WBAUnofficial
Bartley… - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Bartley… (/showthread.php?tid=37217)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Bartley… - Stillclem4england - 04-09-2025

Has any single player not regressed under Mowbray? Certainly none have improved. Says it all.


RE: Bartley… - Sliced - 04-09-2025

Keeping Bartley is a lazy stop gap for planning for the future. We need to get rid. The number of times he steps away from his attackers and makes no effort to block shots in criminal. I think some see the fact that he's a tall centre back who's good with his head, points about a bit to look like a leader and block out the problems, but he's a liability. Week after week there's mistakes, and on the rare occasions that one of his footballing errors don't cost or almost cost us a goal he loses his head and does something stupid. I know he got a red for shoving someone in the face, but that's not the only red he should have had in the past few weeks.

Whenever the an attacker with the ball at feet gets near him I just think "we're fucked", and too often recently it's been the case.

(04-09-2025, 08:07 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Has any single player not regressed under Mowbray? Certainly none have improved. Says it all.

Maybe Mowatt


RE: Bartley… - Birdman1811 - 04-09-2025

It's time for Bartley to go, good servant and done well overall, but he's declining now and we need to move on.


RE: Bartley… - Tom Joad - 04-09-2025

(04-09-2025, 08:33 AM)Sliced Wrote: Keeping Bartley is a lazy stop gap for planning for the future. We need to get rid. The number of times he steps away from his attackers and makes no effort to block shots in criminal. I think some see the fact that he's a tall centre back who's good with his head, points about a bit to look like a leader and block out the problems, but he's a liability. Week after week there's mistakes, and on the rare occasions that one of his footballing errors don't cost or almost cost us a goal he loses his head and does something stupid. I know he got a red for shoving someone in the face, but that's not the only red he should have had in the past few weeks.

Whenever the an attacker with the ball at feet gets near him I just think "we're fucked", and too often recently it's been the case.

(04-09-2025, 08:07 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Has any single player not regressed under Mowbray? Certainly none have improved. Says it all.

Maybe Mowatt

Exactly Sliced. Bartley needs replacing ASAP.


RE: Bartley… - Lurker#3 - 04-09-2025

Bartley is not the issue, never has been and on the right money never will be.

He's in the top few percentile for aerial duels won, and whilst our defending is largely about shape, and as a team we make very few tackles and challenges, when he does get dribbled at he's in the top few percent for successful tackles and challenges. Not to mention his brilliant passing stats contrary to popular (and misguided) beliefs.

People seem to think Bartley is very much the emperors new clothes but the fact is the opposite. They pin much of their frustration on him because he is an easy target as he's been here so long, and through a turbulent few years. Barts should play 15-30 games next year, mostly from the bench if we get the recruitment right to replace Semi. Espeiclaly if the Semi replacement is 22-25 and a bit wet behind the ears still. As Taylor, Heggem and a new younger CB would need the guidance and experience of somebody like Barts.


RE: Bartley… - HLS - 04-09-2025

Goodness me. I get that tensions are high but calling out Bartley is harsh. He's had a good season imo.

There's only two people to blame for last night and neither of them are Bartley.


RE: Bartley… - Cheshire East Baggie - 04-09-2025

(04-09-2025, 08:50 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Bartley is not the issue, never has been and on the right money never will be.

He's in the top few percentile for aerial duels won, and whilst our defending is largely about shape, and as a team we make very few tackles and challenges, when he does get dribbled at he's in the top few percent for successful tackles and challenges. Not to mention his brilliant passing stats contrary to popular (and misguided) beliefs.

People seem to think Bartley is very much the emperors new clothes but the fact is the opposite. They pin much of their frustration on him because he is an easy target as he's been here so long, and through a turbulent few years. Barts should play 15-30 games next year, mostly from the bench if we get the recruitment right to replace Semi. Espeiclaly if the Semi replacement is 22-25 and a bit wet behind the ears still. As Taylor, Heggem and a new younger CB would need the guidance and experience of somebody like Barts.

You are wrong on this one, Lurk. Being not quite good enough for a significant number of the games you play is very costly. When he's good he can be OK in a solid defence. When the muck and bullets are flying he's not your man. Offering him an extension would be a big mistake.


RE: Bartley… - Lurker#3 - 04-09-2025

That's the thing about opinions, Chesh. I don't think he is "not quite good enough for a significant number for games". He's been out best CB this year. Heggem will develop to be a very good CB over the next year or so I have no doubt. But right now every CB we have play better with Bart's, that's not a coincidence.

When the muck and bullets are flying he's exactly who you want. He makes more blocks than anyone (apart from Diakite as he's usually brought on to hold on to something) and head and kicks everything away in terms of clearances.

I do agree though that we should have a first choice, younger CB partnership ideally, and Barts and Taylor should dip in and out based on form or game situation.


RE: Bartley… - Sliced - 04-09-2025

Bartley has not been our best cb this year. That’s insane. Heggem is head and shoulders above the rest.


RE: Bartley… - Lurker#3 - 04-09-2025

(04-09-2025, 09:39 AM)Sliced Wrote: Bartley has not been our best cb this year. That’s insane. Heggem is head and shoulders above the rest.

Not insane mate. He made less errors, won a bigger percentage of his duels and each defensive partnership without him has looked more shaky. Obviously the last one if purely opinion and subjective.