less time to shop, cook, and eat. 

Try raising a couple kids, with two parents in full time employment who are commuting a few times a week, and cooking fresh meals every day. Add in the time taken to plan and shop and it’s soon pretty obvious why people are gaining weight.

Southern Europeans are healthier because they have more free time, they often live closer to relatives or in multigenerational homes and every block has a fresh grocer, butcher and baker. 

We can’t fix our poor relationship with food until we give people the opportunity to cook and eat better.

Whilst I understand this argument I can't agree. 

A chick pea and spinach curry and micro rice, made from tins, packets and frozen stuff, whilst minimally processed, would cost less than a quid a head and from start to finish would be on the table in less than 15 mins. Much quicker than nuggets, chips and beans and cheaper. 

Food education is a massive problem, but also our Germanic relationship with food. We sit, scran and go. We don't value that time to exist together as families or communities, we don't factor in food as part of our social lives, so we get a very disordered mentality towards our meal times.


RE: Does the government have a role in promoting healthy eating? - Fido - 05-19-2025

(05-19-2025, 08:20 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-19-2025, 07:48 PM)Fido Wrote: I think a lot of people feel they have less time but if you took out pissing about on your phone, social media et al, then you’ll probably find there is time. Personal priorities trump those for the greater population.

Sadly Fido the stats don’t really back that up.

Even today, households where one parent doesn’t work spend 70 minutes daily preparing meals, in houses where both adults work it’s just over half that. 

You also see these households spending far greater amounts of their disposable income on food out of home (admittedly that’s probably down to having the means to) but it leads to less control over diet.

Don’t get me wrong, there will be a lot of people caught in that trap but this is not the complete picture and time can be more of an excuse than an actual reason. As Lurker says it has a lot to do with us as a nation in that eating is more of a task than a pleasure. And if my missus didn’t enjoy cooking so much I’m sure I’d fall into the same hole.


RE: Does the government have a role in promoting healthy eating? - SW4Baggie - 05-19-2025

(05-19-2025, 08:20 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(05-19-2025, 07:37 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-19-2025, 09:57 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Sugar isn't the enemy, neither is fat.

Ultra processed, low quality foods are. They are hyper palatable and too easy to overconsume.

It's really hard to over eat whole foods. Get a whole cooked chicken, eat it, then see if you fancy anything else to eat. I would very much doubt it. That would be 1000-1500lcals depending on the size of the bird. Now I could eat a large big Mac meal and 20 nuggets and my brain would still be telling me to eat again soon.

The issue is the general populations lack of food knowledge and perceived lack of time to cook. The government also won't push a whole food revolution because so much money would be stripped from the economy in terms of food production and people would moan and whine about lack of choice and convenience.

It's a sad state of affairs that science is the best it's ever been keeping us alive and as a population our lifestyles are the worst they've ever been.

Exactly this.

But you have to dig deeper to find a cure… UPFs are popular because they’re cheaper, faster and more convenient than whole foods. We live in an age where folks have less time to shop, cook, and eat. 

Try raising a couple kids, with two parents in full time employment who are commuting a few times a week, and cooking fresh meals every day. Add in the time taken to plan and shop and it’s soon pretty obvious why people are gaining weight.

Southern Europeans are healthier because they have more free time, they often live closer to relatives or in multigenerational homes and every block has a fresh grocer, butcher and baker. 

We can’t fix our poor relationship with food until we give people the opportunity to cook and eat better.

Whilst I understand this argument I can't agree. 

A chick pea and spinach curry and micro rice, made from tins, packets and frozen stuff, whilst minimally processed, would cost less than a quid a head and from start to finish would be on the table in less than 15 mins. Much quicker than nuggets, chips and beans and cheaper. 

Food education is a massive problem, but also our Germanic relationship with food. We sit, scran and go. We don't value that time to exist together as families or communities, we don't factor in food as part of our social lives, so we get a very disordered mentality towards our meal times.

I don’t disagree with you lurker, but in the time that you’ve taken the lid off one of those cans I’ve thrown the chips and the nuggets in the air fryer… it’s not about the amount of outright time, it’s the amount of active cooking time. 20 mins in the oven on a baking tray is more convenient than 15 minutes chopping, stirring and cooking.

We also live in a time where many of the people buying processed foods have little disposable income to experiment - if the meal turns out badly, there’s no money for a second one. You know where you are with chips and a microwave lasagna.

The rest of the post is spot on.


RE: Does the government have a role in promoting healthy eating? - Pipkins - 05-20-2025

(05-19-2025, 07:37 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-19-2025, 09:57 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Sugar isn't the enemy, neither is fat.

Ultra processed, low quality foods are. They are hyper palatable and too easy to overconsume.

It's really hard to over eat whole foods. Get a whole cooked chicken, eat it, then see if you fancy anything else to eat. I would very much doubt it. That would be 1000-1500lcals depending on the size of the bird. Now I could eat a large big Mac meal and 20 nuggets and my brain would still be telling me to eat again soon.

The issue is the general populations lack of food knowledge and perceived lack of time to cook. The government also won't push a whole food revolution because so much money would be stripped from the economy in terms of food production and people would moan and whine about lack of choice and convenience.

It's a sad state of affairs that science is the best it's ever been keeping us alive and as a population our lifestyles are the worst they've ever been.

Exactly this.

But you have to dig deeper to find a cure… UPFs are popular because they’re cheaper, faster and more convenient than whole foods. We live in an age where folks have less time to shop, cook, and eat. 

Try raising a couple kids, with two parents in full time employment who are commuting a few times a week, and cooking fresh meals every day. Add in the time taken to plan and shop and it’s soon pretty obvious why people are gaining weight.

Southern Europeans are healthier because they have more free time, they often live closer to relatives or in multigenerational homes and every block has a fresh grocer, butcher and baker. 

We can’t fix our poor relationship with food until we give people the opportunity to cook and eat better.

I agree with your comments 
Why are the reasons both parents work compared to those in EU?
Mortgaged up to the eyeballs & in debt paying for material things they have been convinced will make their life better